How to Reconcile Pay Stubs and Year-End Earnings With Your W-2

To reconcile your pay stubs with your W-2, line up your final year-to-date pay stub next to the W-2 and work box by box, accounting for pre-tax deductions that lower federal taxable wages, taxable fringe benefits that raise them, and the Social Security wage cap that can hold Box 3 below your actual earnings. Most apparent mismatches turn out to be correct once you follow the money through those adjustments. The ones that remain are real errors, and payroll can fix them with a corrected W-2 if you bring specific numbers.

Documents You Need Before You Start

Pull three records together: your final pay stub of the year, any year-end earnings summary your employer provides, and your W-2. The final pay stub shows cumulative totals for gross pay, each type of deduction, and each category of tax withheld across all twelve months. The year-end summary, which some employers issue separately, often breaks out categories the regular pay stub lumps together, such as the taxable portion of fringe benefits or employer retirement contributions.

Most employees can download these from a company payroll portal. If your employer uses a third-party payroll service, the records may live on that provider’s website instead.

Reconciling Box 1 Against Your Gross Pay

Box 1 reports your total taxable wages, tips, and other compensation for federal income tax. It almost always differs from the gross pay on your final pay stub, because certain deductions come out before federal tax applies. The basic formula is simple: start with gross pay, subtract all pre-tax deductions, and you should land on the Box 1 figure.

The most common pre-tax subtractions are traditional 401(k) or 403(b) contributions and health insurance premiums paid through a cafeteria plan.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 125 – Cafeteria Plans If your pay stub shows you contributed $8,000 to a traditional 401(k) and $3,600 to employer-sponsored health coverage, your Box 1 wages should be $11,600 less than your gross pay.

When the math still doesn’t add up, check whether your employer added taxable fringe benefits to Box 1. The cost of group-term life insurance coverage above $50,000, for example, gets included in taxable wages even though you never received that money as cash.2Internal Revenue Service. Group-Term Life Insurance Personal use of a company vehicle is another common addition; your employer must calculate the taxable value of that personal use and include it in Box 1.3Internal Revenue Service. Publication 15-B (2026), Employer’s Tax Guide to Fringe Benefits These items push Box 1 higher than paycheck math alone would predict, and they’re the usual culprit when people assume their W-2 overstates their income.

Using Box 12 Codes to Trace the Difference

Box 12 is where your employer reports specific deductions and benefits using letter codes. These codes are your best tool for tracing exactly which pre-tax items were subtracted from gross pay before arriving at Box 1. The ones you’ll see most often:

  • Code D: traditional 401(k) contributions. This amount should match your year-to-date 401(k) withholding on the final pay stub.
  • Code E: 403(b) plan contributions, common among public school and nonprofit employees.
  • Code W: employer and employee contributions to a health savings account.
  • Code DD: the total cost of employer-sponsored health coverage. Informational only, not taxable.
  • Code AA: designated Roth contributions to a 401(k). Unlike Code D, these are made with after-tax dollars and are already included in Box 1.

The distinction between Code D and Code AA is where reconciliation often stalls. A traditional 401(k) deferral reduces Box 1; a Roth 401(k) deferral does not. If your pay stub shows $6,000 in retirement contributions but Box 1 only dropped by $4,000, check whether $2,000 went to a Roth account. Your W-2 can show up to four Box 12 entries; if you have more, your employer should issue a second W-2 for the additional codes.4Internal Revenue Service. 2026 General Instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3

Why Box 1 and Box 3 Usually Differ

Finding that Box 1 (federal taxable wages) and Box 3 (Social Security wages) show different amounts is normal, and the difference can run in either direction depending on your situation.

Traditional 401(k) contributions reduce Box 1 but not Box 3. Retirement deferrals are exempt from federal income tax but still subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes. If you earned $80,000 and deferred $10,000 to a traditional 401(k), Box 1 shows $70,000 while Box 3 shows $80,000. Working the other way, if you earned above the Social Security wage base of $184,500 for 2026, Box 3 caps at that amount while Box 1 keeps climbing, because federal income tax has no wage ceiling.5Social Security Administration. Contribution and Benefit Base

A mismatch between these two boxes is usually evidence that your employer got the math right, not wrong.

Verifying Social Security and Medicare Withholding

Social Security tax is 6.2% of wages, and Medicare tax is 1.45%.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 3101 – Rate of Tax The check is straightforward multiplication:

  • Social Security: multiply Box 3 by 0.062. The result should match Box 4.
  • Medicare: multiply Box 5 by 0.0145. The result should match Box 6.

Social Security tax applies only up to the wage base, which is $184,500 for 2026.7Social Security Administration. Maximum Taxable Earnings If you earned more, Box 3 should cap at $184,500 and Box 4 should be no more than $11,439. Medicare has no wage ceiling, so Box 5 typically matches or exceeds Box 3.

