To sell gold for a fair price, you need to know three things before you talk to a buyer: what your item is actually worth as raw metal, which type of buyer fits what you’re selling, and how the IRS will tax any profit. Get those right and you’ll walk away with hundreds or even thousands of dollars more than someone who takes the first offer at a pawn shop.
Figure Out What Your Gold Is Actually Worth
Every gold item’s value starts with purity and weight. Purity is measured in karats: 24k is pure gold, and lower numbers mean the piece is mixed with other metals. In the United States, 10k is the legal minimum for anything sold as gold, and 14k is the most common jewelry grade. A 14k ring is only 58.3 percent gold by weight, so nearly half of what you’re holding isn’t gold at all.1World Gold Council. Gold Jewellery: Colour, Carat and Purity
Look for a small hallmark stamped somewhere discreet, like the inner band of a ring or a necklace clasp. Federal trade rules require any item described as gold to carry a correct karat marking such as “14K,” “14Kt,” or “14 K. Gold.”2Federal Trade Commission. Guides for the Jewelry, Precious Metals, and Pewter Industries A cheap 10x loupe is enough to find them. If your piece has no hallmark, it may be gold-plated rather than solid, which changes its value dramatically.
Gold trades by the troy ounce, not the standard kitchen-scale ounce. A troy ounce is 31.1 grams. To estimate melt value, multiply the item’s weight in troy ounces by the purity percentage, then multiply by the current spot price. If gold trades at $2,500 per troy ounce, a 14k necklace weighing one troy ounce contains about 0.583 troy ounces of pure gold, giving a melt value around $1,458.
Melt, Numismatic, and Retail Are Not the Same Number
Melt value is the floor. Two other numbers sit above it, and confusing them is where first-time sellers lose the most money.
- Melt value: what the raw gold content is worth at spot price.
- Numismatic value: a premium above melt for a coin’s rarity, age, condition, or collector demand. Some gold coins sell for many times their gold content.
- Retail replacement value: what it would cost to buy a similar item from a jeweler. Insurance appraisals use this figure, and it’s always the highest.
If you have gold coins, especially older ones, get them looked at by a coin dealer or numismatist before selling them for scrap. A coin worth $60 in gold could be worth hundreds or thousands to a collector. And don’t confuse an insurance appraisal with what a buyer will pay. Insurance numbers reflect retail replacement, which can run two to three times what you’d actually receive.
Who Buys Gold and What They Pay
Where you sell matters almost as much as what you sell. Each buyer type operates with different margins and expertise.
Pawn Shops
Fastest and typically worst-paying. Pawn shops carry heavy overhead and resale risk, so offers often land well below melt value. They make sense for small scrap items when convenience matters more than squeezing out every dollar.
Coin Shops and Jewelry Stores
Specialized coin dealers bring expertise pawn shops lack, especially for investment-grade bullion and collectible coins. They’re more likely to recognize numismatic premiums. The American Numismatic Association notes that the average retail commission on popular one-ounce gold coins like American Eagles or Maple Leafs runs about five to six percent.3American Numismatic Association. Tips for Buying Gold and Silver Bullion When a dealer buys from you, expect roughly that same spread below spot.
Refineries and Online Buyers
Refineries process gold directly into raw material, so they can afford tighter margins. Large-volume sellers sometimes receive 90 to 95 percent of melt value, though minimum shipment weights often apply. Online buyers are convenient if no specialized dealer is nearby, but you’ll ship your gold and wait for an offer. Get the price locked in writing before shipping, and confirm the return policy if you reject the offer.
Whatever route you take, get at least three quotes before committing. The spread between offers on the same item can be surprisingly wide, and five minutes on the phone can be worth hundreds of dollars.
How Buyers Test Your Gold
Buyers won’t take your word on purity. Expect one of two methods. Acid testing applies a small drop of acid to a scratch mark from the piece; the reaction reveals purity. It’s cheap and reliable but leaves a tiny mark. X-ray fluorescence (XRF) scanning reads the metal’s composition without touching the item, which makes it the better option for finished jewelry and collectible coins.4London Bullion Market Association. A Handheld XRF Scanner
Once purity is confirmed, the buyer calculates an offer based on the spot price minus their commission. If a buyer won’t show you the testing or explain the math behind the number, walk out.
Taxes You’ll Owe on the Sale
This is the part most first-time sellers skip, and it produces the ugliest surprises at tax time. The IRS treats physical gold as a “collectible,” which sits in a higher tax bracket than stocks or real estate.
