In the 41 states and the District of Columbia that tax wages, an employer is required to withhold state income tax from employee paychecks once the business has a legal connection to the state or has an employee performing work inside its borders. Nine states impose no wage income tax and no withholding duty. Everywhere else, the obligation is not optional, and the person at the company responsible for payroll can be held personally on the hook for money that should have been withheld and was not.
States Where No State Withholding Applies
If your business and all its employees operate entirely within a state that does not tax earned income, there is no state withholding to do. As of 2026, nine states fall into this group: Alaska, Florida, Nevada, New Hampshire, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming. New Hampshire previously taxed interest and dividend income, but that tax was fully repealed for tax years beginning after December 31, 2024, which made it a true no-income-tax state.
Federal withholding for income tax, Social Security, and Medicare still applies in every state. And if even one of your employees works remotely from a state that does tax wages, the rules in the rest of this article can pull you into that state’s system regardless of where your headquarters sits.
What Triggers the Withholding Duty
In the taxing states, the duty attaches once a sufficient legal connection, usually called nexus, exists between the business and the state. Physical presence is the clearest form: an office, a warehouse, a retail location, or any other fixed place of business. Nexus reaches further than that, though. Having a single employee who regularly performs work inside a state’s borders can create a withholding obligation for the employer, whatever state the company calls home.
States use sourcing rules to decide which jurisdiction gets to tax a worker’s pay. The general principle is that income follows the location where the work is physically performed. An employee based at your Chicago office who spends three months on a project site in another state may generate a tax claim from that other state for the wages earned during those three months. Tracking the split, calculating the right amount for each state, and remitting on time is the employer’s job.
Remote Workers and Multi-State Employees
Remote work has taken a formerly niche compliance question and made it routine. When an employee works from home in a state different from where the business is located, many states treat those wages as earned within their borders. How quickly the withholding duty kicks in varies sharply. Some states require withholding after an employee works there for as few as 14 days in a calendar year, others set the threshold at 30 or 60 days, and a handful impose no day-count threshold at all and require withholding from the first dollar earned inside the state.
Roughly 16 states have reciprocal tax agreements with their neighbors. Under those agreements, an employee who lives in one state but commutes to work in another pays income tax only to the home state, and the employer withholds for the state of residence rather than the state where the work happens. Employees typically have to file a certificate of nonresidence with the employer to activate this. Without the certificate, the employer defaults to withholding for the work state.
A few states apply what is known as the convenience-of-the-employer rule. If an employee works remotely from another state for their own convenience rather than because the job requires it, the employer’s home state can still claim the right to tax those wages. New York is the most prominent state enforcing that rule, and it has generated significant controversy since remote work spread. Check each state’s specific stance rather than assuming the physical-work-location rule governs everywhere.
The Rule Only Applies to Employees
State withholding is a duty owed for employees. A worker properly classified as an independent contractor gets paid gross, and the business withholds nothing from those payments. That makes classification one of the highest-stakes calls in payroll, because getting it wrong means the employer owes all the tax that should have been withheld, plus penalties and interest.
Many states use a version of the ABC test, which presumes a worker is an employee unless the business can show the worker is free from its control, performs work outside the company’s usual business, and runs an independent trade or business of the same type. Other states use a common-law test that weighs a longer list of factors and looks heavily at behavioral and financial control. Some states even apply different tests for tax withholding, unemployment insurance, and workers’ compensation. When the classification is genuinely close, treating the worker as an employee is the safer call, because misclassification penalties almost always exceed the cost of withholding.
Registering and Setting Up Withholding
Before withholding a single dollar, you need a state employer identification number from each state where you have a withholding obligation. Registration usually happens through the state’s online business tax portal and asks for your federal EIN, business formation details, and an estimate of your expected payroll. Some states register you for withholding automatically when you register for unemployment insurance; others make you file a separate application.
Then you collect the right withholding certificate from every employee. The federal W-4 governs federal income tax withholding only. Many states use their own version, and the allowances or exemptions an employee claims on the state form can differ from what they claim federally. State tax codes do not always mirror the federal structure, so an employee might claim fewer exemptions at the state level or qualify for state-specific credits. If an employee never submits a state withholding certificate, most states require the employer to withhold at the highest rate, assuming zero exemptions.
From there, you use the employee’s filing status and exemptions to look up the correct amount in the state’s tax tables or formulas, which state revenue departments publish annually. Payroll software automates the calculation, but someone on your team should confirm the software has loaded the current year’s rates, especially after a state legislature changes its brackets or adds new credits.
Bonuses, Commissions, and Other Supplemental Pay
Regular wages are straightforward. Bonuses, commissions, and severance often follow different rules. At the federal level, employers can withhold a flat 22% on supplemental wages up to $1 million. Many states with graduated income taxes offer a similar shortcut: a flat supplemental withholding rate that skips the bracket calculation. Other states require you to aggregate the supplemental payment with the employee’s regular wages and withhold on the combined total, which usually withholds more.
The flat supplemental rate varies by state, and not every state offers one. Payroll that spans multiple states means you need to know each state’s method before cutting bonus checks. Withhold too much and employees get the money back at tax time but feel the smaller check now. Withhold too little and the employee could face a balance due at filing.
Depositing and Reporting What You Withhold
Withholding the money is half the job. Getting it to the state on time is the other half. Every state with an income tax sets a deposit schedule, and the required frequency depends on how much you withhold. State schedules generally follow the same monthly-or-semiweekly pattern the federal system uses, with different dollar thresholds and deposit windows.1IRS.gov. Notice 931 Deposit Requirements for Employment Taxes Most states require electronic filing for these deposits.
On top of deposits, employers file periodic returns, usually quarterly, that reconcile amounts withheld with amounts deposited. At year-end, you issue a W-2 to each employee and send copies to both the Social Security Administration and the appropriate state tax agency.2Internal Revenue Service. Topic No. 752, Filing Forms W-2 and W-3 Many states also require an annual reconciliation transmittal that ties the individual W-2s to your total deposits for the year. Mismatched numbers usually generate a notice, sometimes an audit.
Keep thorough records. Federal law requires employers to maintain documentation of wages paid, deductions taken, hours worked, and pay period dates for each employee.3U.S. Department of Labor. Recordkeeping and Reporting Most states impose their own retention rules on top, often requiring at least three to four years. If a state audits and you cannot produce the records, the burden of proving you withheld correctly falls on you.
What Happens If You Don’t Withhold
The federal Trust Fund Recovery Penalty is the most severe consequence. Because withheld taxes are treated as money the employer holds in trust for the government, a responsible person who willfully fails to collect or deposit those funds can be held personally liable for a penalty equal to the full amount of the unpaid tax.4Internal Revenue Service. Trust Fund Recovery Penalty “Willfully” here does not require bad intent; it means the person voluntarily chose to use the money for something else, such as paying vendors instead of making the deposit.5Internal Revenue Service. Employment Taxes and the Trust Fund Recovery Penalty (TFRP) The IRS can file a federal tax lien or seize personal assets to collect.
State penalties layer on top. Most states charge a percentage-based penalty on late or missing withholding deposits, and many add flat-dollar fines for failure to file the required returns, typically $50 to $250 per late return and higher when the state considers the failure willful. Some states also add daily interest on unpaid balances. Personal liability is what makes payroll tax exposure unusual: it can follow a business owner even after the company shuts down.5Internal Revenue Service. Employment Taxes and the Trust Fund Recovery Penalty (TFRP)