To compare 401(k) plans well, look at three things first: the fees you’ll pay to invest, the employer match formula, and how quickly that match vests. Everything else is secondary. A plan charging 1.5% in annual fees instead of 0.5% can shrink your final balance by roughly 28% over a 35-year career. A generous match is only worth its headline number if you stay long enough to own it. And the investment menu determines whether you can keep fees low in the first place. The rest of this guide walks through what to pull from each plan’s documents and how to weigh the differences.
Get the Real Documents First
Enrollment brochures gloss over the numbers you need. Federal law entitles you to two documents that don’t.
The first is the Summary Plan Description. Every plan administrator must provide one free of charge, and it lays out eligibility, matching formulas, vesting schedules, and how to file a benefits claim.1U.S. Department of Labor. Plan Information Ask HR or check the benefits portal. Start with the sections labeled “Contributions” and “Vesting.”
The second is the participant fee disclosure required under 29 CFR 2550.404a-5. Administrators must provide it before you first direct your investments and at least annually after that. It lists every investment option, each fund’s historical performance, and the total annual operating expenses as both a percentage and a dollar amount per $1,000 invested.2GovInfo. 29 CFR 2550.404a-5 Fiduciary Requirements for Disclosure in Participant-Directed Individual Account Plans If you’re weighing two job offers, request this document from both employers.
For a broader picture, search the Department of Labor’s Form 5500 database. Every plan with more than 100 participants files this annual report, which discloses total plan assets, participant count, and fees paid to service providers. Shrinking assets or administrative costs out of line with participant count are worth questioning.
Read the Match Formula Carefully
Match formulas vary widely, and the headline number can mislead you. A dollar-for-dollar match on the first 4% of salary means an employee earning $80,000 who contributes at least $3,200 picks up another $3,200 from the employer. A 50-cents-on-the-dollar match on the first 6% yields $2,400 on that same salary. Some employers skip matching entirely and make a flat nonelective contribution, often around 3% of pay, regardless of what you save.
Focus on the effective match rate rather than the formula. A 100% match on 3% gives you 3% of salary in free money. A 50% match on 6% gives you the same 3%, but you have to save twice as much to capture it. Both are valuable, and both reward different savings behaviors. Always contribute enough to capture the full match before anything else; leaving match dollars on the table is the single most expensive mistake in retirement saving.
Check How Fast the Match Vests
Your own contributions belong to you from day one. Employer contributions do not. The vesting schedule determines when you gain permanent ownership of what the company puts in. Leave before you fully vest and you forfeit the unvested portion.
Plans generally use one of two approaches. Cliff vesting gives you nothing until you hit a milestone, then 100% all at once; the longest permissible cliff for 401(k) matching contributions is three years. Graded vesting phases ownership in over time, with the standard schedule starting at 20% after two years and rising in 20-point increments to 100% after six.3Internal Revenue Service. Retirement Topics – Vesting
Those are the slowest schedules the law allows. Many employers vest faster, and some vest immediately. Safe harbor 401(k) plans, which satisfy certain nondiscrimination requirements, must vest their matching or nonelective contributions immediately or, in the case of a Qualified Automatic Contribution Arrangement, within two years.
Vesting matters most if you expect to change jobs. A generous match with six-year graded vesting is worth far less to someone who moves every two or three years. When comparing offers, multiply the annual match by the share you’ll realistically vest before your next likely departure. That adjusted number is the match’s true value to you.4U.S. Department of Labor. FAQs About Retirement Plans and ERISA
Compare the Investment Menu and Its Fees
The investments inside a 401(k) are chosen by the plan’s fiduciary, who is legally required to act in participants’ best interests and select a diversified menu at reasonable cost.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 U.S. Code 1104 – Fiduciary Duties The quality of that menu ranges from excellent to barely adequate. A strong lineup includes low-cost index funds covering domestic stocks, international stocks, and bonds, plus target-date funds that shift conservative as you approach retirement. A weak lineup offers only actively managed funds with expense ratios above 0.75%.
The expense ratio is the single most important number for comparison. It’s the annual percentage deducted from your investment to cover management costs. Index funds tracking broad markets commonly charge between 0.02% and 0.10%. Actively managed funds typically run 0.50% to 1.00% or more. A Department of Labor example illustrates the stakes: starting with a $25,000 balance and 7% average returns, a plan charging 1.5% produces $163,000 after 35 years while a plan charging 0.5% produces $227,000.6U.S. Department of Labor. A Look at 401(k) Plan Fees
Administrative Fees and Sales Loads
Beyond investment expenses, most plans charge administrative fees for recordkeeping, legal compliance, and account maintenance. These may appear as a flat quarterly charge deducted from your balance. Some plans instead cover these costs through revenue sharing, where fund companies pay the plan administrator out of higher expense ratios. The fee disclosure document is required to flag when administrative expenses are being paid this way.2GovInfo. 29 CFR 2550.404a-5 Fiduciary Requirements for Disclosure in Participant-Directed Individual Account Plans
Watch for sales loads. A front-end load takes a percentage off the top when you buy; a back-end load charges you when you sell. No-load funds skip these commissions entirely. A menu loaded with load-bearing funds signals how the plan was designed and who benefits.
