IRS Section 501(r) Requirements for Tax-Exempt Hospitals

Section 501(r) of the Internal Revenue Code sets out four things a charitable hospital has to do to keep its federal tax exemption: run a community health needs assessment every three years, maintain written financial assistance and emergency care policies, cap what it charges patients who qualify for assistance, and follow specific rules before pursuing unpaid bills. Congress added these requirements to the Affordable Care Act in 2010 so that the tax break given to nonprofit hospitals produces something concrete for the communities around them. A hospital that misses the mark can owe a $50,000 excise tax per facility per year for community health needs assessment failures, and in serious cases can lose its 501(c)(3) status altogether.

Which Hospitals Are Covered

The rules apply to every facility operating under a 501(c)(3) exemption that its state licenses, registers, or otherwise recognizes as a hospital. Multiple buildings under a single state license count as one facility. The obligations attach at the facility level, not just the organizational level, which matters for large systems running several hospitals under one corporate parent.

That structure also shapes enforcement. When one hospital inside a multi-facility organization fails to comply, the IRS can tax that facility’s income rather than pull the exemption of the entire organization. Compliant facilities in the same system are not automatically dragged down with a noncompliant sibling.

The Four Requirements

Section 501(r) rests on four pillars, each with its own regulations and its own exposure if ignored: the community health needs assessment, the financial assistance and emergency medical care policies, limits on charges to eligible patients, and restrictions on billing and collection. A hospital has to meet all four, at each facility, every year.

Community Health Needs Assessment

Every covered hospital must conduct a Community Health Needs Assessment, or CHNA, at least once every three tax years. The CHNA is a structured look at the most significant health problems in the area the hospital serves, and the hospital has to turn its findings into a written plan for addressing them.

Desk research isn’t enough. Federal rules require the hospital to gather input from three sources: at least one state, local, tribal, or regional public health department with knowledge of the community’s health needs; members of medically underserved, low-income, and minority populations in the service area, or organizations representing them; and written comments the hospital received on its most recent CHNA and implementation strategy.

The hospital then documents everything in a written CHNA report, makes it freely available on its website and in paper form at the facility on request, and has an authorized body such as the board of directors formally adopt it. For each significant health need identified, the hospital must adopt a written implementation strategy. If it decides not to address a particular need, the strategy has to explain why.

Missing the three-year cycle triggers a $50,000 excise tax under 26 U.S.C. ยง 4959, assessed per noncompliant facility for each year the requirement goes unmet.

Financial Assistance and Emergency Care Policies

Every covered hospital has to establish and maintain two written policies: a Financial Assistance Policy (FAP) and an emergency medical care policy. Together they spell out who qualifies for free or discounted care and guarantee that no one is turned away from the emergency department based on ability to pay.

What the FAP Must Say

The FAP has to cover the eligibility criteria for free or discounted services, whether the assistance applies to all care or only medically necessary services, the method the hospital uses to calculate charges for eligible patients, and how a patient applies. It also has to describe the actions the hospital may take when a patient doesn’t pay, including any collection measures.

Hospitals must translate the FAP into the primary language of any limited-English-proficiency group that makes up the lesser of 1,000 individuals or 5 percent of the community the hospital serves. The threshold applies separately to each language group, and hospitals can use any reasonable method to estimate the numbers.

Getting the FAP in Front of Patients

Writing the policy is only half the obligation. The hospital has to push it into the community through several specific channels:

  • The FAP, application form, and a plain-language summary all posted online, downloadable without an account or a fee.
  • Free paper copies available by mail on request and on display in public areas of the hospital, including the emergency department and admissions areas.
  • A conspicuous notice on every billing statement about the availability of financial assistance, along with a phone number and the direct web address for the FAP documents.
  • An offer of a paper copy of the plain-language summary during intake or discharge, plus conspicuous public displays inside the facility.

Emergency Care Without Discrimination

The emergency medical care policy has to state that the hospital will provide care for emergency conditions without discrimination and regardless of a patient’s ability to pay or FAP eligibility. Staff cannot delay screening or treatment to ask about insurance or collect payment. This overlaps with obligations under the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act, but Section 501(r) makes it a condition of tax exemption rather than only a Medicare participation rule.

Limits on What Eligible Patients Can Be Charged

Tax-exempt hospitals cannot bill FAP-eligible patients the full list prices from their chargemasters. Charges for emergency or medically necessary care to eligible patients must be limited to “amounts generally billed,” or AGB, to insured individuals.

Hospitals calculate AGB one of two ways. Under the look-back method, the hospital reviews all claims allowed by Medicare and private insurers over a prior 12-month period, divides total allowed amounts by total gross charges for those claims, and arrives at an AGB percentage that it applies going forward. The calculation must be updated at least once a year. Under the prospective method, the hospital calculates what Medicare fee-for-service, or Medicaid, would pay for the specific service; if the hospital uses both programs to set AGB, the FAP must describe the circumstances under which each applies.

