How to Record a 1031 Exchange on Books: Entries, Boot, Form 8824

Recording a 1031 exchange on your books takes a sequence of journal entries that remove the relinquished property, hold the sale proceeds in a Qualified Intermediary account, recognize any boot as gain, and place the replacement property on the ledger at its purchase price reduced by the deferred gain. That final reduction is the entry people miss most often, and it’s the one that keeps depreciation and future gain calculations correct. Federal tax law doesn’t erase the gain in a 1031 exchange; it embeds it in a lower basis for the new property, which means smaller depreciation deductions and a larger taxable gain on any eventual non-exchange sale.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 1031 – Exchange of Real Property Held for Productive Use or Investment Get the entries wrong and the balance sheet overstates the new asset, depreciation runs too high, and the numbers won’t tie to Form 8824 at tax time.2Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 8824

Start With the Adjusted Basis of the Relinquished Property

Every entry that follows depends on this number, so pull it before closing day. Take the original purchase price plus any capitalized closing costs, add capital improvements made over the years, and subtract accumulated depreciation.3Internal Revenue Service. Topic No. 703, Basis of Assets

A running example makes the entries concrete. You bought a rental for $500,000 and have claimed $150,000 in depreciation, so the adjusted basis is $350,000. The property sells for $900,000, a $200,000 mortgage is paid off at closing, and the Qualified Intermediary receives the remaining $700,000. Realized gain is $550,000 ($900,000 minus $350,000).

Journal Entry to Record the Sale of the Relinquished Property

On the closing date, one compound entry does four jobs: it removes the asset at its original cost, clears the accumulated depreciation, pays off the mortgage, and creates a temporary asset account for the funds the QI is holding. The realized gain lands in a temporary liability account until the exchange resolves.

Account Debit Credit
Accumulated Depreciation $150,000
Mortgage Payable $200,000
Exchange Proceeds Held by QI $700,000
Land & Building – Relinquished Property $500,000
Deferred Gain – 1031 Exchange $550,000

Both sides total $1,050,000. The QI holding account is a short-lived asset that will zero out when the replacement property is acquired. The Deferred Gain account is a temporary liability that will either reduce the basis of the new property in full or be partly reclassified to recognized income if boot appears. Both accounts should be empty once the exchange closes.

One trap at this stage: tenant security deposits and prorated rents need to flow through the QI, not be credited directly to the buyer at closing. Money credited outside the exchange counts as cash you received, which becomes taxable boot. Put a prorations clause in the purchase contract that routes those amounts through the intermediary.

How Closing Costs Enter the Entry

Broker commissions on the sale, QI fees, title insurance, escrow fees, and transfer taxes can be paid from exchange funds without triggering constructive receipt. They simply reduce the balance in the Exchange Proceeds Held by QI account. If commissions of $45,000 and QI fees of $5,000 come out at closing, the QI account carries $650,000 instead of $700,000, and the deferred gain shrinks accordingly.2Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 8824

Loan costs are different. Points, origination fees, prorated mortgage insurance, and lender-required appraisals are costs of obtaining financing on the new property, not costs of the exchange. A useful test: if the expense would vanish in an all-cash purchase, it’s a loan cost. Don’t roll it into the replacement property’s basis for exchange purposes.

Journal Entry When Boot Creates Recognized Gain

A fully deferred exchange happens only when you receive nothing but like-kind property. Cash returned by the QI, and net debt relief when the replacement mortgage is smaller than the relinquished mortgage, both count as boot and force recognition of gain up to the amount of boot received. Recognized gain can never exceed realized gain, and losses are not recognized in a 1031 exchange.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 1031 – Exchange of Real Property Held for Productive Use or Investment

Boot appears in two forms. Cash boot is any net cash the QI returns to you or that gets diverted out of the exchange along the way. Mortgage boot is the net reduction in your liabilities when the old mortgage exceeds the new one. In the running example, taking on a $300,000 replacement mortgage against a $200,000 old mortgage produces no mortgage boot. Taking on only $100,000 of new debt produces $100,000 of mortgage boot, and $100,000 of the $550,000 realized gain becomes recognized. Injecting additional cash into the exchange can offset mortgage boot dollar for dollar.

When boot exists, reclassify the recognized portion out of the deferred gain account:

Account Debit Credit
Deferred Gain – 1031 Exchange $100,000
Recognized Gain – 1031 Exchange $100,000

The recognized amount flows to the income statement and creates a current-year tax liability. The remaining deferred gain stays in the temporary liability account and will reduce the replacement property’s basis. Skip this entry entirely on a clean, fully deferred exchange.

