How to Fill Out the Molina Healthcare Return of Overpayment Form

The Molina Healthcare Return of Overpayment Form is a one-page document providers use to send back money Molina paid in error on a claim. You enter your provider information, list the Molina claim and check numbers tied to the overpayment, note the refund amount and reason, and mail the form with a refund check to Molina’s recoveries lockbox. The form lives on Molina’s provider website under the Forms section for your state plan, and the mailing address printed at the bottom of your state’s version is the one you should use.

What the Form Asks For

The form is short on purpose. It collects just enough to match your check to the right claim in Molina’s system. Each field:

  • Date you are completing the form.
  • Provider name, exactly as it appears on your Molina contract.
  • Provider tax identification number (your federal EIN used for Molina billing).1Molina Healthcare. Molina Healthcare Return of Overpayment Form
  • Provider contact person who can answer questions about the refund.
  • Provider phone number for that contact.
  • Reason for return (one of four checkboxes, with an “Other” line for explanation).
  • Molina claim number from your Explanation of Payment. You can list multiple claim numbers if one refund check covers several claims.
  • Molina check number from the original payment, also on the EOP.
  • Amount refunded to Molina, which must match your enclosed check exactly.
  • Provider check number of the refund check you are enclosing.

The form does not ask for the patient’s name, member ID, or your NPI. Keep the information to what the form actually requests, and attach a copy of the original EOP or remittance advice so the recoveries team can cross-reference the payment quickly.

Which Reason to Check

The four checkbox options cover the situations Molina sees most often:

  • Patient not affiliated with your office. A payment arrived for a member you never treated, usually because a claim was filed under the wrong provider number or after a patient changed practices.
  • Member has primary insurance and Molina paid as primary. A coordination-of-benefits error where Molina should have been secondary. Once the primary insurer processes the claim, the difference goes back.
  • Billing error causing overpayment. An incorrect procedure code, a duplicate submission, or a wrong quantity inflated the payment. If the claim still needs to be reprocessed at the correct amount, submit a corrected claim alongside your refund.
  • Other. Use this for payments for members no longer enrolled on the date of service, retroactive eligibility changes, or anything else. Write a brief explanation on the line provided.

Where to Mail the Form and Check

Molina routes refunds to a recoveries lockbox at a financial institution, not to a regional office, and the correct address depends on your state plan. The Virginia plan form lists these addresses:1Molina Healthcare. Molina Healthcare Return of Overpayment Form

Regular mail:
Molina Healthcare Medicaid
Attn: Recoveries Lockbox
401 Market Street
Box 780192
Philadelphia, PA 19178-0192

Overnight mail:
Lockbox #780192
Molina Healthcare Medicaid
Attn: Recoveries Lockbox
MAC Y1372-045
401 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA 19106

Other state plans use different addresses. New York’s self-disclosure program, for example, directs providers to P.O. Box 744627, Atlanta, GA 30374-4627, or accepts submissions by fax at 844-305-2186.2Molina Healthcare. Self-Disclosure Program Always use the address on the form version for your own state plan. If you are mailing close to a deadline, send it certified with return receipt so you have proof of the submission date.

Why the 60-Day Deadline Matters

Under Section 1128J(d) of the Social Security Act, a provider who receives a Medicare or Medicaid overpayment must report and return it within 60 days of identifying the overpayment, or by the due date of any corresponding cost report, whichever is later.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 42 USC 1320a-7k – Medicare and Medicaid Program Integrity An overpayment is “identified” when you have determined, or through reasonable diligence should have determined, that one exists and you can quantify the amount.2Molina Healthcare. Self-Disclosure Program

Running internal audits of your remittance advice on a regular cycle is the most reliable way to catch discrepancies before Molina’s recovery team does. Keeping an identified overpayment past the 60-day window can trigger liability under the federal False Claims Act, including treble damages and per-claim civil penalties.4Federal Register. Civil Monetary Penalty Inflation Adjustment

Offset Instead of a Refund Check

If writing a refund check would strain cash flow, Molina offers an alternative. The Provider Recovery Reversal Permission Form authorizes Molina to deduct the overpayment from your future remittances until the balance is satisfied.5Molina Healthcare. Provider Recovery Reversal Permission Form – Medicaid and Marketplace You complete that form in place of the Return of Overpayment Form, no check changes hands, and the deduction shows up as a line item on upcoming EOPs until the debt clears.

The offset route still satisfies the 60-day requirement as long as you submit the form within that window. It works best for moderate overpayments where your ongoing claim volume will absorb the deductions without disruption. For a large overpayment, a single refund check is often cleaner to account for.

Confirming Molina Received It

After Molina processes your refund, confirmation appears on your Explanation of Payment. Look for adjustment reason codes such as “Adjustment of Claim,” “Additional payment/recoupment approved based on payer-initiated review or audit,” or “Claim Reversal.”2Molina Healthcare. Self-Disclosure Program Those indicators mean the claim has been corrected in Molina’s system.

If none of those codes appear on your EOP within 45 days of submission, call Molina’s Payment Recovery Contact Center at 866-642-8999.2Molina Healthcare. Self-Disclosure Program Have your provider tax ID, the Molina claim number, and your refund check number in front of you.

If You Disagree With the Overpayment

You are not required to refund money you believe was paid correctly. If Molina sends a notice you disagree with, do not use the Return of Overpayment Form. Molina’s Provider Dispute Resolution process gives you up to 365 days from the last action on the claim to file a formal dispute, preferably through the Molina Provider Portal.6Molina Healthcare. Provider Dispute Filing a dispute also means agreeing not to bill the member for the disputed amount while the review is pending.7Molina Healthcare. Provider Dispute Resolution Request

Records to Keep

Federal rules allow a six-year lookback period for Medicare overpayments, so Molina or a government auditor could revisit a payment made years ago.8Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Fact Sheet Medicare Overpayments For every refund you submit, keep a copy of the completed form, the EOP showing the original payment, your canceled refund check or bank confirmation, and any certified-mail receipt. Many compliance professionals recommend retaining billing records for five to seven years to cover both federal and state recovery windows.