To get a stock certificate for shares you own in a public company, you submit a request to the company’s transfer agent, provide your registration details, and pay a fee that generally runs between $25 and $150 per certificate. For private company shares, the request goes to the corporate secretary rather than a transfer agent. The process is straightforward on paper, but three things catch people off guard: many companies no longer issue paper at all, selling the shares later requires extra steps, and losing the certificate is expensive to fix.
First, Confirm the Company Still Issues Paper
A growing number of public companies have moved to book-entry-only issuance. Your ownership is recorded electronically on the transfer agent’s books, and a paper certificate simply is not available at any price. Before you fill out any forms, call the transfer agent or check the investor relations page on the company’s website to confirm paper is still an option.
The SEC has noted that investors “might be able to choose” to receive a physical certificate, acknowledging that the choice depends on the issuer’s policies.1U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Investor Bulletin: Holding Your Securities If the company has gone fully electronic, your alternative is the Direct Registration System, which puts shares in your name on the transfer agent’s books without producing paper. DRS typically carries no fee and gives you the same direct relationship with the issuer that a certificate does.2FINRA. Know the Facts About Direct Registered Shares
Find the Transfer Agent
The transfer agent is the institution that maintains the company’s official shareholder records and is the only party that can issue a certificate for public shares. You can find the transfer agent’s name on the company’s investor relations page, in the annual report (Form 10-K filed with the SEC), or by calling the company directly.3U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Transfer Agents The largest U.S. transfer agents include Computershare, Equiniti Trust Company, and Continental Stock Transfer.
Gather Your Documents and Fees
Once you have the transfer agent, you need four things to submit a request:
- A certificate request form, sometimes called a Letter of Transmittal. It is usually available on the transfer agent’s website; some agents also accept requests by phone or online portal.
- Your exact registration details. Your full legal name must match your brokerage statement precisely. Any mismatch in name, address, or Social Security number will delay or reject the request.
- Your account number and the exact number of shares you want withdrawn from electronic form into a physical certificate.
- Payment. The transfer agent fee generally runs $25 to $150 per certificate. If your shares currently sit in a brokerage account in street name, your broker may charge a separate outbound transfer fee, which can run $100 or more.
If your shares are held in street name, you will usually need to move them first to the transfer agent through a DRS transfer before the paper certificate can be issued. Your brokerage initiates this transfer using the Deposit/Withdrawal at Custodian (DWAC) system. Call your broker to start it and ask about their specific fees and timing.
What Happens After You Submit
The transfer agent verifies your share balance against its records and confirms the shares are unencumbered — not pledged as collateral, subject to a hold, or otherwise restricted. Once that check clears, the agent withdraws the shares from electronic form and prints the certificate.
From submission to delivery, expect two to six weeks. The certificate is typically shipped by a tracked delivery service to reduce the risk of loss in transit. The shares will disappear from your brokerage or DRS balance once the certificate is issued. They are not in limbo at that point; they exist on the paper in your hands, and safeguarding it is now your job.
Private Company Shares Work Differently
Private companies rarely use a transfer agent. The company handles share records internally, usually through the corporate secretary who maintains the capitalization table and stock transfer book.
Start by reviewing your stock purchase agreement or shareholders’ agreement. These documents spell out your right to receive a certificate and any restrictions on the shares. You then submit a written request, and the board of directors or an authorized officer approves issuance. A private company certificate typically carries signatures from at least two officers, usually the president and secretary, and many companies still emboss a corporate seal.
Expect a restrictive legend printed on the face of the certificate. The SEC notes that for restricted securities acquired through a private placement, you will “almost always” receive a certificate stamped with a restrictive legend indicating the shares may not be resold unless registered or exempt from registration.4U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Rule 144: Selling Restricted and Control Securities Removing that legend later, when the shares become eligible for resale, is governed by state law rather than federal law.
What Changes Once You Hold the Paper
A physical certificate changes how you interact with the company in a few ways worth understanding before you commit.
Dividends come directly to you from the issuer or transfer agent, either by check mailed to the address on file or by direct deposit, depending on your instructions.1U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Investor Bulletin: Holding Your Securities Proxy statements, annual reports, and other corporate communications also come straight to you. If you move, notify the transfer agent immediately. The company has no other way to reach you, and undeliverable mail is one of the triggers that starts the clock on escheatment.
