How to Fill Out and Submit the Prudential Evidence of Insurability Form

The Prudential Evidence of Insurability form is a health questionnaire you complete when you want group life or disability coverage above your employer plan’s guaranteed issue amount, or when you missed your initial enrollment window. Your employer fills in Part A with your earnings and the coverage amounts requested. You fill in Part B, which covers your personal information, a five-year medical history, and your authorization for Prudential to pull records from your doctors. Once both parts are done, you submit the form by mail to Prudential Group Medical Underwriting at P.O. Box 8796, Philadelphia, PA 19176, by fax to 877-605-6671, or through Prudential’s online EOI portal if your employer offers it.

When the Form Is Required

Not every enrolled employee has to complete an EOI. Your plan sets a guaranteed issue amount, which is the coverage you can elect without any health questions. The limit varies by employer contract. At one large employer, for example, dependent spouse life coverage carried a guaranteed issue of $25,000 for new hires.1Prudential. Prudential Optional Dependent Term Life Summary of Benefits Your benefits materials or HR team can tell you your plan’s number.

The form is triggered in three main situations:

  • You are requesting employee life, spouse life, or long-term disability coverage above the guaranteed issue amount. The excess requires underwriting.
  • You are a late entrant. If you did not enroll within your initial eligibility window, usually 31 days from your hire date, you lose the automatic approval even for amounts under the guaranteed issue.2Prudential. Evidence of Insurability
  • You are increasing coverage outside a qualifying life event like marriage or the birth of a child.

Children covered under the plan do not require evidence of insurability.2Prudential. Evidence of Insurability

What to Have Ready Before You Start

Incomplete answers are the top reason Prudential delays or returns an EOI. The form itself warns that missing doctor names and addresses will slow processing.2Prudential. Evidence of Insurability Pull these together before you sit down with the paperwork:

  • Your group contract number, which appears on your benefits enrollment materials.
  • Your Social Security number, date of birth, birthplace, address, email, and phone number.
  • Your current doctor’s name and address, even if you rarely visit.
  • Dates, provider names, and addresses for every hospitalization, surgery, diagnosis, and course of treatment in the past five years.
  • A list of your current medications with dosage and the condition each one treats.
  • The same level of medical detail for your spouse if you are requesting dependent life coverage.

Working Through the Sections

Part A is your employer’s job. They fill in your earnings, your current coverage, and the amounts you are requesting, then hand you Part B. Which sections of Part B you complete depends on who the coverage is for:2Prudential. Evidence of Insurability

  • Employee coverage only: Sections 1, 2, 4, and 5.
  • Spouse coverage only: Sections 1, 3, 4, and 5.
  • Both: all five sections.

Section 1: Personal Information

Name, SSN, contact information, date of birth, birthplace, and sex. Double-check the SSN. A transposed digit can disconnect your form from your employer’s group record.

Section 2: Employee Health Questions

This is the longest part of the form. The questions cover a five-year lookback and ask about:2Prudential. Evidence of Insurability

  • Whether you can currently perform all the duties of your job.
  • Surgeries you have had or been advised to have but did not.
  • Hospitalizations, including stays for observation or diagnosis.
  • Use of controlled substances not prescribed by a doctor, and any treatment or counseling for alcohol use.
  • Treatment or counseling by a psychologist or psychiatrist.
  • Prior disability benefits, and any previous insurance application that was declined, postponed, or rated up.
  • Specific conditions: heart or chest pain, high blood pressure, abnormal pulse, cancer, diabetes, lung conditions, nervous or mental disorders, arthritis, ulcers, intestinal or kidney problems, liver or gallstone issues, back or spinal disorders, and others.
  • Current medications and conditions not already covered, including pregnancy.
  • Tobacco or nicotine use within the past year, including cigarettes, cigars, chewing tobacco, and nicotine gum.

For every “yes,” the form requires the full name, address, and phone number of the treating doctor or hospital, the specific condition, dates, and whether you fully recovered. Having your records in front of you matters here. A vague answer like “saw a doctor in 2023” without names and dates will trigger a follow-up request that adds weeks to your timeline.

