To conduct an internal audit, you need a written charter that gives the team authority, a risk-based plan that picks the highest-priority areas, a scoping step for each engagement, disciplined fieldwork built on transaction testing and interviews, workpapers that can support every conclusion, a report management responds to in writing, and follow-up that verifies the fixes actually happened. Skip any of those and the audit becomes paperwork rather than protection.
Start With a Charter That Gives the Team Authority
Before anyone opens a spreadsheet, the internal audit function needs a written charter approved by the board or its audit committee. The charter sets the team’s mandate, where it sits in the organization, who it reports to, what it can access, and what work it performs.1The Institute of Internal Auditors. Model Internal Audit Charter Tool and User’s Guide Without it, auditors have no organizational backing to demand documents, interview reluctant staff, or push back when management resists a finding.
Independence lives in the charter too. The chief audit executive typically reports functionally to the audit committee and administratively to senior management. That dual line matters because it lets the team flag problems to the board even when senior leaders are part of the problem. Auditors should not review processes they helped design or departments they recently worked in.
Choose What to Audit Based on Risk
Most organizations keep an “audit universe,” a complete inventory of departments, processes, systems, and programs that could be reviewed. You won’t audit all of it every year. The annual plan picks which parts get attention based on where risk is highest.
Score each area on factors like financial materiality, regulatory exposure, complexity, recent management turnover, and time since the last audit. Areas with high transaction volumes, known control weaknesses, or exposure to laws like the Sarbanes-Oxley Act or the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act should rise to the top. Interviews with executives and board members supplement the scoring by surfacing risks that don’t show up in spreadsheets, such as new cybersecurity threats or concerns about a specific vendor.
The final plan balances risk priorities against staffing and budget. Leave enough flexibility to handle urgent mid-year requests without derailing the schedule. Once the audit committee approves the plan, it becomes the roadmap for the next twelve months.
Scope Each Audit and Set Objectives
Every individual audit starts with scoping. Decide exactly which department, process, or control set you’re reviewing and what period of activity you’re looking at. A scope that’s too broad drains resources and produces shallow findings. One too narrow misses connected risks.
Objectives flow from the scope. You might aim to verify that accounts payable follows proper authorization, that cybersecurity controls meet a specific framework, or that financial reporting complies with SOX Section 404. Under Section 404(a), management of public companies must assess the effectiveness of internal controls over financial reporting each year, and under Section 404(b), external auditors must independently attest to that assessment.2U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. SEC Proposes Additional Disclosures, Prohibitions to Implement Sarbanes-Oxley Act An internal audit that evaluates those same controls gives management early warning before the external audit begins.
The Foreign Corrupt Practices Act adds another layer for companies with securities registered in the United States. The FCPA requires them to maintain accurate books and records and to operate a system of internal accounting controls sufficient to ensure transactions are properly authorized, recorded, and reconciled.3U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Recordkeeping and Internal Controls Provisions Section 13(b) Internal audits are one of the primary tools for testing whether those controls actually work.
Setting Materiality
Materiality decides how large an error needs to be before you treat it as a reportable finding. The core question: could this misstatement influence a decision made by someone relying on these numbers? Judgment drives the answer, informed by the dollar size of the error, its nature (a $5,000 intentional misstatement is more significant than a $5,000 rounding difference), and what stakeholders care about. Getting management’s view on materiality before fieldwork calibrates expectations.
Picking a Control Framework
Most internal audits assess controls against the COSO Internal Control-Integrated Framework, which organizes controls into five components: the control environment, risk assessment, control activities, information and communication, and monitoring. Testing against these categories ensures you’re evaluating the full control system rather than isolated transactions.
Gather Documents and Notify the Department
Start by pulling the records that establish a baseline: general ledger entries, bank reconciliations, payroll records, expense reports, and relevant contracts. Corporate policies, employee handbooks, and prior audit reports show the current control environment and whether earlier problems were fixed.
Send an audit notification letter to the department heads involved. State the purpose and scope, the timeline, and which staff you expect to interview or request documents from. Some teams also send a control self-assessment questionnaire asking management to describe their own procedures, authorization levels, and reconciliation frequency. Treat those responses as a starting point, not a substitute for testing. If the audit touches tax processes, name the specific filings needed, such as corporate returns, payroll tax documentation, or sales tax reports.
Organize everything in a secure digital repository with consistent naming. Categorize files by department, transaction type, or control objective so anyone reviewing the workpapers later can find evidence without help. Centralizing access also protects confidential employee data.
Do the Fieldwork
Fieldwork produces the evidence the audit rests on. Four activities carry most of the weight: transaction testing, physical verification, staff interviews, and process observation.
Transaction Testing
Select entries from the general ledger and trace them back to supporting documents: invoices, receipts, purchase orders, or contracts. That process, called vouching, confirms recorded expenses reflect real business activity. Working the other direction, start with source documents and trace forward to the ledger to confirm everything was captured. Cross-referencing bank statements against internal cash logs surfaces unauthorized transactions and posting errors.
Sampling
You rarely test every transaction. Draw a representative sample and extrapolate. Sample size depends on the confidence level you need (typically 90 or 95 percent), the tolerable exception rate (how many errors you’d accept before concluding the control has failed), and the number of exceptions you expect.
For populations over 200 transactions, standard attribute sampling tables give useful floors. At 90 percent confidence with a 5 percent tolerable error rate and no expected exceptions, the minimum sample is 50 items. At 95 percent confidence with the same tolerable rate, the minimum rises to 65. If you accept a 10 percent tolerable rate, those figures drop to 25 and 35. For smaller populations, proportionally smaller samples work: roughly 20 items for populations of 100 to 199, 10 items for 50 to 99, and 5 items for 20 to 49.4HUD Office of Inspector General. Appendix A Attribute Sampling These are floors. Judgment and the nature of the control being tested may justify larger samples.
