How to Withdraw From a TFSA: Rules, Taxes, and Re-Contribution

To withdraw from a TFSA, you ask your financial institution to move money out of the account; the cash lands in your bank account within a few business days, no tax is owed, and you do not need to notify the Canada Revenue Agency. The institution reports the withdrawal to the CRA after year-end. The one thing that trips people up is timing: withdrawn amounts do not restore your contribution room until January 1 of the following year, so re-depositing the same money in the same calendar year can trigger a penalty.

How to Request the Withdrawal

Your financial institution runs the entire process. Most banks and brokerages let you initiate a withdrawal online by transferring cash from the TFSA to a linked chequing or savings account. You can also do it in a branch or over the phone. A cash withdrawal typically settles in two to five business days.

The CRA charges nothing for a withdrawal. Your institution may charge an administrative fee on certain transactions, particularly a full account closure or a transfer out to another institution. Transfer-out fees at major Canadian banks often run around $150 plus tax, and some receiving institutions will reimburse that cost if you are moving a large enough balance.

Cash or In-Kind

You can take the money as cash or move the actual investments out “in kind.” With a cash withdrawal, the institution sells the holdings inside the TFSA and deposits the proceeds. An in-kind withdrawal moves the securities themselves — stocks, ETFs, bonds — into a non-registered investment account without selling them.

For an in-kind transfer, the fair market value of the securities on the day of the transfer is what gets reported to the CRA as the withdrawal amount, and that same value becomes your new cost base in the non-registered account. The transfer does not trigger tax on its own. Capital gains or losses only arise later, when you sell the securities from the non-registered account.

The Re-Contribution Trap

Every dollar you withdraw is added back to your contribution room, but not immediately. The amount is restored on January 1 of the year after the withdrawal. This is the single most common cause of accidental over-contributions.

Here is how the CRA calculates your available room each year:

  • The current year’s TFSA dollar limit set by the government
  • Plus any unused room carried forward from previous years
  • Plus withdrawals made in the previous year
  • Minus contributions already made in the current calendar year

Current-year withdrawals do not enter that formula until the following January 1. If you withdraw $10,000 in March and re-contribute $10,000 in September, the CRA treats the September deposit as a brand-new contribution against your existing room, not as putting the money back. If you did not already have $10,000 of unused room, you have over-contributed.1Canada Revenue Agency. Calculate Your TFSA Contribution Room

The penalty is 1% per month on the highest excess amount for every month it stays in the account.2Justice Laws Website. Income Tax Act – Section 207.02 A $5,000 over-contribution left in for six months costs $300 before you even notice. If you catch the mistake, withdraw the excess right away rather than waiting for the CRA to write to you.3Canada Revenue Agency. If You Over-Contribute to a TFSA

You can check your available room in CRA My Account under the TFSA section, but the figure lags real time. Financial institutions report contributions and withdrawals on an annual cycle, so any deposits you have made in the current year may not yet appear. Track your own contributions and withdrawals in the meantime and subtract current-year deposits manually from whatever CRA My Account displays.

Tax on the Withdrawal

Withdrawals from a TFSA are fully tax-free. The money is not income, you do not report it on your T1 return, and your institution does not issue a T-slip. No T4, no T5, nothing. That treatment covers everything in the account: the original contributions plus any interest, dividends, and capital gains they earned.4Canada Revenue Agency. Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA), Guide for Individuals This is the main structural difference from an RRSP, where every withdrawal generates a T4RSP slip and adds to your taxable income for the year.

Because the withdrawal is not part of your net income, it does not reduce income-tested federal benefits. Old Age Security, the Guaranteed Income Supplement, the GST/HST credit, the Canada Child Benefit, and the Canada Workers Benefit are all calculated on net income, and TFSA withdrawals stay out of that calculation.5Canada Revenue Agency. Tax-Free Savings Account – What Is a TFSA For retirees, that is the practical reason to draw from a TFSA before an RRSP: an RRSP withdrawal can push you past the OAS clawback threshold or reduce your GIS, while a TFSA withdrawal does neither.

You Do Not Need to Tell the CRA

There is no form to file and no call to make. Every TFSA issuer is required to file a TFSA Annual Information Return with the CRA reporting every contribution and withdrawal by day.6Canada Revenue Agency. Tax-Free Savings Account Annual Information Return The CRA uses that data to update your contribution room the following January.

If You Are Moving the TFSA to Another Institution

Do not withdraw the money to move it. Ask your current issuer to send the funds or securities directly to the new issuer as a transfer. A direct transfer between TFSA issuers is not a withdrawal and does not affect your contribution room.7Canada Revenue Agency. How to Contribute to a TFSA

If you withdraw the money, deposit it in your bank account, and then contribute it to the new TFSA in the same year, you will almost certainly over-contribute unless you had that much unused room sitting free. The room from the withdrawal will not come back until January 1. If you have already gone this route by accident, wait until the next calendar year to re-contribute, and accept that your money is outside a tax shelter in the meantime.

If You Live Outside Canada

A non-resident can still withdraw from a TFSA without paying Canadian tax on the withdrawal. New contribution room stops accumulating for any full year you are a non-resident, and any contribution you make while non-resident attracts a 1% monthly tax for as long as the money stays in the account.8Canada Revenue Agency. Non-Resident and TFSA The practical rule while you are abroad: withdraw when you need to, but do not add. Once you re-establish Canadian residency, annual room starts accumulating again.

If You Are a U.S. Citizen or Green Card Holder

The IRS does not treat a TFSA as a tax-sheltered account. Interest, dividends, and capital gains inside the account are fully taxable on your U.S. return each year, even though Canada treats them as tax-free. Because Canada is not taxing that income, there is no Canadian tax to offset the U.S. liability through a foreign tax credit, so the U.S. tax is simply owed.

Many cross-border tax professionals also treat TFSAs as foreign trusts for U.S. purposes, which triggers annual reporting on Forms 3520 and 3520-A, with penalties for non-filing starting at $10,000 per year.9Internal Revenue Service. About Form 3520-A, Annual Information Return of Foreign Trust With a U.S. Owner If your TFSA holds Canadian mutual funds, those may also qualify as passive foreign investment companies and require Form 8621. Talk to a cross-border specialist before you contribute to or withdraw from a TFSA in this situation.