How to Sell on Consignment: Agreements, UCC, and Taxes

To sell on consignment, you hand goods to a shop that displays and sells them for you, keeps a commission on the sale, and pays you the rest; ownership stays with you until a buyer pays. Commission splits usually land between 40/60 and 60/40 depending on the item and the store. The steps that protect you are the ones sellers most often skip: documenting what you own, signing a written agreement with clear terms, and — for higher-value goods — filing a UCC-1 so the shop’s creditors can’t reach your property.

What to Bring to the Intake Appointment

Walk in with proof of what you own and what it’s worth. For designer handbags, fine art, or antique furniture, that means original receipts, certificates of authenticity, or appraisal reports. Many shops that handle luxury goods won’t accept an item without third-party verification, and services like Entrupy and Real Authentication issue certificates that carry weight with buyers.

For everyday clothing, electronics, or home décor, a written description of each piece covering brand, age, condition, and any defects is usually enough. Photograph everything before you hand it over. Those photos are your proof of condition at the moment of transfer if the item is later damaged or disputed.

Do your own pricing research before the appointment. Check recent sold prices for comparable items on resale platforms so you can set a realistic minimum. Shops negotiate more willingly with a seller who arrives with data.

Essential Terms in a Consignment Agreement

Never consign without a written contract. A handshake deal leaves you exposed if the shop closes, loses your property, or simply doesn’t pay. Read every clause, and pay particular attention to any language that lets the shop donate or dispose of unsold items after a deadline. Push back on anything vague.

  • Commission split. The shop’s cut typically runs 40% to 60% of the final sale price. The exact number depends on the item category, the shop’s overhead and traffic, and how sought-after your goods are. Sellers with in-demand products or a track record can negotiate.
  • Listing duration. Most agreements run 60 to 90 days. Some auto-renew; others require you to retrieve unsold items by a set date.
  • Markdown schedule. Many shops reduce the price after a set number of days. A common structure is 20% off after 30 days, with a further cut after 60. Confirm whether markdowns need your approval or happen automatically.
  • Insurance and loss. The contract should say who bears the risk if an item is stolen, damaged by a customer, or destroyed in a fire. Some shops insure consigned inventory; others push that risk onto you. If the agreement is silent, assume you’re unprotected.
  • Return policy pass-through. If the shop lets buyers return purchases, find out whether that window delays or reduces your payment. A 30-day buyer return policy means your sale isn’t final until it closes.

Protecting High-Value Goods Under the UCC

This is the part most casual sellers miss. Under the Uniform Commercial Code, a “consignment” has a specific legal meaning: the goods must be worth $1,000 or more at delivery, the shop must be a merchant that deals in goods of that kind, and the shop must not be generally known by its creditors as selling other people’s property.1Legal Information Institute. UCC 9-102 – Definitions and Index of Definitions If your deal fits that definition, Article 9 governs your rights, and the default rule cuts against you.

Under UCC § 9-319, if you haven’t perfected your ownership interest, the shop’s creditors can treat your consigned goods as if they belong to the shop.2Legal Information Institute. UCC 9-319 – Rights and Title of Consignee With Respect to Creditors and Purchasers If the shop gets sued, falls behind on debts, or files for bankruptcy, a creditor or bankruptcy trustee can seize and liquidate your property to pay the shop’s obligations. You’d stand in line as an unsecured creditor for pennies on the dollar.

Filing a UCC-1 Financing Statement

To prevent that, file a UCC-1 financing statement with the appropriate state filing office, usually the Secretary of State where the shop is organized. This is the same form lenders use to record security interests in personal property. You can file it yourself without the shop’s signature, provided you have a signed consignment agreement describing the goods. Filing fees are modest, generally $5 to $20 depending on the state.

For high-value consignments, this step is not optional. A perfected interest makes you a secured creditor with priority over the shop’s general creditors and the right to reclaim your property in bankruptcy. If the shop already has a lender with a blanket lien on its inventory, send that lender written notice describing your consigned goods before the shop takes possession. Skipping that notification can leave your filing subordinate to the existing lien.

