How to Write a Bonus Letter: Wording, Repayment, and Timing

A bonus letter should state the employee’s name and title, the gross bonus amount, the reason for the payment, the payment date, any conditions such as a repayment obligation, and carry the signature of someone authorized to approve it. That much is the easy part of learning how to write a bonus letter. The harder part is choosing language that doesn’t accidentally convert a discretionary reward into a nondiscretionary obligation, because the wording you use can trigger overtime recalculations, tax-deduction timing problems, and enforceable repayment disputes.

What Goes in the Letter

Keep the document short and specific. The elements that need to appear:

  • The employee’s legal name and job title as they appear in payroll records, so accounting can process the payment without delay.
  • The gross dollar amount. If the bonus is calculated as a percentage of salary, state both the percentage and the resulting dollar figure.
  • The reason for the payment — individual performance, a company milestone, a holiday gesture, a signing incentive, or a referral. This detail carries more legal weight than most drafters realize.
  • The payment date, whether the bonus goes out in the next regular pay cycle or as a separate off-cycle deposit.
  • Any conditions or contingencies, including a requirement to remain employed through a specific date or a repayment obligation if the employee leaves.
  • A signature from a manager or executive with authority to approve the payment.

Add a sentence noting that the payment is subject to standard tax withholding. Employees receiving a first bonus often expect the net deposit to match the gross figure in the letter, and it won’t.

How Wording Turns a Bonus Nondiscretionary

Federal labor law draws a sharp line between discretionary and nondiscretionary bonuses, and the line runs through what the employer says in advance. A bonus is discretionary only if the employer keeps sole control over both whether to pay it and how much to pay, all the way through to the end of the covered period, and only if no prior promise or agreement has led the employee to expect it.

Once you commit to a bonus in advance, the discretion is gone. Attendance bonuses, production bonuses, quality-of-work bonuses, and bonuses conditioned on the employee remaining employed through a payout date are all treated as nondiscretionary no matter what label the letter uses.1eCFR. 29 CFR 778.211 – Discretionary Bonuses Writing the word “discretionary” into the letter does not override the underlying facts.

This matters financially. Nondiscretionary bonuses must be included in the employee’s regular rate of pay for overtime calculations. If the employee worked overtime hours during the period the bonus covers, the employer owes additional overtime compensation on top of the bonus.2U.S. Department of Labor. Fact Sheet 56C: Bonuses Under the Fair Labor Standards Act Department of Labor auditors look for this recalculation, so a bonus letter that promises a specific payment for hitting a target should be paired with a budget adjustment for the overtime true-up.

If you genuinely want the bonus to stay discretionary, say nothing about it in advance. No hints in staff meetings, no formulas tied to metrics, no language in an offer letter. Announce the bonus and the amount only when you’re ready to pay.

Handling Repayment Clauses

Signing bonuses and some retention bonuses come with a clawback: the employee must return part or all of the bonus if they leave within a set window. One- to three-year retention periods are common, and the repayment obligation usually shrinks on a sliding scale. Leaving in the first six months might require returning 100 percent; leaving after nine months might drop that to 50 or 25 percent.

Draft the clause to specify what triggers repayment. Voluntary resignation and termination for cause typically trigger it; layoffs and reductions in force typically don’t. The letter can also reserve the employer’s right to deduct the repayment from the employee’s final paycheck, to the extent state law permits, with any remaining balance due within 30 days of separation.

Define “cause” carefully. A broad definition that sweeps in “violation of company policy” gives the employer wide latitude to demand repayment. A narrow definition limited to fraud or criminal conduct offers the employee more protection. Whichever side of the letter you’re on, that definition is where the real negotiation sits.

Noting Tax Withholding in the Letter

The IRS treats bonuses as supplemental wages, which follow different withholding rules than regular paychecks. The letter doesn’t need to explain the rules in detail, but it should tell the employee that standard withholding will reduce the net deposit.

When a bonus is paid separately from regular wages, the simplest method is to withhold a flat 22 percent for federal income tax. That flat rate holds as long as the employee’s total supplemental wages for the calendar year stay at or below $1 million; the excess above $1 million is withheld at 37 percent.3Internal Revenue Service. Publication 15 – Employer’s Tax Guide

The alternative is the aggregate method: combine the bonus with the most recent regular paycheck and withhold based on the employee’s W-4 as if the combined total were one payment. This often produces higher withholding than the flat 22 percent because the inflated total pushes the calculation into a higher bracket. The employee reconciles everything on their annual return, so any excess comes back as a refund.

Bonuses are also subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes on the same terms as regular wages, and many states apply their own supplemental withholding rate. Employees in high-tax states may find the combined deduction on a bonus larger than they expected.

Timing the Payment Date

The payment date you write into the letter can affect when the employer gets to deduct the expense. Accrual-basis employers can deduct a bonus in the tax year it was earned, but only if the employee actually receives the payment within 2½ months after that tax year ends. For a calendar-year business, that deadline is March 15.4eCFR. 26 CFR 1.404(b)-1T – Deduction Timing for Deferred Compensation Payment after that date pushes the deduction into the year the payment is made.

Cash-basis employers don’t have that option. They deduct bonuses in the year the payment goes out, full stop. Before finalizing the date in a year-end bonus letter, coordinate with accounting so the timing matches the tax result the business wants.

One boundary worth flagging: the 2½-month shortcut does not apply to bonuses paid to certain related parties, including shareholders who own more than 50 percent of a C corporation and any S corporation shareholder. Those bonuses cannot be deducted until the year the recipient reports the income.

Delivering the Letter

Most employers deliver bonus letters through their HR information system, uploading the document to the employee’s portal alongside pay stubs and tax forms. A physical copy handed over in a private meeting adds context and lets the manager explain the award. Encrypted company email works when neither of the other options fits.

Once the letter is delivered, funds typically arrive within one to two pay cycles. A separate off-cycle deposit keeps the withholding simple because the flat 22 percent rate applies cleanly. Rolling the bonus into a regular paycheck forces the aggregate calculation and can temporarily inflate the total withheld, which is worth mentioning in the letter if that’s how payroll plans to process it.