Section 3: Dependent Information

If you are requesting spouse life coverage above the guaranteed issue, Section 3 asks the same medical questions about your spouse. You complete this section on their behalf. Your spouse does not fill out a separate form, but they do sign the authorization in Section 5.2Prudential. Evidence of Insurability

Section 4: Fraud Warnings and Declaration

Section 4 contains state-specific fraud notices and a declaration that your answers are truthful and complete. Do not skim it. Knowingly submitting false information on an insurance application is classified as fraud in most states and can result in claim denials, policy cancellation, fines, and in some states criminal penalties. During the contestability period, typically the first two years after coverage takes effect, Prudential can investigate discrepancies between what you reported and your actual medical history and void the policy if it finds material misrepresentations.

Section 5: Authorization for Release of Information

Your signature here authorizes Prudential to obtain records from the doctors and hospitals you listed. If your spouse is included, they sign here too. The authorization is valid for the lesser of two years after any coverage takes effect or 30 months after you sign.2Prudential. Evidence of Insurability Without this signature, HIPAA bars your providers from releasing your protected health information to Prudential for underwriting.3U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Summary of the HIPAA Privacy Rule

Submitting the Completed Form

Once your employer has finished Part A and you have finished Part B, you have three ways to send it in:

  • Mail Parts A and B together to The Prudential Insurance Company of America, Group Medical Underwriting, P.O. Box 8796, Philadelphia, PA 19176.2Prudential. Evidence of Insurability
  • Fax to 877-605-6671.
  • Submit through Prudential’s online EOI portal if your employer has set up electronic submission. Check with HR for the link.

Fax and online submissions reach the underwriting queue faster because there is no postal transit time. Keep a copy of the completed form whichever method you choose.

What Happens After You Submit

An underwriter reviews your answers against Prudential’s risk standards. The form states that coverage is not effective until the request has been approved.2Prudential. Evidence of Insurability The process generally takes several weeks, with much of that time spent waiting on medical records from your doctors rather than on Prudential’s internal review. If your answers raise questions or the amount is high, Prudential may order a paramedical exam at no cost to you.

You will receive written notification of one of three outcomes: approved, denied, or incomplete, meaning more information is needed. Conditions that frequently complicate approval include uncontrolled high blood pressure, a recent cancer diagnosis, elevated liver enzymes on lab work, and a recent DUI. None is an automatic rejection, but each extends the review and can lead to a denial for the additional coverage requested.

One point that surprises many applicants: your employer may begin deducting premiums for the supplemental coverage before the EOI is approved, because payroll systems often start deductions when you elect the coverage. If Prudential denies the application, you are entitled to a refund. A 2023 Department of Labor settlement requires Prudential to promptly return all premiums collected for supplemental coverage that required EOI when the application is denied, and the denial notice must explain the refund amount and who will receive it.4U.S. Department of Labor. Settlement Agreement Between the Prudential Insurance Company

If approved, coverage takes effect on the date set by your group plan, provided you are actively at work on that date.2Prudential. Evidence of Insurability The effective date is not retroactive to your submission date; it is the later of your plan’s scheduled effective date and Prudential’s approval date.

If Your Application Is Denied

You have 180 days from receiving the written denial to file a written appeal.5Prudential. Summary of Material Modifications of Claim Procedures You can request copies of all documents and records in your claim file at no charge. A different team at Prudential, people not involved in the original decision, reviews the appeal, and you can submit new medical evidence such as updated lab results showing a flagged condition is now controlled.

Prudential must issue a decision within 45 days of receiving the appeal. Special circumstances can extend that by another 45 days, but the company must send you a written explanation before the first 45-day window closes.5Prudential. Summary of Material Modifications of Claim Procedures If Prudential fails to respond in time, the appeal is deemed denied, which opens external remedies. For ERISA-covered group plans, that typically means a complaint with the Department of Labor or a claim in federal court.