To cancel a WoodmenLife insurance policy, call customer service at 1-800-225-3108 or contact your local WoodmenLife representative, request a surrender form, sign and return it, and wait for the home office to process the request and issue any net cash value you are owed. Because WoodmenLife is a fraternal benefit society, ending the policy also ends your membership. What you actually walk away with depends on your policy type, how long you have held it, whether you have any outstanding loans against it, and whether the payout exceeds what you paid in premiums.
Are You Still Inside the Free-Look Window
If the policy is new, check the free-look period first. Every state requires life insurance policies to include one, typically 10 to 30 days from when you received the documents. Return the policy inside that window and you get a full refund of premiums paid, with no surrender charges and no tax consequences. The exact deadline is printed in your policy. If you are inside it, stop reading and call WoodmenLife to return the contract.
What to Have Ready Before You Call
Pull your policy number from the first page of your original documents. Have your date of birth and the last four digits of your Social Security number ready, since WoodmenLife uses those to verify identity.1WoodmenLife. Frequently Asked Questions If you have borrowed against the policy, find the most recent loan statement. The outstanding balance comes out of whatever cash value you would otherwise receive.
WoodmenLife requires a signed surrender form. You can request one through the member portal at mywoodmen.org, by calling customer service, or through your local representative.2WoodmenLife. Find a Representative for Life Insurance Near You The form asks whether you want a full surrender or a partial withdrawal. Decide before you fill it out.
Submitting the Surrender
Once signed, the form can go back three ways. Mail it to the home office at 1700 Farnam Street, Omaha, NE 68102, using a carrier with tracking.3WoodmenLife. WoodmenLife – Member Hand it to your local representative, who can route it internally and catch missing signatures before it reaches processing. Or upload a scan through the secure document center on the member portal.
Whichever route you use, follow up by phone at 1-800-225-3108 to confirm receipt.4WoodmenLife. Customer Support WoodmenLife does not publish a standard processing timeline, so ask the representative for an estimated completion date.
What You Actually Get Back
Term policies have no cash value, so cancellation simply stops future premiums. Permanent policies (whole life, universal life, indexed universal life) pay out the net cash value: the accumulated value minus any outstanding loan, accrued loan interest, and any applicable surrender charge.
Surrender charges matter. WoodmenLife applies them during the early years of certain policies, particularly indexed universal life.5WoodmenLife. Surrender Charges Indexed Universal Life Insurance The charge shrinks each year and eventually disappears. The schedule depends on your policy type, issue age, and rating class, so check the contract or ask customer service for your specific numbers. If the charge is still steep, waiting a year or two can leave real money on the table.
Reduced Paid-Up Insurance
Rather than take the cash, you can use the accumulated value to buy a smaller, fully paid-up policy of the same type. Premiums end permanently, a reduced death benefit stays in place for life, and you avoid the immediate tax hit of a cash surrender.
Extended Term Insurance
This uses your cash value to buy term coverage at the original death benefit amount, lasting as long as the value can support. If the insurer does not hear from you within 60 days of a lapse for nonpayment, extended term is typically the default. When the term runs out, the policy ends with nothing left over.
The Tax Bill
The IRS treats a surrender as a taxable event when you get back more than you paid in. Subtract total premiums paid from the net cash surrender value. If the result is positive, that gain is ordinary income.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 72 – Annuities; Certain Proceeds of Endowment and Life Insurance Contracts If you get back less than you paid, no tax is owed.
WoodmenLife sends IRS Form 1099-R in the year of surrender. Box 2a shows the taxable portion.7Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498 (2025) Keep the form; the IRS gets a copy. One trap catches people: if an outstanding policy loan is discharged as part of the surrender, the forgiven loan amount can count as taxable income too.
Alternatives to a Full Surrender
Surrendering is permanent. If the real problem is the premium rather than the coverage, other paths may fit better.
1035 Tax-Free Exchange
Federal tax law lets you move the cash value of a life insurance policy directly into another life insurance policy, an annuity, or a qualified long-term care contract without triggering tax on the gain.8Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1035 – Certain Exchanges of Insurance Policies Proceeds must transfer directly to the new contract, and the original policy cannot have outstanding loans at the time of exchange. Your cost basis carries over, so the tax is deferred rather than erased. This is the right tool if you want out of WoodmenLife specifically but still want the underlying coverage or an annuity.
Life Settlement
If you are 65 or older and hold a policy with a face value of $100,000 or more, a third-party buyer may pay more than the cash surrender value for it. Buyers weigh age, health, and premium load; younger or healthier policyholders rarely qualify. The payout is taxable and the process takes longer than a straight surrender, but the check can be substantially larger.
Pause Instead of Cancel
If your policy has cash value and an automatic premium loan provision, WoodmenLife can use that value to cover missed premiums rather than lapsing the policy. Each borrowed premium accrues interest, and once the cash value runs out the policy lapses. Reduced paid-up and extended term, described above, are the other ways to stop paying without walking away with nothing.
Losing Your Membership
WoodmenLife ties membership to owning an active product. When the policy ends, so does the membership, and with it access to member extras like the Focus Forward Scholarship program, which awards up to $10,000 per recipient, along with chapter activities and other benefits.9WoodmenLife. Scholarship Opportunities These extras are not contractual; they exist only for active members. If you have children or grandchildren who might apply for a WoodmenLife scholarship, weigh that before signing the surrender form, not after.