How to Cancel a Washington National Insurance Policy

To cancel a Washington National insurance policy, call the company at (800) 525-7662, mail a signed written request to PO Box 2022, Carmel, IN 46082-2022, or use the surrender forms at my.washingtonnational.com/forms. Before you do any of that, check whether you’re still inside your state’s free look period, because that’s the only way to walk away with a full refund.

Start With the Free Look Period

Every state requires insurers to give new policyholders a window to cancel for a full premium refund with no questions asked. The length runs from 10 to 30 days depending on your state, and the clock starts when the policy is delivered to you, not when you signed the application. If there’s any chance you’re still inside that window, call or write Washington National right away and you’ll get everything back.

How to Submit Your Cancellation

Washington National handles different products through different channels. Annuities and cash-value life policies have dedicated online forms: an Annuity Full Surrender Request Form and a Surrender for Net Cash Value Request form, both available at my.washingtonnational.com/forms. You can complete them online or print, sign, and mail them to the home office. If you don’t have your policy number handy, the site lets you continue by selecting your company and policy type.

Supplemental health products — accident, critical illness, and cancer coverage — don’t build cash value, so there’s no surrender form. For those, call customer service at (800) 525-7662 or send a written cancellation request by mail.

Treat a phone call as the first step, not the last. The company will almost always want written follow-up, so send a signed letter even after you call. Use certified mail with return receipt; it proves when Washington National received the request, which matters if billing continues or if there’s any dispute about your cancellation date.

Your written request should include:

  • Your full name exactly as it appears on the policy
  • Your policy number, from your policy documents or a billing statement
  • The date you want coverage to end
  • A clear statement that you’re requesting cancellation or surrender
  • Your signature

Surrender forms for cash-value products will also ask about tax withholding and where to send the payout.

If Premiums Come Out of Your Paycheck

Washington National sells heavily through employers, and payroll-deducted policies add a second step: notify your HR or benefits department to stop the deduction. Canceling with the insurer alone won’t stop the money leaving your check.

Timing can also lock you in. If your premiums are deducted pre-tax through a Section 125 cafeteria plan, federal rules generally hold your election in place for the full plan year. You can only change it mid-year after a qualifying life event: marriage, divorce, birth or adoption, loss of other coverage, or a change in employment status. Just wanting out doesn’t qualify.

Post-tax deductions, common with supplemental products, aren’t subject to the Section 125 restriction, so you can cancel at any time. Ask HR which type of deduction you have — many employees don’t know, and the answer decides whether you can cancel now or have to wait for open enrollment.

What You’ll Get Back

The refund picture depends entirely on the product.

Supplemental Health Policies

Accident, critical illness, and cancer policies have no cash value. If you cancel mid-cycle, you may get a prorated refund of the unused premium, or the insurer may keep the payment and run coverage through the paid-through date. Some policies use short-rate cancellation, which returns less than a straight prorated amount because it builds in an early-cancellation penalty.

Life Insurance

Term life has no cash value, so there’s nothing to surrender; you simply stop coverage, and any prepaid premium may or may not be partially refunded depending on policy terms. Whole life and universal life are different. They build cash value, and when you surrender you receive the cash surrender value, which is the accumulated cash value minus any surrender charges.

Surrender charges are where people lose money. They’re highest in the early policy years and typically decline over time, often disappearing after 10 to 15 years. Surrendering a whole life policy after only two or three years can mean the charge eats most or all of the cash value. Ask Washington National for a surrender value illustration before you sign anything, so you know the actual payout.

Annuities

Annuities almost always carry surrender charges in the early years, on a similar declining schedule. The Annuity Full Surrender Request Form starts the process. Annuity surrenders also carry tax consequences.

Taxes on the Cash-Out

If you surrender a life insurance policy or annuity with accumulated cash value, the IRS treats any gain as taxable income. The gain is what you receive minus your investment in the contract — essentially total premiums paid, less any refunds, dividends, or unpaid policy loans. Washington National will send a Form 1099-R showing the total payout and the taxable portion, and you’ll report it on your federal return. If the surrender value is less than what you paid in, there’s no taxable gain, but you also can’t deduct the loss on a personal policy.

A 1035 Exchange Avoids the Tax

If you’re switching to a different insurance product rather than leaving coverage altogether, a Section 1035 exchange lets you move the value directly from one contract to another with no tax hit. The IRS allows these transfers only in certain directions:

  • Life insurance to another life insurance policy, an annuity, an endowment, or a qualified long-term care policy
  • Annuity to another annuity or a qualified long-term care policy
  • Endowment to an annuity or a qualified long-term care policy

You can’t go the other direction — an annuity can’t be exchanged into life insurance. The funds have to move directly between insurers, with no check issued to you, and the owner and insured have to stay the same. Cashing out first and buying a new policy later does not qualify. Coordinate with both insurance companies before surrendering anything.

Don’t Just Stop Paying

Some policyholders try to exit by letting the policy lapse. It works, but not cleanly. After a missed payment you enter a grace period, typically 30 to 31 days for life insurance, during which coverage stays active. After that, the policy lapses.

For term life and supplemental health, lapsing and canceling end up in roughly the same place. Permanent life insurance is different. If the policy has cash value, the insurer may automatically use it to pay premiums, keeping coverage alive longer than you wanted. Some policies convert to reduced paid-up coverage instead of terminating. You can end up with a smaller policy you didn’t ask for and a possible taxable event if accumulated gains exceed your cost basis. Formal cancellation gives you control over the timing, written documentation, and no surprises from automatic provisions.

Confirm the Cancellation Went Through

Washington National should send a confirmation letter or email with the termination date and any final numbers — surrender payout, premium refund, or a statement that nothing is owed either way. Read it carefully; errors here cause continued billing or wrong effective dates.

If nothing arrives within two to three weeks, call (800) 525-7662 and document the call: date, representative’s name, what they told you. Check your bank account or paycheck on the next billing cycle to make sure premiums have actually stopped. For payroll-deducted policies, confirm separately with HR that the deduction has been removed.

If Washington National doesn’t process the cancellation or keeps billing after you’ve done everything required, file a complaint with your state’s department of insurance. Every state has a consumer complaint process, and the department can investigate the company’s handling of your request and take enforcement action if state insurance laws have been violated.