How Xactimate Insurance Software Calculates Repair Costs

Xactimate calculates repair costs by multiplying the measurements of your damaged property by composite unit prices drawn from a regional database, then layering waste factors, sales tax, depreciation, and overhead and profit on top. Each line in the estimate pulls a price built from three ingredients (labor, materials, and equipment) tied to the zip code of the loss and the month the price list was downloaded. Understanding how Xactimate calculates repair costs is the difference between accepting an estimate at face value and knowing where to look when the number seems off.

What a Single Line Item Is Actually Priced On

Every entry in the database is identified by a category code and a selector code. The category code names the trade: RFG is roofing, PLM is plumbing, ELE is electrical, DRY is drywall, PNT is painting.1Xactware Help Docs. Category Codes in Xactimate Online The selector narrows it to a specific task, such as removing and replacing a particular shingle or installing a specific gauge of wire. When your estimate reads “RFG SHNGL” with a description after it, that code is pulling one composite price from the database.

That composite is built from three components:

  • Labor, calculated as a “retail labor rate.” This is a fully burdened figure that includes the worker’s base wage, employment taxes (Social Security, Medicare, unemployment insurance), workers’ compensation premiums, general liability coverage, and overhead such as company vehicles and hand-tool depreciation. The burden varies by trade, because a roofing laborer carries much higher workers’ compensation cost than a demolition laborer.2C3 Adjusters. Retail Labor Rate Corrections
  • Materials, meaning the retail price of the physical goods needed to complete the repair, including fasteners, adhesives, and other consumables. These prices come from supplier feeds and market surveys.
  • Equipment, meaning rental rates for specialized tools such as industrial dehumidifiers, scaffolding, or air scrubbers. Not every line item has an equipment component; when one does, the rate reflects daily or weekly rental pricing for the region.

Blending the three into one unit price is what makes the software usable. When the estimate says a square foot of hardwood flooring costs a certain amount, that figure already covers the installer’s wages, the wood, and any equipment. The desktop version lets you open each line item and view the breakdown, which is useful when you want to check whether a specific material price lines up with what you’re seeing at local suppliers.

Why Labor Costs More Than the Wage

Labor burden is the piece most policyholders underestimate. The hourly rate in your estimate is not what the worker takes home. For a non-union contractor, employment-related costs typically add 24% to 33% on top of the base wage. For union contractors, pension contributions, benefit funds, and higher insurance requirements push the burden to 60% to 70%.3Payroll4Construction. How to Calculate Labor Burden and Its Impact on Construction Payroll A $30 wage costs the non-union shop $37 to $40 to employ, and the union shop $48 to $51. Those costs are real, and they appear in every labor-bearing line.

Where the Prices in the Database Come From

The pricing engine is maintained by Verisk, Xactware’s parent company, which collects real-world cost data from material suppliers, equipment rental companies, contractors, subcontractors, and completed Xactimate estimates submitted by users in the field. Data arrives through phone and email surveys, direct supplier feeds, and actual transaction records and bids.4Xactware. Pricing Methodology Summary Each price list carries roughly 13,000 line items spanning structural repair, cleaning, water mitigation, and hazardous material work.

General pricing refreshes monthly; vendor-specific pricing updates nightly.5Xactware Help. What Are the Differences in Price Lists, Both in Area and by Month? That monthly cycle matters when inflation or supply disruption shifts material costs quickly. A price list downloaded in March will not match one downloaded in July if lumber or drywall prices moved in between. The methodology aggregates a large pool of submissions, identifies the most common price cluster, and selects a point within that range rather than relying on any single contractor’s quote.4Xactware. Pricing Methodology Summary

How Your Property’s Measurements Enter the Math

Xactimate’s Sketch tool is where physical dimensions become financial data. An estimator draws the footprint of each room, inputting length, width, and wall height. For roofs, they set the slope and drag edges to match the actual dimensions, using break tools to add dormers, valleys, and other overbuilds.6Xactware. Quick Reference Sketching Roofs in Xactimate From those drawings the software calculates total square footage, linear measurements, and vertical surface areas, which cuts out the arithmetic errors that plague hand-written estimates.

Once the base dimensions are set, Xactimate applies waste factors to account for material lost during cutting and installation. You never need exactly 20 squares of shingles for a 20-square roof: overlaps, hip and ridge cuts, and starter courses consume extra material. The software can calculate roof waste automatically when the setting is enabled under Sketch preferences.7Xactware Help. Calculating Roof Waste Carpet, tile, and other flooring carry their own waste percentages for room shape, pattern matching, and seam placement.

When an estimator deviates from the standard waste factor, they attach a note explaining why (using the F9 key in the desktop version).8Xactware Help. Attach or Delete Notes, Images, or Sound Files to a Line Item in X1 Those notes are visible to anyone reviewing the estimate. If a waste factor looks unusually high or low and there is no note, that is worth questioning.

Why the Same Repair Costs More in One Zip Code Than Another

Xactimate does not use a single national price list. Price lists are area-specific, tied to the zip code of the loss, so the same line item prices differently depending on where your property sits.5Xactware Help. What Are the Differences in Price Lists, Both in Area and by Month? A kitchen repair in a high-cost coastal metro will price higher than the same scope in a rural community, because the underlying data reflects local labor markets, material delivery costs, and supply availability.