Journal Entries to Acquire the Replacement Property

When the replacement property closes, use two entries. Assume a fully deferred exchange, a $1,000,000 replacement property funded by the $700,000 in the QI account and a new $300,000 mortgage.

First, record the acquisition at full purchase price:

Account Debit Credit
Land & Building – Replacement Property $1,000,000
Exchange Proceeds Held by QI $700,000
Mortgage Payable $300,000

This zeros out the QI holding account and records the new debt. Additional cash contributed at closing would credit the Cash account for that amount.

Second, embed the deferred gain by reducing the asset’s book value to the carryover basis:

Account Debit Credit
Deferred Gain – 1031 Exchange $550,000
Land & Building – Replacement Property $550,000

After this entry, the replacement property sits on the books at $450,000, the deferred gain account is empty, and the QI account is closed. The $450,000 book value equals the old adjusted basis of $350,000 plus the $100,000 of net new investment ($300,000 new mortgage minus $200,000 old mortgage).1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 1031 – Exchange of Real Property Held for Productive Use or Investment

That lower basis is the entire point. The $550,000 gain didn’t vanish; it’s now inside the replacement property as a smaller depreciable base and a larger future gain. Leave the property on the books at $1,000,000 and you’ll overclaim depreciation and understate tax for years.

Set Up Depreciation on the Replacement Property

Depreciation after the exchange isn’t a fresh schedule at the new basis. The IRS splits the basis into two layers, each depreciated separately.4Internal Revenue Service. Notice 2000-4, Exchange of MACRS Property for MACRS Property

  • Carryover basis, up to the adjusted basis of the relinquished property, continues on the old property’s schedule. Same method, same convention, same remaining recovery period. In the example, $350,000 keeps depreciating on whatever schedule the old property was on, for whatever years were left.
  • Excess basis, meaning the portion of the new book value above the old adjusted basis, is treated as a new asset. It gets a fresh recovery period (27.5 years for residential rental, 39 years for commercial) and its own method. In the example, the $100,000 excess basis begins a new schedule.

Some smaller operations run one blended schedule over the entire new basis. That approach does not technically comply with the IRS rules. Before you calculate either layer, separate land from depreciable improvements; land is never depreciable, and a 1031 exchange doesn’t change that.

Tie the Ledger to Form 8824

The bookkeeping and the tax filing pull from the same numbers. The exchange is reported on Form 8824, attached to the return for the year the relinquished property was transferred.5Internal Revenue Service. Form 8824 – Like-Kind Exchanges Line 18 captures adjusted basis of the relinquished property plus exchange expenses and any net cash or debt contributed. Line 24 shows the deferred gain. Line 25 produces the basis of the like-kind property received.2Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 8824 If the journal entries are clean, those figures should match the general ledger exactly. When they don’t, the replacement property is usually sitting on the books at the wrong value.

What Happens on the Books if the Exchange Fails

Two deadlines govern every deferred exchange: 45 days to identify replacement property in writing, and 180 days to close (or by the due date of the return, whichever comes first). Missing either turns the transaction into a fully taxable sale.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 1031 – Exchange of Real Property Held for Productive Use or Investment

At the ledger level, a failed exchange means reversing the deferred gain entry and recording an ordinary taxable sale. The Deferred Gain account is reclassified to recognized gain, and the funds move from the QI holding account into the regular cash account when the intermediary returns them. Until the replacement property actually closes, treat both temporary accounts as provisional; a memo note or sub-ledger flag helps whoever reviews the books later understand that the deferral is contingent.

Related-party exchanges add a two-year holding requirement: if either side disposes of the exchanged property within two years, the deferred gain snaps back and becomes taxable in the year of that early sale. On the books, the entries look identical to any other 1031 exchange, but carry a contingent liability note for two years so the deferral doesn’t get forgotten if a disposition triggers it.

Bookkeeping Mistakes That Show Up Later

A handful of errors turn up repeatedly, and each one distorts the numbers for years.

Recording the replacement property at purchase price and skipping the basis adjustment entry is the most common. The books look clean in the exchange year, but depreciation runs too high every year after, and the eventual sale calculation is wrong in both directions. This entry doesn’t correspond to any cash movement, which is exactly why it gets forgotten. It’s the most important one in the sequence.

Failing to separate land from depreciable improvements on the replacement property inflates depreciation. If $200,000 of a $1,000,000 replacement is land, only the improvement portion, net of the allocated deferred gain, goes on a depreciation schedule.

Treating loan costs as exchange expenses inflates both basis and future depreciation. Points and origination fees on the new mortgage are not part of the exchange.

Leaving the Exchange Proceeds Held by QI and Deferred Gain accounts open after the exchange closes clutters the balance sheet. Both should be zero once the replacement property is on the books at the carryover basis.