Under IRC 6751, the IRS generally cannot impose a discretion-based penalty unless the examiner’s immediate supervisor personally approved that penalty in writing before it was formally communicated to you. That is the core of the supervisory approval requirements in IRC 6751, added by the IRS Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998 to keep revenue agents from using penalty threats as audit leverage.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 6751 – Procedural Requirements Final regulations published in December 2024 now set out the timing rules that had produced years of conflicting court decisions.
The Two Rules Inside Section 6751
Section 6751 contains two separate protections, and it helps to keep them straight.
Subsection (a) governs what a penalty notice must say. Every notice has to identify the name of the penalty, the Code section authorizing it, and a computation showing how the amount was reached.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 6751 – Procedural Requirements A notice missing any of those elements fails the statute.
Subsection (b) is the supervisory approval rule and the one that drives almost all the litigation. It bars assessment of a penalty unless the “initial determination of such assessment is personally approved (in writing) by the immediate supervisor of the individual making such determination or such higher level official as the Secretary may designate.”1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 6751 – Procedural Requirements The idea is simple: a second person reviews the penalty before the taxpayer ever sees it, so a single agent cannot impose penalties or dangle them as a settlement tool.2Taxpayer Advocate Service. 2021 Purple Book – Legislative Recommendation 33
Which Penalties Need Approval
The requirement reaches any penalty an IRS employee proposes based on judgment rather than automatic computation. The ones that come up most often are:
- Accuracy-related penalties under IRC 6662, covering negligence, disregard of rules or regulations, and substantial understatement of income tax. An examiner has to decide whether a position was “negligent” or an understatement “substantial,” which is exactly the kind of judgment the rule targets.
- Civil fraud penalties under IRC 6663, which turn on a determination about your intent.
- Tax return preparer penalties under IRC 6694 for unreasonable positions or willful misconduct.
Any other penalty proposed through human review during an examination generally requires approval unless it falls within one of the exceptions below.
Penalties That Are Exempt
Section 6751(b)(2) carves out two categories.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 6751 – Procedural Requirements The first is a list of specific penalties Congress named:
- Failure-to-file and failure-to-pay penalties under IRC 6651.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 6651 – Failure to File Tax Return or to Pay Tax
- Estimated tax penalties for individuals under IRC 6654 and for corporations under IRC 6655, both computed from payment shortfalls and due dates.
- Certain conservation easement accuracy penalties tied to Section 170(p) overstatements or Section 170(h)(7) disallowances. Other accuracy-related penalties under Section 6662 still require approval.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 6662 – Imposition of Accuracy-Related Penalty on Underpayments
The second exemption is broader: any penalty “automatically calculated through electronic means.”1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 6751 – Procedural Requirements Between the two exemptions, roughly 98 percent of penalties the IRS imposes each year fall outside the approval requirement, because the bulk are late-file, late-pay, estimated tax, and bad check penalties generated by automated systems.5Taxpayer Advocate Service. 2021 Purple Book – Legislative Recommendation 34 The approval rule bites in the smaller universe of penalties an actual person chose to propose.
Who Approves, and What Counts as Written
Two categories of officials may sign off: the immediate supervisor of the person who first proposed the penalty, or a higher-level official the Secretary designates.6eCFR. 26 CFR 301.6751(b)-1 – Supervisory and Higher Level Official Approval for Penalties The person who proposed the penalty cannot approve their own work. That separation is the whole mechanism.
The 2024 final regulations read “personally approved (in writing)” broadly. Any writing, electronic form included, satisfies the statute as long as it reflects the approver’s intent to approve the penalty. No specific signature format, timestamp technology, or wording is required.7Federal Register. Rules for Supervisory Approval of Penalties Treasury and the IRS rejected comments asking for mandatory digital signatures or standardized forms, saying such formalities go beyond what the statute requires. The IRS typically uses an internal Civil Penalty Approval Form, but the regulations do not mandate any particular document.
