How to Calculate the Pre-1998 Tax-Free Benefit Formula

The General Rule for pensions and annuities is the IRS method that lets you treat part of each pension or annuity payment as a tax-free return of your own after-tax contributions. You calculate a fixed percentage, called the exclusion ratio, by dividing your investment in the contract by your expected return from an IRS actuarial table. That percentage of every payment is tax-free; the rest is ordinary income. The math is set out in IRS Publication 939.1Internal Revenue Service. Publication 939 – General Rule for Pensions and Annuities

Whether the General Rule Applies to You

Not every retiree with after-tax contributions uses this method. You use the General Rule if any of the following describes your situation:

  • Your payments come from a nonqualified plan, such as a private annuity, a purchased commercial annuity, or a nonqualified employer plan. The start date does not matter.
  • Your annuity starting date from a qualified employer plan, 403(b), or government pension was before November 19, 1996, and you have been using the General Rule since.
  • You were 75 or older on the annuity starting date and the annuity guarantees payments for at least five years, even if payments began later.

Everyone else with a qualified plan that started on or after November 19, 1996 uses the Simplified Method instead, which relies on a fixed divisor rather than actuarial tables.2Internal Revenue Service. Publication 575 – Pension and Annuity Income If you chose the General Rule during the window when a choice was available, you are locked into it until your cost is recovered.

The Numbers You Need Before You Start

Pull these figures together first. Missing any one of them stalls the calculation.

  • Your total after-tax contributions, called your investment in the contract. Check Box 5 of Form 1099-R, or request a contribution history from your plan administrator if Box 5 is blank.3Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498
  • Your annual pension amount before taxes, from Box 1 of the 1099-R or by annualizing your monthly check.
  • Your annuity starting date, meaning the first day of the first period for which you received a payment.
  • Your age on that starting date. The tables key off that age, not your current age.
  • The names and birthdates of any survivor annuitants, if your pension continues to someone else after your death.

Publication 939 contains the actuarial tables. Table V covers single-life annuities. Table VI covers joint and survivor annuities. Other tables handle term-certain and temporary life arrangements.1Internal Revenue Service. Publication 939 – General Rule for Pensions and Annuities

The Three-Step Calculation

The exclusion ratio is a single fraction. Build it in three steps.

Step 1. Find your investment in the contract. Total your after-tax contributions. If you received any tax-free distributions before the annuity started, subtract them.

Step 2. Calculate your expected return. Multiply your annual payment by the life expectancy multiple from the appropriate table in Publication 939. For a single-life annuity, that is Table V, and the multiple reflects the number of years the IRS expects payments to continue based on your age when they began.

Step 3. Divide. Investment in the contract divided by expected return equals the exclusion ratio, expressed as a percentage. Apply that percentage to each payment to find the tax-free portion.

Publication 939 works through a concrete example. A retiree age 65 has $10,800 in after-tax contributions and receives $100 a month. The Table V multiple at age 65 is 20.0, so expected return is 20.0 × 12 × $100 = $24,000. Dividing $10,800 by $24,000 gives an exclusion ratio of 45 percent. That makes $540 of the $1,200 received each year tax-free and $660 taxable.1Internal Revenue Service. Publication 939 – General Rule for Pensions and Annuities

The ratio is fixed for the life of the annuity. You do not recalculate it if a cost-of-living adjustment changes your payment. What changes is when the exclusion ends.

Joint and Survivor Annuities

If your pension continues to a surviving spouse or other beneficiary, use the combined life expectancy from Table II or Table VI instead. Two lifetimes produce a longer expected payout period, so the expected return is larger and the exclusion ratio is smaller than for a single-life annuity with the same investment. Each payment carries a lower tax-free dollar amount, but the exclusion stretches over more years.1Internal Revenue Service. Publication 939 – General Rule for Pensions and Annuities

If the survivor receives a reduced payment, such as 50 or 75 percent of the original, the expected return has to account for both payment levels across both life expectancies. Publication 939 includes a separate worksheet for that case.

When the Exclusion Stops

For annuities that started after 1986, the exclusion ends once the cumulative tax-free portions of your payments equal your full investment in the contract. Every dollar of every payment after that is fully taxable.2Internal Revenue Service. Publication 575 – Pension and Annuity Income There is no phase-out.

Applied to the Publication 939 example, a $540 annual exclusion against $10,800 in contributions runs out after 20 years. Starting in year 21, the entire payment is taxable. The only way to know when you hit the cap is to keep a running tally of what you have excluded each year. Retirees who lose track often either keep excluding too long, inviting an IRS adjustment, or stop early and overpay.

Annuities with starting dates before 1987 do not have this cap. Those retirees keep applying the exclusion ratio for as long as payments continue, even if the excluded total eventually exceeds the original investment.1Internal Revenue Service. Publication 939 – General Rule for Pensions and Annuities

Reporting the Result on Form 1040

On Form 1040, the full payment amount from Box 1 of your 1099-R goes on line 5a, and only the taxable portion after applying the exclusion ratio goes on line 5b.4Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 1040

Trouble often starts with the 1099-R itself. Many plan administrators check the Taxable Amount Not Determined box (Box 2b) or enter the full distribution in Box 2a as though the whole payment is taxable.3Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498 When your return shows a smaller taxable amount, the IRS computer flags the mismatch and may send an automated notice. That does not mean the return is wrong. Keep your exclusion ratio worksheet, the actuarial table you used, your contribution history, and your running total of prior years’ exclusions. If a notice arrives, that documentation is what resolves it.

Fixing Past Returns

Some retirees learn years in that they have been paying tax on money that should have been excluded, often because a preparer did not know about the after-tax contributions or the 1099-R was taken at face value. File Form 1040-X for each affected year, recalculating the taxable portion with the correct exclusion ratio.5Internal Revenue Service. About Form 1040-X, Amended U.S. Individual Income Tax Return

You generally have three years from the date you filed the original return, or two years from the date you paid the tax, whichever is later, to claim a refund.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 6511 – Limitations on Credit or Refund Overpayments older than that are lost, but you can still correct the calculation going forward. If you have been excluding too much because you already recovered your full cost, amend anyway to stop interest and penalties from building.

Unrecovered Cost at Death

If a retiree dies before recovering the full after-tax investment and no survivor annuitant continues receiving payments, the unrecovered balance is deductible on the deceased annuitant’s final income tax return.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 72 – Annuities; Certain Proceeds of Endowment and Life Insurance Contracts The deduction equals the original investment minus every tax-free amount the annuitant actually received.

The deduction is treated as if attributable to a trade or business, so it can generate or contribute to a net operating loss the estate or surviving spouse may use. The executor or surviving spouse claims it on the decedent’s final Form 1040. This rule applies to annuities with starting dates after 1986.