The FAP has to describe which method the hospital uses. If the hospital switches methods, it must update the FAP before the change takes effect. These caps are what prevent a situation where a patient technically qualifies for financial assistance but still gets billed at rates no insured person would ever pay.

Billing and Collection Rules

The part of Section 501(r) that matters most day-to-day for patients deals with collections. A hospital cannot take extraordinary collection actions, called ECAs, against a patient until it has made reasonable efforts to determine whether that person qualifies for financial assistance. ECAs include some of the most aggressive tools a creditor has:

  • Reporting the debt to credit bureaus
  • Selling the debt to a third-party collector
  • Placing a lien on the patient’s property
  • Foreclosing on the patient’s property
  • Garnishing wages
  • Seizing bank accounts
  • Filing a lawsuit against the patient

The 120-Day and 240-Day Windows

Two clocks run from the date of the first post-discharge billing statement. The hospital must wait at least 120 days before starting any ECA. During that window it must provide written notice about the FAP, include a plain-language summary, and make a reasonable effort to notify the patient orally about financial assistance and how to apply. At least 30 days before starting any specific ECA, the hospital must send another written notice identifying the exact collection action it plans to take and giving the patient a deadline to respond.

The second clock is longer. The hospital has to accept and process FAP applications for at least 240 days after the first billing statement. If a patient submits a complete application during this period, the hospital must suspend any ECAs, decide eligibility, and notify the patient of the decision in writing along with the reason for it. If the patient is eligible, the hospital must refund any amount the patient already paid beyond what an eligible individual owes, provided the excess is $5 or more. It also has to take reasonably available steps to reverse ECAs already initiated, such as vacating judgments, lifting liens, and removing negative information from credit reports.

Even an incomplete application triggers protections. The hospital must suspend ECAs and tell the patient in writing what additional documentation is needed.

Anti-Abuse Rule

A hospital fails the reasonable-efforts standard if it bases an eligibility denial on information it has reason to believe is unreliable, or on information obtained through coercion, such as delaying emergency care until a patient hands over financial details.

Penalties for Noncompliance

Penalties escalate with the severity of the problem. For CHNA failures, the IRS imposes the $50,000 excise tax under Section 4959 for each noncompliant facility in each tax year the requirement goes unmet. For broader 501(r) failures, the IRS can revoke the organization’s entire 501(c)(3) status. In multi-facility systems the IRS has the option of taxing only the noncompliant facility’s income and leaving the rest of the organization’s exemption intact.

Revocation is the far end of the scale. It effectively converts the hospital into a taxable entity, ends its ability to receive tax-deductible charitable contributions, and can affect its access to tax-exempt bond financing. The IRS has signaled that revocation is reserved for the most serious or persistent failures, but the possibility is what gives the other requirements weight.

Fixing a Violation Without Losing Exempt Status

Not every mistake costs a hospital its exemption. The IRS evaluates noncompliance based on the facts and circumstances, and the regulations carve out two categories of forgivable errors. Minor omissions and errors that are inadvertent or due to reasonable cause are not treated as 501(r) failures at all, so long as the hospital corrects them promptly. Separately, failures that are neither willful nor egregious can be corrected and disclosed under the procedures in Revenue Procedure 2015-21 without jeopardizing exempt status.

The IRS defines “willful” broadly to include gross negligence and reckless disregard, not only intentional violations. “Egregious” is reserved for very serious failures measured by the severity of harm and the number of people affected. The act of correcting and disclosing a failure is itself a factor suggesting the failure was not willful.

Correction generally means restoring affected patients to the position they would have been in if the failure had never occurred. If a hospital overcharged FAP-eligible patients, it has to issue refunds (unless the overpayment is under $5), even for a prior, closed tax year. The hospital must also establish or revise internal procedures to reduce the chance of recurrence. Disclosure happens on the Form 990 for the year the failure was discovered and has to include a description of the failure, the correction steps taken, and any procedural changes.

Reporting a Hospital to the IRS

Anyone who believes a tax-exempt hospital is violating Section 501(r) can file a complaint with the IRS using Form 13909, the Tax-Exempt Organization Complaint (Referral) Form. The form asks for the hospital’s name, address, and Employer Identification Number, along with a description of the alleged violation, who was involved, what happened, and how the complainant learned about it. Complaints can be submitted by mail to IRS TEGE Classification in Dallas, Texas, or by email to eoclass@irs.gov. Anonymous submissions are allowed for people concerned about retaliation.

The IRS sends an acknowledgment letter after receiving the form but cannot provide updates on any investigation or actions taken; federal law bars that disclosure. Anyone hoping to claim a financial reward for reporting noncompliance has to file a separate Form 211, Application for Award for Original Information.