Johns Manville vs Owens Corning: Payouts, Proof, and Filing

The Johns Manville and Owens Corning asbestos trust claims process runs on the same legal framework but pays out at different rates: the Manville trust currently pays 5.1% of a claim’s scheduled value, the Owens Corning sub-fund pays 4.7%, and the Fibreboard sub-fund (part of the Owens Corning trust) pays 3.7%.1Manville Trust. Manville Trust Quarterly Report – Third Quarter 20252Owens Corning/Fibreboard Asbestos Trust. Owens Corning / Fibreboard Asbestos Trust If your exposure history involves products from both companies, you can file with both trusts, and payment from one does not bar payment from the other.

What Each Trust Actually Pays

The “payment percentage” is the fraction of a claim’s assigned value the trust hands over. Trusts keep this well below 100% so money remains for future claimants who haven’t been diagnosed yet, and the trustees revisit the number periodically based on the trust’s finances.

The real-money impact is easier to see with a specific figure. A mesothelioma claim assigned the Manville trust’s $350,000 scheduled value pays $17,850. That same $350,000 scheduled value would yield $16,450 through the Owens Corning sub-fund and $12,950 through the Fibreboard sub-fund. So the difference between trusts is meaningful but not enormous, and it doesn’t drive where you file: you file with the trust whose products caused your exposure.

Through September 2025, the Manville trust had liquidated more than 1,027,000 claims and paid out over $5.3 billion, making it one of the longest-running asbestos trusts in the country.1Manville Trust. Manville Trust Quarterly Report – Third Quarter 2025 The Owens Corning/Fibreboard trust was established later, after Owens Corning emerged from Chapter 11 in 2006, and maintains its two separate sub-accounts because Fibreboard was a distinct company Owens Corning acquired.3U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Owens Corning/Fibreboard Asbestos Personal Injury Trust Agreement

Scheduled Values by Disease Level

The payment percentage is applied to a “scheduled value” that depends on the disease. The Manville trust uses eight levels:

  • Level VIII (Mesothelioma): $350,000
  • Level VII (Lung Cancer Two): $95,000
  • Level VI (Lung Cancer One): individual review only, payments averaging around $40,000 and capped at $50,000
  • Level V (Other Cancer): $45,000
  • Level IV (Severe Asbestosis): $95,000
  • Level III (Asbestosis/Pleural Disease): $25,000
  • Level II (Asbestosis/Pleural Disease): $12,000
  • Level I (Other Asbestos Disease): $600 cash discount payment

The Owens Corning/Fibreboard trust uses its own categories and values, set out in that trust’s distribution procedures. Which sub-fund applies depends on whether the exposure came from Owens Corning-branded products (such as Kaylo insulation) or from Fibreboard’s products.

Expedited Review or Individual Review

Both trusts offer two evaluation tracks, and the choice matters.

Expedited review is largely administrative. The trust checks whether your medical evidence and exposure history meet the fixed criteria for a given disease level; if they do, you get the standard scheduled value at the current payment percentage. Most straightforward claims go this route.

Individual review is a closer look at the specifics of your case. It can produce a higher payment than the scheduled value (up to a cap for most levels), but it can also produce a lower one. Some claim types, like Manville’s Level VI lung cancer, only exist under individual review. If your documentation clearly satisfies expedited criteria, expedited review is the more predictable path. Individual review makes sense when your circumstances don’t fit the expedited boxes or when you have reason to believe the scheduled value undersells your claim.

Proving Exposure to Each Company’s Products

Both trusts require the same general categories of documentation: medical records confirming the diagnosis (usually with at least 10 years between first exposure and diagnosis), proof of exposure to that specific company’s asbestos products, a death certificate if the claim is on behalf of someone who has died, and proof of representative capacity if you’re filing for an estate.

Product identification is where claims most often stall, and it’s where the two trusts diverge in practice. General asbestos exposure isn’t enough. For the Manville trust you need to show contact with Johns Manville insulation, roofing, or pipe products. For the Owens Corning trust, that typically means Kaylo pipe and block insulation or other Owens Corning-branded materials. Coworker statements, employment and union records, purchase orders showing which products a workplace used, and sworn exposure histories all help build the connection. If you worked somewhere both companies’ products were present, you have a route to both trusts, but you’ll need evidence tying you to each separately.

Claims are processed in the order received. Timelines range from several months to over a year depending on complexity and whether the trust asks for more documentation.

Filing With Both Trusts

You can file claims with both trusts simultaneously if your exposure history supports it. Each trust operates independently under its own distribution procedures, receiving payment from one has no effect on eligibility with another, and there is no legal cap on the number of trust claims you can pursue.

Trust claims also don’t foreclose lawsuits against solvent defendants that never established trusts. Some of those defendants may argue that trust payments should reduce what they owe, and these “setoff” rules vary by state, so how trust filings interact with litigation is worth reviewing with an attorney before you submit anything.

Secondary Exposure and Wrongful Death

Eligibility isn’t limited to workers who handled asbestos products directly. Family members who developed asbestos-related disease from “take-home” exposure, where fibers came home on a worker’s clothing, skin, or hair, can also qualify. Household members who laundered contaminated work clothes or simply lived with accumulated fibers in carpets, furniture, and ventilation have grounds to file.

When a worker or exposed family member has died from asbestos-related disease, surviving relatives can generally file a wrongful death claim. Each trust has its own estate-claim procedures, and filings typically require a death certificate along with documentation of the personal representative’s authority. State statutes of limitations for wrongful death usually run one to three years from the date of death, so acting promptly protects the claim.

Taxes and Medicare Recovery

Payments from asbestos trusts for personal physical injury or illness are generally excluded from taxable income under Section 104(a)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code, whether the money comes through a settlement, judgment, or trust distribution.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 104 – Compensation for Injuries or Sickness The exclusion covers compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and wrongful death damages.

Two carve-outs are worth knowing. Punitive damages are generally taxable, with a narrow exception when state law only permits punitive damages in a wrongful death action. Any interest that accrues while a payment is pending is taxable as ordinary interest income.

Medicare is the other issue to plan around. If Medicare paid for asbestos-related treatment, it operates as a secondary payer and can seek reimbursement from your trust recovery. That right applies to anyone 65 or older, and to those under 65 receiving Social Security disability benefits, and it reaches claims filed through 524(g) asbestos trusts specifically. If all of your asbestos exposure ended before December 5, 1980, Medicare’s recovery right may not apply, but the burden is on you to prove that cutoff.