The zip code also drives the sales tax applied to the estimate. Different jurisdictions tax materials, labor, and equipment at different rates, and the software pulls the rules for that location. Users cannot edit the tax rules imported from Xactware price lists, though they can create custom rules for a specific estimate if local circumstances require it.9Xactware Help. Sales Taxes Tax settings also control whether overhead and profit are calculated before or after tax, which can shift the total on larger projects.10Xactware Help. Customizing Taxes

If an adjuster selects the wrong zip code or an outdated price list month, every line item will be mispriced. Checking the price list date and the zip code at the top of your estimate is one of the simplest first moves when reviewing a claim payment.

How Depreciation Turns Replacement Cost Into Your First Check

Most homeowner policies are written on a replacement cost basis, but the initial check usually reflects actual cash value (ACV): replacement cost minus depreciation. The difference is the depreciation holdback, recoverable only after you complete the repairs and submit proof. If your policy is ACV-only, the depreciated amount is all you will receive.

Xactimate calculates depreciation based on the age and condition of the damaged item relative to its expected useful life. The formula divides age by life expectancy to get a base percentage. A $100 line item with a 14-year life and an age of 2 years depreciates at roughly 14.3% in normal condition, reducing the ACV payout by $14.29.11Xactware Help. Add or Edit Depreciation The software then adjusts that base by condition:

  • Below average condition increases the base depreciation by 40%. A $100 item aged 1 year with a 14-year life depreciates at about 10% instead of the normal 7.1%.
  • Average condition uses the straight age-based calculation with no adjustment.
  • Above average condition reduces the base depreciation by 40%. A well-maintained item loses less value per year.
  • New or replaced items get no depreciation.

Adjusters can set depreciation as recoverable or non-recoverable on each line item, and those settings vary by state and by carrier.12Xactware Help. Depreciation in Xactimate Online Under ACV coverage, the insurer pays the depreciated value. Under replacement cost coverage, the insurer pays what it actually costs to repair or replace with materials of similar kind and quality.13NAIC. What’s the Difference Between Actual Cash Value Coverage and Replacement Cost Coverage If your first check looks low, check whether the depreciation holdback is recoverable under your policy. That is often where the gap between the check and the contractor’s bid actually sits.

Overhead and Profit on Top

The last layer added is General Overhead and Profit, usually called O&P. The industry convention is “10 and 10”: 10% for the contractor’s general overhead (office rent, insurance, administrative staff, vehicles) and 10% for profit. These apply as two separate calculations on the project subtotal rather than a flat 20%. Because profit is figured on a subtotal that already includes overhead, the combined effect runs slightly above 20%.

O&P sits apart from the overhead already embedded in each line item’s retail labor rate. The labor rate covers job-level costs like employment burden and tool wear. General O&P covers the contractor’s broader business costs and their margin for managing the project. Site-specific expenses like portable toilets or building permits are typically entered as their own line items rather than folded into the percentage.

Whether O&P belongs on your estimate at all is one of the most contested issues in insurance claims. Many carriers apply a guideline that O&P is warranted when the project requires coordinating three or more trades, such as roofing, electrical, and drywall. The logic is that once a general contractor must hire, schedule, and supervise multiple subcontractors, the management burden justifies overhead and profit. That threshold is industry practice drawn from case law, not a statute.14EdgeVaco. What Is O&P in Xactimate and Why Carriers Deny It If your project involves fewer than three trades, an insurer may deny O&P, and contractors push back regularly, arguing that two-trade jobs still involve project management.

What to Check If the Number Looks Wrong

Both your insurer and your contractor can run Xactimate and still produce different totals. Adjusters and contractors often disagree on scope (what needs to be repaired), line item selection (which code best describes the work), and pricing (whether the price list reflects actual local costs).

Start with the header of the estimate. Confirm the zip code matches the loss location and the price list month is current. Then work down the line items. Measurements should match the Sketch; waste factors should be reasonable for the material, and any deviation should carry a note. Labor burden, equipment, and tax should be present where they belong. Depreciation should reflect the actual age and condition of what was damaged, not a worst-case assumption.

The most effective external step is an independent estimate from a licensed contractor trained in Xactimate. Even if the bid is formatted differently, someone who knows the codes can spot missing line items, incorrect measurements, or underpriced categories.15United Policyholders. Xactimate Demystified Subcontractor bids for specialized trades help too, because they provide real-world pricing that can override a database figure when the local market has moved.

If direct negotiation stalls, most homeowner policies include an appraisal clause. Either party can invoke it when the dollar amount of the loss is in dispute. Each side selects an appraiser, and the two appraisers choose an umpire. A decision agreed to by any two of the three is binding. You pay your own appraiser and split the umpire’s cost with the insurer. Appraisal resolves disputes over the amount of the loss, not coverage questions, so it fits when the fight is about how much the repairs cost rather than whether they are covered.

Whatever route you take, present your case in a format the insurer can line up against its own output. An estimate that cannot be compared line-by-line against the adjuster’s Xactimate is hard to negotiate from.15United Policyholders. Xactimate Demystified