The flexibility runs both ways. It eases IRS compliance, and it means the evidence you see in a dispute may be as informal as a supervisor’s email. The question in any challenge is whether the writing, in whatever format, shows the supervisor actually reviewed and approved the specific penalty before the applicable deadline.
When Approval Must Be Obtained
Timing is where most fights happen. The 2024 regulations set three deadlines depending on how the penalty reaches you.7Federal Register. Rules for Supervisory Approval of Penalties
Penalties Subject to Tax Court Pre-Assessment Review
This covers most penalties proposed during an audit of your income tax return. The IRS asserts the penalty in a statutory notice of deficiency, and you may challenge it in Tax Court before any assessment. For these penalties, the supervisor must sign off in writing on or before the date the notice of deficiency is mailed.7Federal Register. Rules for Supervisory Approval of Penalties This tracks the Second Circuit’s holding in Chai v. Commissioner (2017), that Section 6751(b)(1) “requires written approval of the initial penalty determination no later than the date the IRS issues the notice of deficiency (or files an answer or amended answer) asserting such penalty.”8Justia Law. Chai v. Commissioner, No. 15-1653 (2d Cir. 2017)
Penalties Not Subject to Tax Court Pre-Assessment Review
Some penalties, including many employment tax penalties and various assessable penalties, do not go through the deficiency process. For these, the supervisor must approve the penalty in writing before it is assessed.7Federal Register. Rules for Supervisory Approval of Penalties Assessment itself is the cutoff.
Penalties Raised After a Tax Court Petition Is Filed
If the IRS raises a new penalty after you have already petitioned the Tax Court, the supervisor must approve the penalty no later than the date the IRS asks the court to determine it.7Federal Register. Rules for Supervisory Approval of Penalties
The 2024 regulations tie the deadline to specific, identifiable events (the mailing of the notice of deficiency, the assessment, or the court filing) rather than to any earlier informal contact between examiner and taxpayer. That gives the IRS more room than the Tax Court’s broadest readings had allowed, but it preserves the core protection: the sign-off has to come before the formal trigger event.
How to Challenge a Penalty for Lack of Timely Approval
Under IRC 7491(c), the IRS carries the burden of production on any penalty in court. It must come forward with evidence that it followed the law, including Section 6751(b), before you have to prove anything about the merits.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 7491 – Burden of Proof In practice, a Section 6751(b) challenge runs like this:
- Petition the Tax Court after receiving the notice of deficiency, contesting both the underlying tax and the penalty.
- Raise the approval issue. You do not have to prove the IRS failed to obtain approval. You have to credibly put the question in play, which shifts the burden onto the IRS to prove it did.
- Request the administrative file, often through a Freedom of Information Act request. The Civil Penalty Approval Form or its equivalent should be there. If it is missing, undated, or dated after the deadline, the IRS has a problem.
- Force the IRS to produce evidence. If it cannot show written supervisory approval obtained on or before the applicable deadline, the penalty falls, no matter what the return said.
This is a purely procedural defense. It can void a penalty even when the IRS was right about the underlying tax issue, which is why so many accuracy-related penalties have been undone on these grounds. The common failure mode is an examiner who communicated the penalty to the taxpayer, or the IRS that mailed the notice of deficiency, before the supervisor actually signed.
International Information Return Penalties
Whether Section 6751(b) reaches penalties for failing to file international information returns under IRC 6038 and 6038A is unsettled. The IRS assesses these penalties in two ways. Systemically assessed penalties, generated automatically when a late return is filed, likely sit within the “automatically calculated through electronic means” exemption. Manually assessed penalties, imposed after an examiner’s determination in an audit, would ordinarily need supervisory approval.10Taxpayer Advocate Service. 2020 Annual Report to Congress – Most Serious Problem 8 International
The Tax Court’s 2023 decision in Farhy v. Commissioner held that the IRS lacks authority to assess certain Section 6038(b) penalties at all without first going to court, and how that ruling interacts with the approval requirement is still being worked out. If you are facing an international information return penalty, whether Section 6751(b) helps you will depend on precisely how the IRS imposed it.