An extra 0.9% Medicare tax kicks in once your wages pass a threshold tied to your filing status: $200,000 for single filers, $250,000 for married filing jointly, and $125,000 for married filing separately.8Internal Revenue Service. Topic No. 560, Additional Medicare Tax Your employer starts withholding this additional tax once your pay exceeds $200,000 for the year, regardless of your actual filing status. If you’re married filing jointly and neither spouse individually crosses $200,000 but your combined income exceeds $250,000, you may owe additional Medicare tax when you file. If you’re married filing separately with wages of $180,000, your employer won’t withhold the extra tax, but you’ll owe it on the $55,000 above your $125,000 threshold.

If you worked for more than one employer during the year, each one withholds Social Security tax independently, and neither knows what the other withheld. Add up Box 4 across all your W-2s; if the total exceeds $11,439 for 2026, claim the excess as a refundable credit on your return.7Social Security Administration. Maximum Taxable Earnings

Checking Box 2 Against Your Pay Stub

Box 2 shows the total federal income tax your employer withheld across the year. Compare it directly to the year-to-date federal withholding on your final pay stub. Unlike the other boxes, Box 2 involves no adjustments or wage-base calculations. It’s simply the sum of every federal income tax deduction from every paycheck, so the two figures should match exactly.

If they don’t, the usual explanations are a mid-year W-4 change applied to the wrong pay period, or a bonus withheld at a flat supplemental rate rather than your regular rate. Pull your individual pay stubs and add up the federal withholding line by line. Tedious, but it’s the only reliable way to find where the numbers diverge.

Reading Box 14 and the State Boxes

Box 14 is a catch-all where employers report items that don’t fit elsewhere. Employers label each entry, but the labels aren’t standardized, so you may see abbreviations that aren’t immediately obvious. Common entries include state disability insurance withholdings, union dues, uniform allowances, and after-tax pension contributions.4Internal Revenue Service. 2026 General Instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3 Some of these entries matter for your state return even though they don’t affect federal taxes. If you see an entry you don’t recognize, ask your payroll department what it represents before assuming it’s wrong.

State and local information appears in Boxes 15 through 17. Box 15 identifies the state and your employer’s state tax ID. Box 16 shows state taxable wages, and Box 17 shows state income tax withheld. If you live in one state and work in another, you may see two state entries on the same W-2 or receive separate W-2s for each state. Compare Box 17 to the state withholding total on your final pay stub, the same way you compared Box 2 for federal.

A Reconciliation Walkthrough

Say your final pay stub shows $85,000 in gross pay. During the year, you contributed $6,000 to a traditional 401(k), paid $4,200 in employer-sponsored health insurance through a cafeteria plan, and your employer provided $75,000 in group-term life insurance (so $25,000 above the $50,000 exempt threshold, with a taxable cost of $63 in this example). The W-2 boxes should break down as follows:

  • Box 1 (federal taxable wages): $85,000 − $6,000 (401(k)) − $4,200 (health) + $63 (life insurance above $50,000) = $74,863.
  • Box 3 (Social Security wages): $85,000 − $4,200 (health) + $63 = $80,863. The 401(k) contribution does not reduce this figure.
  • Box 4 (Social Security tax): $80,863 × 0.062 = $5,013.51.
  • Box 5 (Medicare wages): $80,863, same as Box 3 here.
  • Box 6 (Medicare tax): $80,863 × 0.0145 = $1,172.51.
  • Box 12, Code D: $6,000.

If any of these figures don’t match what you calculate from your own numbers, you now know exactly which deduction or benefit to investigate. The life insurance addition is small in this example, but that’s where reconciliation errors hide most often: in the additions people forget to account for, not the subtractions.

When the Numbers Still Don’t Match

Start with your payroll or human resources department. Most discrepancies trace to a data entry mistake, a benefits change that took effect on the wrong date, or a fringe benefit that was miscategorized. Give payroll specific information: which box is wrong, what number you expected, and how you arrived at that figure. Vague complaints go to the bottom of the pile.

If your employer agrees an error occurred, they issue Form W-2c, the corrected wage and tax statement, which updates the figures originally reported to the Social Security Administration and the IRS.9Internal Revenue Service. About Form W-2c, Corrected Wage and Tax Statements You should also receive corrected copies. If the correction arrives after you’ve already filed your return, amend using Form 1040-X.

If your employer refuses to issue a correction or doesn’t respond, the IRS can step in. Call 800-829-1040 after the end of February, and an IRS representative will contact your employer directly to request the corrected form.10Internal Revenue Service. W-2 – Additional, Incorrect, Lost, Non-Receipt, Omitted

If the filing deadline is approaching and you still don’t have a correct W-2, file using Form 4852, a substitute for the W-2.11Internal Revenue Service. About Form 4852, Substitute for Form W-2, Wage and Tax Statement You estimate wages and withholdings using your pay stubs and year-end earnings statement, explain on the form how you arrived at those figures, and attach it to your return. If the actual W-2 shows up later with different numbers, file an amended return with Form 1040-X. Be accurate with your estimates. The IRS can impose a 20% accuracy-related penalty on any underpayment caused by negligence or careless errors, so working from your best available records rather than guessing matters.12Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 6662 – Imposition of Accuracy-Related Penalty on Underpayments