Is a Review an Attest Engagement? Independence and Audit Comparison

Yes, a review is an attest engagement. Under the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants’ standards, a CPA review of your historical financial statements produces a written report that conveys limited assurance, and that assurance is what puts the engagement in the attest category alongside audits and agreed-upon procedures. The practical consequence is twofold: the CPA performing the review must be independent of your company, and the resulting report carries more weight with lenders, investors, and bonding companies than a compilation or a preparation does.

Why a Review Counts as Attest

The AICPA’s Clarified Statements on Standards for Attestation Engagements, at AT-C Section 105, define an attest engagement by five conditions. There has to be a three-party relationship (the CPA, the responsible party, and intended users), appropriate subject matter, suitable criteria against which that subject matter is measured, sufficient appropriate evidence gathered by the CPA, and a written report communicating the level of assurance obtained.1AICPA. AT-C Section 105 – Concepts Common to All Attestation Engagements

A review of historical financial statements checks every box. Management is the responsible party, the financial statements are the subject matter, the applicable reporting framework (usually GAAP) supplies the criteria, the CPA gathers evidence through inquiry and analytical procedures, and the engagement ends with a signed report. Reviews themselves are governed by Statements on Standards for Accounting and Review Services, specifically AR-C Section 90.2AICPA & CIMA. AICPA SSARSs – Currently Effective

The assurance the CPA provides is limited, not reasonable. In the report, that limited assurance is expressed as “negative assurance”: the CPA states that they are not aware of any material modifications that should be made for the financial statements to conform to the applicable reporting framework. That is a narrower statement than an audit opinion, but it is still a professional conclusion backed by evidence. Having a conclusion is what matters for attest status. A compilation, which offers none, sits outside the category for exactly that reason.

The procedures behind the conclusion are lighter than an audit’s. Inquiry means the CPA asks management targeted questions about accounting policies, unusual transactions, and significant judgments. Analytical procedures mean comparing relationships in the numbers, such as this year’s revenue against last year’s, or gross margins against industry norms. When something looks off, the CPA follows up with more questions or additional procedures. There is no confirmation of balances with banks or customers, no testing of internal controls, and no substantive sampling of transactions.

What Independence Means for You

Attest status carries a requirement that shapes who can perform the work. The AICPA Code of Professional Conduct requires the CPA to be independent in both fact and appearance for any auditing or attestation engagement, and a review is an attestation engagement.3AICPA. AICPA Code of Professional Conduct Independence means the CPA has no financial interest in your business, does not make management decisions on your behalf, and has no relationship that a reasonable person would see as compromising objectivity.

Situations that impair independence include making investment decisions for the client, holding custody of the client’s assets, or having a direct financial interest in the business.4AICPA & CIMA. Independence and Conflicts of Interest This is where many small businesses run into trouble. If the same firm handles your bookkeeping, prepares your tax returns, and advises on major financial decisions, you should talk through independence before engaging that firm for a review. Safeguards may be available. In some cases the firm may not be able to perform the review at all, and you will need a separate CPA.

For non-attest services, none of this applies. A CPA who is not independent can still compile or prepare your financial statements. They cannot issue a review report.

How a Review Differs from the Non-Attest Alternatives

Two SSARS services sit below a review and are not attest engagements. Understanding what they are is the fastest way to see why the “attest” label on a review is not a formality.

A compilation, governed by AR-C Section 80, has the CPA help management present financial information in the form of financial statements without performing procedures to verify accuracy or completeness.2AICPA & CIMA. AICPA SSARSs – Currently Effective The CPA reads the statements and considers whether they look appropriate in form and free from obvious material error. That is where the work stops. The compilation report explicitly disclaims any opinion or conclusion, and each page of the statements must carry a notation that no assurance is provided. Because no assurance is conveyed, independence is not required, though a lack of independence has to be disclosed in the report.

A preparation engagement, governed by AR-C Section 70, goes one step further down.2AICPA & CIMA. AICPA SSARSs – Currently Effective The CPA helps prepare the statements and delivers them, and that is it. No report of any kind. Independence is not required, and a lack of it does not have to be disclosed. Preparation is well suited for internal use or for situations where no third party is asking for CPA-level assurance.

If a bank asks for “CPA-prepared financial statements,” pin down whether they mean a compilation with a report or a preparation without one. The two look similar from the outside but differ in deliverable, cost, and formality.

Where a Review Sits Against an Audit

An audit is the other main attest service on historical financial statements, and it provides the highest level of assurance a CPA can offer. Audits are governed by Generally Accepted Auditing Standards, and the CPA expresses a positive opinion that the statements are presented fairly in all material respects.5Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AU Section 150 – Generally Accepted Auditing Standards The procedures are much broader than a review’s: the CPA tests account balances, sends confirmations to third parties, evaluates internal controls, and assesses fraud risk.

A review’s limited assurance sits below that bar by design. Reviews typically take one to three weeks; audits run two to six weeks or longer depending on the company’s complexity. Fees follow. A review generally costs a fraction of what an audit costs for a comparable business.

The choice between the two usually is not yours to make freely. Lenders, investors, bonding companies, and regulators tend to specify what they want. If a loan covenant calls for audited financial statements, a review will not satisfy it. If the covenant calls for reviewed statements, an audit is more than you need to buy. Read the agreement first.

Picking the Right Level

The four SSARS and audit services form a clear hierarchy. Audits give reasonable assurance and a positive opinion, and the CPA must be independent. Reviews give limited assurance and a negative-assurance conclusion, and the CPA must be independent. Compilations give no assurance, produce a report that says so, and do not require independence (though a lack of it is disclosed). Preparations give no assurance, produce no report at all, and do not require independence.

The review is the only one of the four that combines attest status with a cost well below an audit. That middle position is the whole point of the service. It gives a lender or investor a meaningful professional conclusion without putting a full audit’s procedural weight on a company that does not need one. If a third party is asking for attest-level work from your CPA, a review is the minimum engagement that qualifies.