To calculate bad debt expense, choose one of three methods: the direct write-off method, the percentage of credit sales method, or the accounts receivable aging method. The direct write-off method is the only one the IRS accepts for a tax deduction. The other two are estimation methods used for financial reporting under Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), and many businesses run both — an estimation method for the books and the direct write-off for the tax return.
What You Need Before You Start
Accurate numbers depend on clean source data. Pull these from your general ledger and sales journals:
- Total credit sales for the period, separated from cash sales. Only credit sales carry non-payment risk.
- The current accounts receivable balance.
- An aging schedule showing how long each unpaid invoice has been outstanding.
- Historical records of past uncollectible amounts, which give you the loss percentages the estimation methods rely on.
- The current balance of your allowance for doubtful accounts, if you already keep one.
If you also plan to deduct a specific bad debt on your tax return, the IRS requires evidence that the debt is genuinely worthless. The agency considers all relevant evidence, including the value of any collateral and the debtor’s financial condition. You do not have to sue the debtor first; if the surrounding circumstances show suing would not lead to payment, that is enough.1eCFR. 26 CFR 1.166-2 – Evidence of Worthlessness A bankruptcy filing, a debtor going out of business, or a debtor with no seizable assets are common indicators.
Method 1: The Direct Write-Off
The direct write-off method removes a specific customer’s balance from your books once you decide it is uncollectible. The calculation is exact rather than estimated: the bad debt expense for the period equals the sum of the specific balances you wrote off.
The journal entry debits bad debt expense and credits accounts receivable for the unpaid amount. If a customer owes $5,000 and you conclude the money will never arrive, that $5,000 is your bad debt expense.
This is the method the IRS requires for tax purposes. A business bad debt deduction is allowed for any debt that becomes worthless during the tax year.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 166 – Bad Debts You take the deduction in the year the debt actually becomes worthless — not earlier, not later.3Internal Revenue Service. Topic No. 453, Bad Debt Deduction You do not have to wait until the invoice’s payment due date has passed before making that determination.
Partially Worthless Debts
A business debt that is only partially worthless can still be deducted, as long as you charge off the uncollectible portion on your books during the tax year you claim the deduction.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 166 – Bad Debts If a customer owes $10,000 and you determine that $6,000 is recoverable but $4,000 is not, the bad debt expense is $4,000. Partial worthlessness is only available for business bad debts; nonbusiness debts (such as personal loans) must be entirely worthless to deduct, and they follow a different set of rules that fall outside a calculation question.
The Weakness of This Method for Financial Reporting
Because the direct write-off records the loss only when a specific debt is confirmed worthless, the loss often lands in a period long after the sale that created it. GAAP generally calls for one of the estimation methods below to match the loss to the same period as the revenue.
Method 2: Percentage of Credit Sales
This method estimates bad debt expense from the volume of credit sales during the period. The formula is straightforward:
Bad debt expense = Total credit sales × Historical loss rate
The loss rate comes from your own collection history. If your records show that about 2% of credit sales eventually go unpaid, and credit sales for the period were $1,000,000, the estimated bad debt expense is $20,000.
The journal entry debits bad debt expense and credits an allowance for doubtful accounts. The allowance is a contra-asset account that reduces the reported value of receivables on the balance sheet. Because the calculation is tied to sales activity rather than to the balance of receivables, this is sometimes called the income statement method.
Its strength is simplicity and consistency: as long as your credit policies and customer base are stable, the historical percentage produces a reliable estimate. Its weakness is that it ignores the current condition of specific accounts. A few large accounts turning shaky can leave the estimate well below your real exposure.
Method 3: Accounts Receivable Aging
The aging method estimates bad debt expense from the balance of receivables, sorted by how long each invoice has been outstanding. You sort every open invoice into aging buckets — commonly 0–30 days, 31–60 days, 61–90 days, and over 90 days past due — and apply a progressively higher loss rate to each, because older debts are less likely to be collected.
The steps:
- Total the receivable balance in each aging bucket.
- Multiply each bucket total by its estimated loss rate.
- Add the results. This is the required ending balance of the allowance for doubtful accounts.
- Compare that required balance to the current balance already sitting in the allowance account. The difference is the period’s bad debt expense.
Say you apply a 1% loss rate to the 0–30 day bucket and 25% to the over-90 bucket. With $200,000 in the first bucket (estimated loss: $2,000) and $40,000 in the last bucket (estimated loss: $10,000), plus the middle buckets, the required allowance totals $50,000. If the allowance account already has a $10,000 credit balance, the adjusting entry is $40,000: debit bad debt expense, credit the allowance.
Step 4 is where this method differs from the credit sales method. You are calculating what the allowance should be, then plugging in whatever expense makes the balance right. Because it focuses on stating receivables at the amount you actually expect to collect, it is sometimes called the balance sheet method.
The aging method reflects a changing receivable mix more accurately than a flat historical percentage of sales. It also demands more work: current aging data and periodic review of each customer’s status.
Choosing a Method
For your tax return, the choice is made for you: use the direct write-off method for specific debts that became worthless during the year. For financial statements, pick between the two estimation methods based on how stable your business is. A steady customer base and consistent credit policies favor the percentage of credit sales method for its simplicity. Fluctuating receivable balances, a small number of large customers, or wide variation in payment behavior favor the aging method for its accuracy.
When a Written-Off Debt Gets Paid
If a customer pays a debt you already wrote off, both your books and your tax return need attention. On the bookkeeping side, reverse the original write-off first by debiting accounts receivable and crediting the allowance for doubtful accounts (or bad debt expense, depending on the method). Then record the cash receipt normally: debit cash, credit accounts receivable.
On the tax side, the recovery triggers the tax benefit rule. The recovered amount is included in gross income in the year received, but only to the extent the original deduction actually reduced your tax.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 111 – Recovery of Tax Benefit Items If the earlier deduction produced no tax benefit — because you already had a net operating loss, for instance — you do not report the recovery as income.
Reconciling Books to Tax Return
When you use an estimation method for your financial statements and the direct write-off method for your taxes, the two figures will not match in any given year. The estimation method books an expense before any specific debt is confirmed worthless; the tax method waits for the worthlessness event. That gap is a temporary timing difference.
Report the difference on Schedule M-1, or Schedule M-3 for larger companies, with your corporate return. If your books show $50,000 in estimated bad debt expense for the year but your tax return only writes off $35,000 of specific debts, the $15,000 difference is added back to taxable income. As those specific debts are actually written off in later years, the timing difference reverses, and the total deduction over time comes out the same.