Brokerage Windows
Some plans offer a self-directed brokerage window that lets you invest beyond the standard menu, buying individual stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds from the broader market. This helps when the core lineup is limited or expensive. The tradeoff is extra fees. Recordkeepers commonly charge brokerage window participants a quarterly maintenance fee, and roughly half of plans cap the share of your account you can invest through the window, often at 50%. Most also restrict certain investments through the window, such as employer stock or speculative securities.
Roth Availability and the Catch-Up Change
Whether the plan offers a Roth 401(k) option is worth confirming early. Traditional pre-tax contributions reduce your taxable income now, and withdrawals in retirement are taxed as ordinary income. Roth contributions go in after tax, meaning no upfront break, but qualified withdrawals in retirement are tax-free, including growth.
The choice turns on whether you expect your tax rate to be higher now or later. Many plans let you split contributions between both types, which hedges against future rate changes.
One boundary to watch: starting in 2027, a SECURE 2.0 provision requires that employees who earned more than $145,000 in FICA wages the prior year make any catch-up contributions on a Roth basis. Plans can adopt the rule earlier.7Internal Revenue Service. Treasury, IRS Issue Final Regulations on New Roth Catch-Up Rule, Other SECURE 2.0 Act Provisions If you earn above that threshold, check whether the plan has a Roth option at all. A plan without one may not be able to accept your catch-up contributions once the mandate takes effect.
Loans, Hardship Access, and Auto-Enrollment
Plan flexibility differs in ways you may not care about until you do. Not every plan allows loans. Among those that do, you can borrow up to the lesser of $50,000 or your full vested balance, with a floor of $10,000.8Internal Revenue Service. Retirement Plans FAQs Regarding Loans The loan must be repaid within five years through substantially level payments, with interest going back into your own account.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 72 – Annuities; Certain Proceeds of Endowment and Life Insurance Contracts
The real risk comes if you leave the job with a loan outstanding. The unpaid balance becomes a “plan loan offset” treated as a taxable distribution. You can avoid the tax hit by rolling the offset amount into an IRA or new employer plan, but only until your tax filing deadline, including extensions, for the year of the offset.10Internal Revenue Service. Plan Loan Offsets Miss the window and you’ll owe income tax on the full amount plus the 10% early withdrawal penalty if you’re under 59½.
Hardship withdrawals are a separate feature. Plans that allow them let you pull money for specific urgent needs like preventing eviction, covering unreimbursed medical expenses, or paying funeral costs. Hardship withdrawals aren’t repaid. The amount is included in your taxable income and may trigger the 10% early withdrawal penalty unless an exception applies.11Internal Revenue Service. Retirement Plans FAQs Regarding Hardship Distributions
Automatic enrollment also varies. Under SECURE 2.0, most new 401(k) plans established after December 31, 2024, must automatically enroll eligible employees at a default rate between 3% and 10% of pay, then raise that rate by one percentage point each year until it reaches at least 10% but no more than 15%.12Federal Register. Automatic Enrollment Requirements Under Section 414A Businesses less than three years old and employers with ten or fewer employees are exempt. A plan that auto-escalates to 15% will accumulate noticeably more than one capped at 10% if you don’t override the defaults.
What Happens When You Leave
How a plan handles departures is easy to overlook during enrollment and painful to discover later. When you leave an employer, you generally have four options: leave the money in the old plan, roll it into your new employer’s plan, roll it into an IRA, or cash out. Cashing out triggers income tax on the full amount and a 10% penalty if you’re under 59½, so it’s almost always the worst choice.
If you roll money to an IRA or new plan, insist on a direct rollover, where funds transfer between custodians without touching your hands. An indirect rollover, where the plan sends a check to you, triggers mandatory 20% federal tax withholding. You’d then need to come up with that 20% from other funds and deposit the full original amount into the new account within 60 days to avoid tax and penalty on the withheld portion.13Internal Revenue Service. Rollovers of Retirement Plan and IRA Distributions
Rolling into a new employer’s plan isn’t automatically right. Compare the investment options and fees in both. If your old plan has cheaper index funds, leaving the money there can make sense. If the new plan is more expensive, rolling into a low-cost IRA gives you access to virtually any investment on the market. One advantage of keeping money in an employer plan rather than an IRA: the Rule of 55. If you separate from service during or after the calendar year you turn 55, you can withdraw from that employer’s plan without the 10% early withdrawal penalty. The exception only applies to the plan at the employer you’re leaving, not to old 401(k) accounts from previous jobs. Public safety employees qualify at age 50.14Internal Revenue Service. Retirement Topics – Exceptions to Tax on Early Distributions
Finally, if you’re comparing offers across states, remember that state income tax treatment of eventual withdrawals varies widely, from zero in states without an income tax to over 13% in the highest-bracket states. Some states exempt a portion of retirement income or offer age-based deductions. That won’t change which plan is better on fees and match today, but it will change what the money is worth to you decades from now.