When the UCC Rules Don’t Apply

If the goods are worth less than $1,000 per item, Article 9’s consignment rules don’t apply and you can’t file a UCC-1 for protection. Your rights then depend on general contract and bailment law, which varies by state. That makes the written agreement your primary protection for lower-value items.

Items You Can’t Legally Consign

Federal law bars selling any consumer product that has been recalled or that fails a mandatory safety standard. Under 15 U.S.C. § 2068, it’s unlawful to sell, offer for sale, or distribute a product subject to a voluntary corrective action taken with the Consumer Product Safety Commission, or one that has been ordered recalled.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 USC 2068 – Prohibited Acts The rule applies to individual sellers as well as shops.

The CPSC’s guidance for resellers is that hazardous, non-compliant, or recalled products should be destroyed rather than sold or given away.4Consumer Product Safety Commission. Resellers Guide to Selling Safer Products Before consigning children’s products, small appliances, or older electronics, check the recall database at cpsc.gov/recalls. Most reputable shops screen for recalls at intake, but the legal responsibility doesn’t disappear because a shop accepted the item.

Getting Paid

Payment timing varies more than sellers expect. Some shops pay within a week of a sale; others batch monthly, or hold funds for 15 to 30 days to cover buyer returns. The contract should spell out the schedule. If it doesn’t, ask, and get the answer in writing before you consign.

Payment methods usually include direct deposit, mailed checks, or store credit. Your share is the gross sale price minus the shop’s commission and any fees named in the contract. When you consign, keep the consignment receipt or inventory log the shop issues at intake. That document lists each item, the agreed minimum price, and the delivery date, and it’s your primary evidence that the shop holds your property under the terms of your agreement.

Picking Up Unsold Items

When the listing period ends without a sale, you’ll usually have a short window to retrieve your property. Many contracts allow 7 to 14 days. Miss it and the consequences range from storage fees to loss of the goods: some agreements let the shop donate, dispose of, or claim ownership of unsold items. Courts have upheld those forfeiture clauses where the contract language was clear and the seller had notice.

If you can’t collect in person, arrange for someone else to pick up and confirm with the shop that they’ll release items to a third party. Set a calendar reminder the day you sign the contract. This is one of the most common ways sellers lose property they never meant to give up.

Taxes on Consignment Income

Money you earn through consignment is taxable, but the treatment depends on whether you’re selling occasionally or running a business.

Cleaning Out the Closet

If you’re consigning used clothing, furniture, or household goods, you only owe tax if you sell an item for more than you originally paid for it, which rarely happens with used personal property. Any gain is a capital gain.5Internal Revenue Service. Publication 544 (2025), Sales and Other Dispositions of Assets Losses on personal-use property are not deductible. If you paid $200 for a jacket and consigned it for $50, you can’t claim the $150 difference as a loss.

Selling With Regularity

If you consign with continuity and regularity, such as a maker selling handcrafted jewelry through multiple shops or someone buying items specifically to resell, the IRS treats that as a business. You report the income on Schedule C and owe self-employment tax on the net profit.6Internal Revenue Service. 2025 Instructions for Schedule C (Form 1040) You can also deduct related expenses: cost of goods, authentication fees, shipping, and mileage to drop off inventory.

Form 1099-K

If the shop pays you through a payment card or third-party payment network, you may receive a Form 1099-K. For payment card transactions there’s no minimum threshold; you’ll get a 1099-K regardless of the amount. For third-party settlement organizations like PayPal or Venmo, the reporting threshold is $20,000 and more than 200 transactions in a calendar year.7Internal Revenue Service. IRS Issues FAQs on Form 1099-K Threshold Under the One, Big, Beautiful Bill Not receiving a 1099-K doesn’t make the income tax-free; you still have to report it.

Keep records of every consignment sale, including the original purchase price of each item. Those records are the only way to calculate your actual gain or loss, and they’re what you’ll need if the IRS ever questions a return.