Physical Verification
Some controls can’t be tested from a desk. Inventory counts in warehouses require physically checking quantity and condition against recorded stock. This work catches asset misappropriation that digital records miss. Verifying physical collateral for loans or capital assets on the balance sheet belongs here too.
Observing processes in real time reveals how work actually happens versus how the policy manual describes it. Check whether separation of duties holds in practice: the person who authorizes a payment should not be the one who records it. The person who opens incoming checks should not handle bank deposits. When one employee controls too many steps, the risk of undetected fraud rises sharply.
Staff Interviews
Interviews with frontline staff are where auditors learn the most. Open-ended questions about how someone handles a process routinely surface informal workarounds, outdated procedures, and controls that exist on paper but get skipped under time pressure. Document interviews in formal workpapers with date, interviewee, and substance. Auditors who rely only on documents miss the human side of control breakdowns.
Document Everything and Keep It
Every conclusion must be traceable to specific evidence in the workpapers. Workpapers include the documents you gathered, the tests you performed, the results, and your reasoning. If a finding can’t be reconstructed from the workpapers alone, it isn’t adequately supported.
Retention rules vary. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act requires audit or review workpapers for public companies to be kept for at least five years from the end of the fiscal period the audit covered. Knowing and willful violations carry a fine and up to ten years in prison.5U.S. Department of Labor. Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, Public Law 107-204 – Section: Title VIII Corporate and Criminal Fraud Accountability PCAOB Auditing Standard 1215 extends that to seven years for external audit documentation. Broker-dealers face separate rules: internal audit working papers must be preserved for at least three years, with the first two in an easily accessible location.6eCFR. 17 CFR 240.17a-4 – Records to Be Preserved by Certain Exchange Members, Brokers and Dealers
A separate and heavier penalty applies to destroying records to obstruct a federal investigation. Under 18 U.S.C. ยง 1519, enacted through Section 802 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, anyone who knowingly destroys or falsifies records to impede a federal matter faces up to twenty years in prison.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 US Code 1519 – Destruction, Alteration, or Falsification of Records in Federal Investigations and Bankruptcy That provision reaches far beyond accountants. Anyone involved in an audit who feels tempted to clean up a file should understand the federal government treats document destruction as seriously as the underlying misconduct.
Write a Report Management Can Act On
The report is what stakeholders see. It has to translate fieldwork into clear, actionable findings leadership can act on without decoding jargon.
Open with an executive summary stating scope, objectives, and an overall opinion on the effectiveness of the controls reviewed. Many teams use a three-tier scale: satisfactory (controls adequately address key risks and operate effectively), needs improvement (controls only partially address risks or aren’t consistently followed), and unsatisfactory (controls are absent, ineffective, or have been significantly breached). Explain the rating in plain terms so the severity is obvious.
Structure each finding consistently: the condition (what you found), the criteria (what the rule or standard requires), the cause (why the gap exists), and the effect (what harm results or could result). Attach a recommended action to each finding. Vague recommendations like “improve controls” are useless. The recommendation should be concrete enough that someone could implement it without further interpretation.
Send the report to senior management and the audit committee. Management provides written responses to each finding, either agreeing and committing to a corrective action with a target date, or disagreeing and explaining why. Those responses become part of the final report. This exchange puts management’s commitments on the record.
Track Remediation to Completion
Issuing the report is not the end. The most common failure in internal audit programs is letting findings age without resolution. Keep a corrective action tracking log capturing each finding’s reference number, the responsible person, the specific corrective action planned, and the target completion date.8OVC Tribal Financial Management Center. Audit Corrective Action Plan Guide Sheet
Follow-up timelines depend on severity. High-risk findings involving potential fraud or significant regulatory exposure may demand remediation within 30 days. Lower-risk items involving procedural improvements or documentation gaps might reasonably take 60 to 90 days. Whatever the deadline, schedule a follow-up review to verify the corrective action was actually implemented and is working. Management saying it’s done is not verification. The follow-up should include the same testing that found the original problem.
Escalate unresolved findings. If management repeatedly misses deadlines or disputes findings without legitimate basis, the chief audit executive reports directly to the audit committee. That escalation path is why the charter’s reporting structure matters so much.
Protect Employees Who Come Forward
Internal audits often depend on employees sharing what they know about problems in their departments, and federal law protects those employees from retaliation. Under Section 806 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, publicly traded companies cannot fire, demote, suspend, threaten, harass, or otherwise discriminate against an employee who provides information about conduct the employee reasonably believes violates federal securities laws or constitutes fraud against shareholders.9U.S. Department of Labor. Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, PL 107-204, Section 806 That protection reaches reports made to a supervisor or anyone in the company with authority to investigate misconduct, including internal auditors.
An employee who experiences retaliation can file a complaint with the Secretary of Labor. If the Department of Labor hasn’t issued a final decision within 180 days, the employee can bring a lawsuit in federal district court.9U.S. Department of Labor. Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, PL 107-204, Section 806 OSHA enforces whistleblower provisions across more than 20 federal statutes, so protections extend beyond SOX depending on the industry.10Occupational Safety and Health Administration. Recommended Practices for Anti-Retaliation Programs
For the audit team, the practical step is straightforward: set up confidential or anonymous reporting channels and make sure employees know about them before fieldwork starts. People share useful information when they trust the process won’t cost them their job. Audit notifications and interview protocols should reference those protections explicitly.