IRC Section 304 is an anti-abuse rule that stops shareholders from pulling cash out of two corporations they control by selling the stock of one to the other and calling the proceeds a capital gain. When a shareholder sells stock of one controlled corporation to another controlled corporation for cash or property, Section 304 recharacterizes the sale as a deemed stock redemption and pushes the transaction through the dividend-testing rules of Section 302.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 304 – Redemption Through Use of Related Corporations In most related-party fact patterns, the result is ordinary dividend income rather than capital gain.
When Section 304 Applies: The Control Test
Section 304 only bites when the same person or group controls both corporations involved: the corporation whose stock is being sold (the issuing corporation) and the corporation buying it (the acquiring corporation). Control means owning stock with at least 50% of the total combined voting power of all voting classes, or at least 50% of the total value of all classes. Either prong is enough.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 304 – Redemption Through Use of Related Corporations
Section 304(c)(1) also reaches through chains of ownership. If a person controls Corporation A, and Corporation A owns at least 50% of the vote or value of Corporation B, that person is treated as controlling B as well.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 304 – Redemption Through Use of Related Corporations Section 304 can therefore reach transactions several corporate layers deep.
Constructive Ownership Widens the Net
Whether you cross the 50% control threshold is not measured only by shares you actually hold. Section 318(a) attribution treats you as owning stock held by certain family members, partnerships, estates, trusts, and corporations.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 318 – Constructive Ownership of Stock
Family Attribution
You are treated as owning stock held by your spouse (unless legally separated under a divorce or separate maintenance decree), your children, grandchildren, and parents. Adopted children count as children by blood. Siblings are not on the list. Stock attributed to you through one family member cannot then be re-attributed through you to another family member, which caps the chain effect.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 318 – Constructive Ownership of Stock
The 5% Corporate Attribution Rule
This is where Section 304 catches people who thought they were unrelated to a transaction. Under the normal Section 318 rules, corporate attribution runs only when a person owns 50% or more of the corporation. Section 304(c)(3)(B) replaces that “50 percent” with “5 percent” for the control determination.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 304 – Redemption Through Use of Related Corporations Own just 5% of a corporation and you are treated as owning a proportionate share of everything that corporation holds. The rule runs in reverse too: a corporation is treated as owning a proportionate share of any 5%-or-greater shareholder’s other stock.
Shareholders who look wholly unconnected under ordinary attribution can find themselves treated as controlling both sides of a stock sale, dragging what looked like a routine transaction into Section 304.
The Two Covered Transactions
Brother-Sister Acquisitions
Section 304(a)(1) covers the brother-sister case: one or more persons control two corporations, and one of those corporations acquires stock of the other from the controlling shareholder in exchange for cash or property.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 304 – Redemption Through Use of Related Corporations
Say you own 100% of both Corporation X and Corporation Y, and you sell your X stock to Y for cash. Without Section 304, you might report a stock sale at capital gains rates. Section 304 recharacterizes the payment as a distribution in redemption of Y’s stock (the acquiring corporation), which is then tested under Section 302 for sale versus dividend treatment.
Parent-Subsidiary Acquisitions
Section 304(a)(2) covers the parent-subsidiary case: a subsidiary acquires stock of its parent from a shareholder of the parent, and the parent (issuing corporation) controls the subsidiary (acquiring corporation).1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 304 – Redemption Through Use of Related Corporations Here, the cash from the subsidiary is treated as a distribution in redemption of the parent’s stock (the issuing corporation), not the subsidiary’s. If a transaction could fit either category, the parent-subsidiary rule takes priority.
Sale or Dividend: The Section 302 Tests
For both transaction types, the redemption is tested by looking at the shareholder’s interest in the issuing corporation, not the acquiring corporation.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 304 – Redemption Through Use of Related Corporations The shareholder gets sale-or-exchange treatment only by passing one of three Section 302(b) tests:3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 302 – Distributions in Redemption of Stock
- Not essentially equivalent to a dividend. The redemption must produce a meaningful reduction in the shareholder’s proportionate interest. Courts read “meaningful” narrowly.