Capital Gains Rates
If you held the gold more than one year, any profit is taxed at a maximum federal rate of 28 percent, rather than the 15 or 20 percent rate that applies to most other long-term capital gains.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1 – Tax Imposed If you held it a year or less, the gain is taxed as ordinary income at your regular bracket, which could be even higher. State income tax may apply on top.
Calculating Your Gain
Taxable gain equals sale price minus cost basis (what you originally paid, including purchase commissions or sales tax). You report the sale on Form 8949 and carry the totals to Schedule D of Form 1040.6Internal Revenue Service. Publication 544 – Sales and Other Dispositions of Assets If the sale produces a loss, you can deduct capital losses against capital gains, plus up to $3,000 of ordinary income per year.7Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Schedule D (Form 1040)
Inherited or Gifted Gold
Basis rules shift depending on how you got the gold. Inherited gold generally gets a “stepped-up basis” equal to the fair market value on the date the previous owner died, not what they originally paid, which often reduces or eliminates the taxable gain. If someone gave you the gold, your basis for calculating a gain is the donor’s original cost. If you sell for less than fair market value at the time of the gift, your basis for calculating a loss is that lower fair market value instead.8Internal Revenue Service. Publication 551 – Basis of Assets
If you have no records of what the gold originally cost and can’t reconstruct a reasonable basis, the IRS can treat your basis as zero. You’d then owe capital gains on the entire sale amount.
Reporting and Records
You’ll need to show a valid government-issued photo ID at any sale. Anti-money laundering rules and stolen property statutes require dealers to document the identity of anyone selling precious metals. You also need to be at least 18 to enter the contract.
When the Dealer Files a 1099-B
Dealers must file IRS Form 1099-B for certain large transactions. The gold thresholds are narrow:
- Gold bars or rounds of .995 fineness or higher, totaling one kilogram (32.15 troy ounces) or more
- 25 or more one-ounce Krugerrands
- 25 or more one-ounce Canadian Maple Leafs
- 25 or more one-ounce Mexican Onzas
American Gold Eagles and most other common gold coins aren’t on that list. A sale under these thresholds won’t generate a 1099-B, but you still owe tax on any profit. No form doesn’t mean no tax.
What to Keep
The IRS expects you to hold records that support your cost basis.8Internal Revenue Service. Publication 551 – Basis of Assets For gold, that includes original purchase receipts showing price and any premiums, shipping, or sales tax; inheritance documents such as estate valuations or Schedule A from Form 8971; gift records showing the donor’s original price and fair market value on the gift date; and the final sale receipt showing date, weight, purity, price per ounce, and total payment. Keep them at least three years after filing the return that reports the sale, and longer if the amounts are substantial.
Avoiding Scams
Gold buying is loosely regulated, and that attracts bad actors. Check credentials before selling. Professional Numismatists Guild membership requires at least five years of experience and a clean ethical record. The American Numismatic Association can expel members who violate its code of ethics. A strong Better Business Bureau rating adds another layer. Some states also require gold dealers to register, so check whether yours does and verify the dealer on the list.
Watch for these red flags, especially with mail-in services:
- Offers far below spot. Pawn shops pay below melt, but 50 percent of spot is predatory.
- Pressure to decide immediately. Legitimate dealers give you time.
- No verifiable address or contact information.
- Refusal to explain testing or pricing. A professional should walk you through the purity test, the weight reading, and the math.
- Wire-transfer-only payment. Wires are irreversible; a buyer who refuses checks is limiting your recourse.
The single best protection is boring but effective: know your melt value and collect three quotes. A lowball offer becomes obvious the moment you have something to compare it to.
Shipping Gold Safely
If you sell to an online buyer or refinery, how you ship matters as much as who you ship to. Most reputable online buyers send a prepaid, insured label, but check the coverage amount. Some labels only cover a fraction of the shipment’s value.
USPS Registered Mail offers insurance up to $50,000 with a chain-of-custody tracking system.9USPS. Registered Mail – The Basics Compensation is capped at $50,000 even if you declare a higher value.10USPS. Insurance and Extra Services FedEx and UPS also offer high-value options, and some buyers specify which carrier to use.
Before shipping, photograph every item alongside a written description of its weight and purity. Save the tracking number and all correspondence. Once the buyer receives the package, they’ll test, weigh, and present a final offer. If the offer differs significantly from your own calculation, ask for an itemized breakdown. Reputable buyers will return your gold at their expense if you reject the offer, and they’ll put that in writing before you ship. Any buyer who won’t isn’t worth the risk.