Cost basis tracking becomes your responsibility. When shares sit in a brokerage account, the broker tracks your purchase price and holding period for tax reporting. Once the shares are withdrawn as a physical certificate, that recordkeeping falls entirely on you. Keep documentation of what you paid per share and when you acquired them, because you will need those figures to calculate capital gains when you sell.
Selling or Transferring the Certificate Later
You cannot simply call a broker and sell shares represented by a paper certificate. The certificate has to be converted back to electronic form or delivered with proper endorsement documentation before anyone will transact.
Depositing the Certificate With a Broker
To sell, you generally deposit the certificate into a brokerage account, which converts it back to electronic form. The process varies by firm. Some brokerages affiliated with banks let you drop the certificate at a branch; others require you to mail it or first convert it to DRS through the transfer agent. The round trip can take several weeks, during which you cannot trade those shares. In a market that settles trades within one business day, that delay can be costly if you are trying to hit a particular price.
Medallion Signature Guarantee
Transferring ownership of a physical certificate, whether to sell, gift, or re-register the shares, requires a Medallion Signature Guarantee. This is not a notary stamp. A Medallion Guarantee is a special authentication from a financial institution that confirms your identity, verifies your signature, and certifies that you have legal authority to transfer the shares. Transfer agents are authorized by SEC rules to reject transfers that do not include one from an approved program participant.
Getting one can be harder than people expect. Only financial institutions enrolled in an approved Medallion program (STAMP, SEMP, or MSP are the common ones) can issue the guarantee, and participation is concentrated among larger banks and brokerages. If you do not have an account at a participating institution, you may need to open one. The guarantee also carries a dollar limit tied to the institution’s bond, so a high-value transfer may require finding an institution with a larger bond amount.
Stock Power Forms
When transferring shares represented by a physical certificate, you typically complete a stock power form instead of endorsing the back of the certificate. The stock power identifies the shares, the number being transferred, the cost basis, and the new owner’s details including tax identification number. The original certificate is sent along with the completed form, and the Medallion Guarantee goes on the stock power to authenticate your signature.
If You Lose the Certificate
Losing a stock certificate is expensive but not catastrophic. The Uniform Commercial Code provides a replacement framework. Under UCC Section 8-405, the issuer must issue a new certificate if the owner requests it before a good-faith purchaser acquires the original, files a sufficient indemnity bond, and meets any other reasonable requirements the issuer imposes.5Legal Information Institute. UCC 8-405 – Replacement of Lost, Destroyed, or Wrongfully Taken Security Certificate
The practical sequence runs like this:
- Notify the transfer agent immediately and request a stop transfer on the missing certificate. This flags the certificate number as invalid and prevents anyone from using it to transfer or sell the shares.
- File an affidavit of loss. This notarized document describes when you last saw the certificate, how it went missing, and declares that you have not sold or pledged the shares. Notary fees typically run $2 to $25 depending on your state.
- Purchase an indemnity bond. The bond protects the transfer agent in case the original surfaces and someone claims to be a legitimate holder. It typically costs 2% to 3% of the current market value of the shares. For a $50,000 position, that is $1,000 to $1,500 out of pocket just for the bond.
- Pay the transfer agent’s replacement processing fee.
Once the agent has your affidavit, bond, and fees, it cancels the old certificate and issues a replacement. The timeline resembles a new issuance, usually a few weeks, though cases involving estates or disputed ownership can take much longer.
Escheatment: The Cost of Doing Nothing
Physical certificates create a risk electronic holders rarely face. If the transfer agent cannot reach you, because you moved, because dividend checks go uncashed, or because you simply stop making contact, the shares can eventually be turned over to a state government as unclaimed property.
The dormancy period before escheatment kicks in varies by state. Currently, 33 jurisdictions use a three-year dormancy period, 18 use five years, and one uses seven years.6Computershare. Escheatment and Unclaimed Property: How Shareholder Property is Turned Over to the States The clock starts from your last contact with the transfer agent or issuer. When property is escheated, accumulated dividends and other rights tied to the shares typically go with them.
Resetting the clock takes very little effort. Cash a dividend check, log into your account, respond to a mailing, or call the transfer agent to confirm your address. If your shares have already been escheated, you can usually reclaim them through your state’s unclaimed property office, though the process can take months and the shares may have been liquidated in the meantime.