- Substantially disproportionate. After the redemption, the shareholder must own less than 50% of the combined voting power, and both voting and common stock percentages must fall by more than 20% from their pre-redemption levels.
- Complete termination. The shareholder’s entire interest is redeemed. Family attribution can be waived under certain conditions, which is often the only realistic path to sale treatment.
Related-party transactions almost always fail these tests. Constructive ownership generally keeps the shareholder’s deemed interest in the issuing corporation flat before and after the transaction, so “meaningful reduction” is very hard to demonstrate. When the tests fail, the full amount received is treated as a distribution under Section 301.
How Much of the Distribution Is a Dividend
When distribution treatment applies, the dividend is measured against the combined earnings and profits of both corporations. The distribution is sourced first from the acquiring corporation’s E&P, then from the issuing corporation’s E&P.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 304 – Redemption Through Use of Related Corporations
Example: you receive $100. The acquiring corporation has $60 of E&P, the issuing corporation has $50. The first $60 comes from the acquirer, the next $40 from the issuer (which retains $10). The entire $100 is a taxable dividend. Any amount that exceeds the combined E&P of both corporations reduces your stock basis, and anything beyond that is capital gain.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 301 – Distributions of Property
Foreign Acquiring Corporation Override
If the acquiring corporation is foreign, Section 304(b)(5)(B) disregards its E&P entirely when more than 50% of the resulting dividends would neither be subject to U.S. tax in the year they arise nor be includible in the E&P of a controlled foreign corporation.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 304 – Redemption Through Use of Related Corporations The rule blocks routing Section 304 transactions through foreign subsidiaries with large E&P pools to generate dividends that escape current U.S. taxation.
Basis and the Deemed Section 351 Exchange
The basis mechanics are where most people stumble. When the transaction produces dividend treatment, Section 304(a)(1) treats it as two events: the shareholder is deemed to have contributed the issuing corporation’s stock to the acquiring corporation in a tax-free Section 351 exchange, and the acquiring corporation is then deemed to have redeemed the stock it was treated as issuing.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 304 – Redemption Through Use of Related Corporations
Because the transfer is treated as a Section 351 contribution, the acquiring corporation takes a carryover basis in the acquired stock under Section 362(a).5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 362 – Basis to Corporations The Treasury regulations confirm the stock received by the acquiring corporation is treated as a contribution to capital.6eCFR. 26 CFR 1.304-2 – Acquisition by Related Corporation (Other Than Subsidiary)
For the shareholder, dividend treatment means the distribution is not offset by stock basis. The shareholder’s unrecovered basis in the transferred stock is added to the basis of their remaining stock in the acquiring corporation. If the shareholder no longer owns any stock of the acquiring corporation, that basis shifts to their stock in the issuing corporation. Basis is preserved rather than lost.
The Anti-Avoidance Regulation
Treasury Regulation Section 1.304-4 lets the IRS look through structures built to sidestep Section 304. It targets two scenarios:7eCFR. 26 CFR 1.304-4 – Special Rules for the Use of Related Corporations
- Deemed acquiring corporation. If an entity is created, organized, or funded with a principal purpose of avoiding Section 304 as applied to a different corporation that actually controls the acquirer, the IRS can treat the controlling corporation as the acquirer. This prevents inserting a shell with little E&P to shrink the dividend.
- Deemed issuing corporation. If the issuing corporation acquires stock of a subsidiary in connection with the transaction, and a principal purpose is to keep Section 304 from applying to that subsidiary, the subsidiary is treated as the issuing corporation. This blocks restructuring ownership to keep a high-E&P entity out of the stacking calculation.
The trigger is “principal purpose.” The IRS does not have to show economic substance was lacking or that tax avoidance was the only motivation. If avoiding Section 304 was a principal purpose, the transaction is recast to pull in the entity the taxpayer tried to leave out.