How to Fill Out and Submit the Aetna Reconsideration Form: 180-Day Deadline

The Aetna reconsideration form, officially titled the Practitioner and Provider Complaint and Appeal Request, is a one-page PDF that providers use to challenge a claim denial, underpayment, or coding decision. You can download it from Aetna’s documents library and submit by mail or fax, call Aetna to open a reconsideration by phone, or skip the PDF entirely by filing through the Availity portal, which builds the form for you during submission.1Aetna. Dispute and Appeals Process FAQs for Health Care Providers Whichever route you choose, the filing must reach Aetna within 180 calendar days of the initial claim decision.2Aetna. Disputes and Appeals Overview

When to Use the Reconsideration Form

Aetna separates reconsiderations from appeals, and the form you are filling out starts a reconsideration. That means a formal review of a reimbursement amount, a coding edit, or a request to reprocess a claim. An appeal is the next step up, used to challenge a reconsideration decision you disagree with or an initial denial based on medical necessity or experimental/investigational criteria.2Aetna. Disputes and Appeals Overview

Reach for the reconsideration form when the dispute involves:

  • Underpayment: the paid amount is lower than your contracted rate.
  • Coding edits: Aetna bundled services or applied NCCI edits you believe were incorrect.
  • Timely filing denials: the claim was denied under reason code CO-29 but you have proof of on-time submission.
  • Reprocessing errors: wrong member data, duplicate denial, or another administrative mistake.

If the denial is clinical, the reconsideration form still starts the process, but include medical records at the outset so Aetna can route it for clinical review.1Aetna. Dispute and Appeals Process FAQs for Health Care Providers

Information You Need to Complete the Form

Completion of the form is mandatory. An appeal submitted without one will be returned with a letter asking you to resubmit within the filing deadline, so missing fields cost you time you may not have.1Aetna. Dispute and Appeals Process FAQs for Health Care Providers Pull the following before you open the PDF:

  • Provider name, TIN, and NPI: enter these exactly as they appear on your billing submission. The NPI is ten digits.
  • Member ID number: on the front of the patient’s Aetna ID card.
  • Claim ID number(s): on the EOB or other Aetna correspondence; this is what links your dispute to the specific transaction.
  • Reference or authorization number: if prior authorization was involved, use the reference number from the original determination.
  • Service dates and CPT/HCPCS codes: identify each service line you are disputing. Multiple dates of service for the same member can go on a single form.3Aetna. Practitioner and Provider Complaint and Appeal Request
  • Initial denial notification date: the date Aetna issued the denial you are challenging.

Documents to Attach

Always include the EOB or denial letter. Aetna lists this as required, and it gives the reviewer the denial reason codes and payment details to locate the claim quickly.2Aetna. Disputes and Appeals Overview

Beyond that, attach whatever evidence supports your position. Aetna’s form names medical records, office notes, discharge summaries, lab records, and member history as examples, and notes the list is not exhaustive.3Aetna. Practitioner and Provider Complaint and Appeal Request For a medical necessity dispute, that means operative notes, pathology reports, or treatment plans. For a timely filing denial, clearinghouse acceptance records or Availity submission logs serve as proof the original claim went out on time.4Muni Health. Aetna Timely Filing Limits

The 180-Day Filing Deadline

You have 180 calendar days from the initial claim decision to submit a reconsideration.2Aetna. Disputes and Appeals Overview Miss that window and the dispute closes regardless of the merits. State regulations or the terms of your provider contract may extend the period, and state law takes precedence over Aetna’s standard timelines whenever it applies to the member’s plan.1Aetna. Dispute and Appeals Process FAQs for Health Care Providers Check both if you are close to the cutoff.

How to Submit

Aetna accepts reconsideration requests three ways: online through Availity, by phone, or by mail and fax.1Aetna. Dispute and Appeals Process FAQs for Health Care Providers

Online Through Availity

Availity is the fastest route and removes the need to fill out the PDF separately. From the Claim Status screen, find the finalized claim and click Dispute Claim. Aetna’s system decides whether the submission qualifies as a reconsideration or an appeal based on claim history. You pick a reason from a dropdown (authorization issue, benefit issue, claim coding issue, claim payment issue, contract dispute, or timely filing), type a rationale of up to 2,000 characters, and upload attachments. Once you submit, you cannot add files later, so attach everything before you confirm. The portal returns a case number on screen.5Aetna. Disputes and Appeals on Availity

By Phone

Reconsiderations can be opened over the phone (formal appeals cannot). Call the number that matches the member’s plan, with the denial letter or EOB, the original claim, and your supporting documentation in front of you:

By Mail or Fax

Mail the completed PDF and attachments to the address printed on your EOB. If no address appears there, use Aetna’s default:

Aetna–Provider Resolution Team
PO Box 14020
Lexington, KY 40512

The national fax number is 859-455-8650.3Aetna. Practitioner and Provider Complaint and Appeal Request Certified mail gives you a delivery receipt if you later need to prove the submission date.

What Happens After You Submit

Aetna targets 45 business days to complete a reconsideration, and the timeline can shift if the case is routed to a specialty review unit.2Aetna. Disputes and Appeals Overview You will get a written decision, either a revised EOB with new payment or a letter upholding the original denial. Availity submissions can also be tracked from the portal worklist.

If Your Reconsideration Is Denied

A denied reconsideration is not the end. The next step is a formal appeal, reviewed by someone who was not part of the reconsideration decision. The windows are short:

  • Non-Medicare and Medicare-contracted providers: 60 calendar days from the reconsideration decision.
  • Medicare non-contracted providers: 65 calendar days from the reconsideration decision.
  • Medical necessity or experimental/investigational denials: 180 calendar days.2Aetna. Disputes and Appeals Overview

State mandates can override these timeframes. Formal appeals must go through Availity or by mail and fax; the phone option that works for reconsiderations is not available at the appeal stage.1Aetna. Dispute and Appeals Process FAQs for Health Care Providers You do not need to resend documentation already submitted at reconsideration; note in the appeal that it is on file and add any new evidence.

Medicare Advantage Claims Use a Different Form

For Medicare Advantage disputes, use the Medicare Provider Complaint and Appeal Request. It follows the same structure but adds a field for the reconsideration denial notification date.6Aetna. Medicare Provider Complaint and Appeal Request The 180-day reconsideration deadline still applies.

Non-contracted providers must also complete and sign a Waiver of Liability stating they will not bill the enrollee regardless of outcome. The WOL must include the beneficiary’s Medicare ID or plan ID, dates of service, and the health plan name. File without it and Aetna will notify you; you then have 65 calendar days from Aetna’s receipt of the appeal to return the signed WOL. Miss that deadline and the appeal is dismissed.7Aetna. Medicare Non-Contracted Provider Appeal Process

External Review for Clinical Denials

Once Aetna’s internal reconsideration and appeal paths are exhausted, clinical denials have one more route. If the denial rested on medical necessity or the experimental nature of a service, and the member’s exposure exceeds $500, you can request external review through an Independent Review Organization.8Aetna. Aetna External Review Program

Aetna’s External Review Unit assigns the case to an IRO, which selects a board-certified physician in the relevant specialty. Decisions typically come within 30 calendar days and are binding on Aetna, the plan sponsor, and the health plan. Expedited review is available when a treating physician certifies that delay would jeopardize the member’s health.8Aetna. Aetna External Review Program