No federal law requires an employer to offer a 401(k) plan. Whether a 401(k) is required by law depends entirely on the state: the federal government leaves the decision to employers, but more than a dozen states now require businesses without a qualified retirement plan to enroll their workers in a state-run program. If a plan does exist, federal rules kick in about how it must be run, and newer plans face automatic-enrollment requirements under the SECURE Act 2.0.
Federal Law Does Not Require a 401(k)
The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) is the main federal law governing workplace retirement plans, but it only sets standards for plans an employer voluntarily creates. ERISA covers fiduciary responsibilities, disclosure rules, and reporting requirements once a plan exists.1U.S. Department of Labor. FAQs About Retirement Plans and ERISA Nothing in it compels a business to set one up.
Internal Revenue Code Section 401(k) works the same way. It defines the tax advantages of these plans and lays out qualification requirements, but nothing in the statute forces an employer to establish one.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 401 – Qualified Pension, Profit-Sharing, and Stock Bonus Plans Federal policy uses tax incentives to encourage employers to offer plans rather than penalties to punish those who don’t. A business with no retirement plan faces no federal fine, regardless of size or industry.
The tradeoff arrives once a plan exists. It must file an annual Form 5500 with the Department of Labor, plan fiduciaries must act in participants’ best interests, and the plan must follow its own written terms.3U.S. Department of Labor. Form 5500 Series Federal law doesn’t care whether you have a plan. It cares intensely about how you run one.
States That Require Employers to Offer Retirement Access
While the federal government stays hands-off, more than a dozen states have passed laws requiring employers to either offer a qualified retirement plan or enroll workers in a state-sponsored program. California’s CalSavers, Illinois Secure Choice, and OregonSaves were among the first. Colorado, Connecticut, Maine, Maryland, and Virginia have followed with their own versions, and several additional states have programs in development.
These programs generally work as automatic-enrollment IRAs rather than traditional 401(k) plans. Employers don’t contribute their own money and don’t manage investments. They register with the state, set up payroll deductions, and forward the contributions. The state handles the rest through a third-party administrator. Mandates typically apply based on headcount, often covering businesses with as few as one or five employees who don’t already offer a qualified plan.
Employers that already sponsor a 401(k), 403(b), SIMPLE IRA, or SEP plan are generally exempt. To claim the exemption, most states require proof of the existing plan. Compliance deadlines are usually phased in by company size, giving smaller firms extra time to register.
Ignoring these mandates gets expensive fast. Several of the largest programs follow a two-tier penalty structure: roughly $250 per eligible employee if noncompliance continues beyond a 90-day notice period, then another $500 per employee if the employer still hasn’t registered after about 180 days. For a company with 50 workers, that adds up to over $37,000 for doing nothing. Where a retirement plan is legally required, that requirement is coming from state law, not federal.
Automatic Enrollment Rules for New Plans
Once an employer decides to create a plan, the SECURE Act 2.0, signed in late 2022, changed the ground rules. Starting with the 2025 plan year, most 401(k) and 403(b) plans established after December 29, 2022, must include an eligible automatic contribution arrangement (EACA). The employer automatically deducts a percentage of each eligible employee’s pay and directs it into the plan unless the employee opts out.4Internal Revenue Service. SECURE 2.0 Act Impacts How Businesses Complete Forms W-2
The initial automatic contribution rate must be at least 3% and no more than 10% of the employee’s pay. Each year after that, the rate automatically increases by one percentage point until it hits a cap the employer sets somewhere between 10% and 15%.
Several plans are exempt from the auto-enrollment mandate:
- Plans established on or before December 29, 2022 — existing plans do not need to add auto-enrollment retroactively.
- Businesses with 10 or fewer employees.
- Businesses less than three years old.
- Church and governmental plans.
Workers who find money being deducted under auto-enrollment aren’t stuck. Anyone can opt out or change their contribution level at any time. Plans with an EACA also offer a special withdrawal window: if you act within 30 to 90 days of your first automatic deduction (the exact deadline depends on the plan), you can pull those contributions back out without owing the usual 10% early withdrawal penalty.5Internal Revenue Service. FAQs – Auto Enrollment – Can an Employee Withdraw Any Automatic Enrollment Contributions From the Retirement Plan The amount withdrawn is still taxable for the year, but the penalty waiver removes the sting for workers who can’t afford the deduction.
Are Employers Required to Match Contributions?
Federal law does not require an employer to match your contributions or deposit any money on your behalf. Many companies offer a match to attract and keep employees, but the decision is voluntary. A common formula matches 50 cents on the dollar up to 6% of pay, though the details vary.
The exception is when the employer picks a plan design that trades mandatory contributions for simplified compliance. A standard 401(k) must pass annual nondiscrimination tests showing that highly paid employees aren’t benefiting disproportionately. Small businesses often struggle with these tests, because owners want to contribute heavily while rank-and-file participation stays low. Safe Harbor plans skip the testing, but the employer has to commit to one of two contribution formulas:
- Basic Safe Harbor match: 100% of the first 3% of pay the employee defers, plus 50% of the next 2%. An employee contributing at least 5% of pay receives a match worth 4% of pay.
- Non-elective contribution: 3% of pay to every eligible employee, regardless of whether they contribute anything themselves.
Under a traditional Safe Harbor plan, these contributions must be 100% vested immediately.6Internal Revenue Service. Notice Requirement for a Safe Harbor 401(k) or 401(m) Plan The employee owns the money the moment it hits the account. If an employer fails to make the required contribution, the plan loses its Safe Harbor status, which can trigger retroactive nondiscrimination testing and, if the plan fails those tests, possible disqualification by the IRS.
A related design called a Qualified Automatic Contribution Arrangement (QACA) also qualifies for testing relief, using a different match formula: 100% of the first 1% of pay deferred plus 50% of the next 5%. QACA contributions do not need to vest immediately; they can follow a two-year cliff schedule, with the employee becoming fully vested after two years of service.7Internal Revenue Service. Vesting Schedules for Matching Contributions Once an employer adopts either structure, the contributions become a binding legal obligation, not a gesture of goodwill.
Tax Credits That Reduce the Cost of Starting a Plan
Congress uses the carrot more than the stick on retirement coverage. Small employers that create a new 401(k), SEP, or SIMPLE IRA can claim a tax credit covering up to 100% of eligible startup costs for businesses with 50 or fewer employees, or 50% for businesses with 51 to 100 employees. The credit maxes out at $5,000 per year and is available for the first three years the plan exists.8Internal Revenue Service. Retirement Plans Startup Costs Tax Credit Eligible costs include setup, administration, and employee education expenses.
Employers that add an auto-enrollment feature to a new or existing plan can claim an additional $500 per year for three years on top of the startup credit.8Internal Revenue Service. Retirement Plans Startup Costs Tax Credit Between those credits, the spreading state mandates, and the recruiting value of offering a plan, the economic case for creating one keeps getting stronger even in states where the legal requirement hasn’t arrived yet.