Insurance steering is illegal in every state once it crosses from recommendation into coercion, misrepresentation, or interference with your right to choose a repair shop. Insurers can suggest a shop in their network, but they cannot require you to use one, threaten delays or denials if you don’t, or mislead you about what your policy covers. The line between a legal recommendation and illegal steering is the pressure behind it.
How to Recognize Steering
Steering rarely sounds like an outright demand. Adjusters are trained to frame their preferred shops as the path of least resistance. You might hear that going to a non-preferred shop will delay your claim, that the insurer “can’t guarantee” work done elsewhere, or that you’ll end up paying more out of pocket. Some adjusters imply that a shop outside the network won’t meet the insurer’s standards, or that your claim could be denied altogether. These are pressure tactics, not honest advice.
Most insurers run a direct repair program, or DRP. Shops in the DRP agree to the insurer’s pricing, use parts the insurer approves, and streamline the claims process in exchange for a steady flow of referrals. A DRP by itself isn’t the problem. The problem starts when an insurer treats the DRP as mandatory rather than optional.
The Legal Basis for Anti-Steering Rules
The framework behind anti-steering rules comes primarily from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ model regulations, which most states have adopted in some form. The NAIC’s model regulation on property and casualty claims prohibits insurers from requiring you to travel an unreasonable distance to get an estimate or to have your vehicle repaired at a specific shop.1National Association of Insurance Commissioners. NAIC Unfair Property/Casualty Claims Settlement Practices Model Regulation The NAIC’s model act on unfair claims practices also requires insurers who own or mandate a specific repair shop to ensure those repairs meet workmanlike standards.2National Association of Insurance Commissioners. NAIC Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act Model Law
State rules vary in their specifics. Colorado explicitly bans acts of intimidation, coercion, or inducement designed to influence your choice of shop. California prohibits insurers from even suggesting a shop unless the policyholder has first been informed in writing of their right to choose or has specifically asked for a referral. The language shifts from state to state, but the core principle is consistent. You pick the shop.
Your Right to Choose a Repair Shop
This right exists in state insurance regulations across the country and applies whether or not the shop participates in your insurer’s preferred network. Your insurer must cover reasonable and necessary repair costs at the shop you select, provided the charges are in line with what qualified facilities in your area would charge for the same work.
The phrase “reasonable and necessary” is where many disputes land. Insurers sometimes use that language to justify paying less than your chosen shop charges. An insurer’s estimate is an approximation, often written before the vehicle has been fully disassembled and often by someone who isn’t a licensed repair technician.
The NAIC model regulation addresses this directly. If you obtain a written estimate showing that necessary repairs exceed the insurer’s figure, the insurer must either pay the difference or provide the name of at least one shop that will complete the work at the insurer’s estimated price. And if the insurer designates a shop, the insurer bears responsibility for restoring the vehicle to its pre-loss condition at no extra cost to you beyond your deductible.1National Association of Insurance Commissioners. NAIC Unfair Property/Casualty Claims Settlement Practices Model Regulation
Most steering disputes actually play out here. The insurer doesn’t tell you outright that you can’t use your shop. Instead, the estimate comes in lower than what your shop charges, and you’re left to assume you’ll owe the difference. Knowing the insurer has an obligation to reconcile that gap changes the dynamic entirely.
Parts Selection as a Quieter Form of Steering
A subtler form of steering shows up in parts. Your insurer’s estimate may specify aftermarket parts rather than parts made by your vehicle’s original manufacturer. Aftermarket parts are cheaper, which saves the insurer money, but they may not fit as precisely or perform identically to the originals.
Most states require insurers to disclose when aftermarket parts will be used and to list those parts on the repair estimate before work begins. Many states also require that aftermarket parts be at least equal to the original parts in quality, fit, and performance. If an aftermarket part doesn’t meet that standard, or if modifications are needed to make it fit, the insurer typically bears that cost. Some states give you the right to insist on OEM parts while your vehicle is still under its original manufacturer warranty.
Parts quality affects safety and resale value. A car repaired with parts that don’t match the manufacturer’s specifications can have alignment issues, gaps in body panels, or compromised structural integrity. If your insurer’s estimate calls for aftermarket parts and you want OEM replacements, ask for them in writing. In some states you may pay the price difference, but you should know what’s going onto your car before work starts.
What to Do If You’re Being Steered
Tell your adjuster clearly that you’ve chosen your own repair shop. You don’t need to justify the choice. State it as a fact and move on to the logistics of getting your vehicle inspected and repaired.
Then document everything. Save emails, take notes during phone calls with the date and the adjuster’s name, and keep copies of every estimate. If the adjuster says your shop will cost more, that repairs won’t be guaranteed, or that your claim will be delayed, write down exactly what was said and when. That record becomes evidence if you need to escalate.
If the insurer keeps pushing back, refuses to pay a reasonable repair estimate, or follows through on threats to delay your claim, you have several options:
- File a complaint with your state’s Department of Insurance. Every state has an insurance regulator that investigates unfair claims practices. The insurer is typically required to respond within a set timeframe, often 14 to 21 days. These complaints create a paper trail and can trigger broader investigations if the insurer has a pattern of steering.3National Association of Insurance Commissioners. How to File a Complaint and Research Complaints Against Insurance Carriers
- Invoke the appraisal clause in your policy. If the dispute is specifically about repair costs rather than shop choice, each side hires an appraiser, the two select a neutral umpire if they can’t agree, and a decision by any two of the three is binding. It only covers the amount of the loss, not coverage questions.
- Contact your state Attorney General. The consumer protection division can investigate patterns of fraud, deception, or unfair business practices, including systematic steering by insurers.
- Consult an attorney. If you’ve suffered financial harm from steering, such as a botched repair at a preferred shop or an insurer refusing to pay legitimate repair costs, an attorney who handles insurance bad faith claims can evaluate whether you have a case.
Before filing a formal complaint, contact the insurer’s own escalation department. Many disputes resolve once a supervisor reviews the file and recognizes the legal exposure. Don’t let politeness slide into passivity. The right to choose your repair shop is well established, and insurers who violate it face regulatory consequences.