How to Audit a Nonprofit Organization: Process, Opinions, and Costs

Auditing a nonprofit organization means hiring an independent Certified Public Accountant to examine your financial statements, test transactions and internal controls, and issue a formal opinion on whether the numbers fairly represent your finances. The process runs in a predictable sequence: confirm whether an audit is required, select an independent auditor, prepare records, sit through fieldwork, and act on the findings. Fees generally run from the low five figures for small, simple organizations to well above $50,000 for larger nonprofits with federal grants.

Is an Audit Actually Required

Before spending anything, confirm what your organization is legally obligated to do. There are three places the requirement usually comes from: federal law, state charity regulators, and your own grant agreements or bylaws.

Federal Single Audit Threshold

Any nonprofit that spends $1,000,000 or more in federal awards during a single fiscal year must undergo a Single Audit (or a program-specific audit) under the Office of Management and Budget’s Uniform Guidance at 2 CFR Part 200, Subpart F. Organizations that spend less than $1,000,000 in federal awards are exempt from this federal audit requirement.1eCFR. 2 CFR Part 200 Subpart F – Audit Requirements

The threshold moved from $750,000 to $1,000,000 for fiscal years beginning on or after October 1, 2024, so use the $1,000,000 figure going forward. A Single Audit goes beyond a standard financial statement audit; it also tests whether the organization complied with the specific terms and conditions attached to each federal grant.1eCFR. 2 CFR Part 200 Subpart F – Audit Requirements

Once complete, the full reporting package goes to the Federal Audit Clearinghouse within 30 calendar days of receiving the auditor’s report, or nine months after the end of the fiscal year, whichever comes first.2eCFR. 2 CFR 200.512 – Report Submission Missing the deadline can trigger increased federal oversight, repayment demands, or suspension of future funding.

State Rules, Grant Terms, and Bylaws

Most states impose their own audit mandates on charities registered to solicit donations, tied to annual revenue. Thresholds vary widely, from roughly $250,000 in some jurisdictions to $2,000,000 in others. Organizations below their state’s threshold may still owe an audit under their bylaws, or as a condition set by a major grantor or lender.

Audit, Review, or Compilation

A full audit is not the only option a CPA can provide, and many smaller nonprofits satisfy their filing or grant requirements with a lighter engagement. There are three levels of service.

  • Audit. The most thorough option. The auditor tests individual transactions, inspects supporting documentation, evaluates internal controls, and issues a formal opinion on whether the financial statements are fairly presented. This is what grantors and regulators mean when they require “audited financial statements.”
  • Review. A mid-level engagement. The CPA performs analytical procedures and inquiries but does not test individual transactions or evaluate internal controls. The report states whether the CPA is aware of any material issues; it does not give an opinion on the financials as a whole.
  • Compilation. The lightest option. The CPA organizes financial data you provide into statements that comply with accounting standards, without testing or analysis. A compilation offers no assurance about accuracy.

The assurance levels are not interchangeable. If your state or grantor requires an audit and you submit a review, you have not met the requirement. Confirm which level applies to your filings, grant agreements, and bylaws before you commit.

Selecting an Independent Auditor

The audit must be performed by a licensed CPA with no financial interest, management role, or other relationship with the organization that could compromise objectivity. Independence is what makes the final report credible to outside parties; a conflict of interest makes the engagement worthless no matter how much work goes into it.

Most boards start with a Request for Proposal issued to several qualified firms. The RFP should describe the scope of work (including whether a Single Audit is needed), the expected timeline, access requirements for records, and any industry-specific expertise the board wants, such as experience with federal grant compliance or endowment accounting. Comparing proposals side by side lets the board evaluate technical qualifications and fee structures before signing an engagement letter.

Look for a firm that regularly audits nonprofits of similar size and complexity. Auditors who mostly serve for-profit businesses tend to need more of your staff’s time to get up to speed on nonprofit accounting standards.

Rotating Auditors

No universal federal rule forces nonprofits to rotate auditors on a fixed schedule, but periodic rotation is widely considered a best practice for maintaining independence. Some boards rotate the lead audit partner every five to seven years while keeping the same firm; others reissue an RFP every several years to invite competitive bids. The purpose is to prevent the kind of familiarity that erodes professional skepticism.

The Audit Committee

An audit committee, drawn from the board of directors, oversees the entire audit process. Its work typically includes appointing and overseeing the independent auditor, receiving the auditor’s findings directly rather than through the executive director, and recommending corrective actions to the full board. This structure keeps financial oversight separate from the staff who manage money day to day.

Even where state law does not require an audit committee, having one demonstrates serious governance. The committee should draft a charter defining its responsibilities, review that charter periodically, and include at least one member with enough financial literacy to ask meaningful questions about the auditor’s work.

Preparing Records Before Fieldwork

The auditor will send a detailed document request, often called a Prepared by Client list, well before fieldwork begins. Getting these materials organized early is the single most effective way to reduce both the time and cost of the engagement. Nearly every request list asks for:

  • A trial balance summarizing every account in the general ledger.
  • Finalized bank reconciliations for every account, showing that book balances match actual cash held.
  • Donor-restricted asset records proving that funds given for specific purposes were tracked and spent as instructed.
  • All active grant agreements and contracts, with amendments, so the auditor can verify revenue terms and spending restrictions.
  • Board and committee minutes from the fiscal year, which supply the legal context for major financial decisions.
  • Fixed asset schedules with acquisition dates, costs, and depreciation calculations.
  • Payroll records and tax filings, including quarterly Form 941 filings, which report federal income tax withholding and the employer’s share of Social Security and Medicare taxes.3Internal Revenue Service. About Form 941, Employer’s Quarterly Federal Tax Return

Every entry should be traceable to supporting documentation. If the auditor selects a transaction for testing and you cannot produce the backup, that gap becomes a finding in the report. Cross-reference each item against your files before the auditor arrives, and flag anything missing so your team can track it down rather than scrambling during fieldwork.

Documenting Internal Controls

The auditor will also evaluate the policies and procedures your organization uses to prevent or detect errors and fraud. Before fieldwork, document who authorizes expenditures, who signs checks, how bank reconciliations are reviewed, and whether any single person has unchecked access to both recording and approving transactions. Segregation of duties is what auditors care about most in smaller nonprofits, where limited staff often means one person wears too many financial hats. If your size prevents full segregation, document the compensating controls you have in place, such as board-level review of bank statements.

The Audit Itself

Risk Assessment and Planning

Auditors do not test everything. The engagement starts with a risk assessment: the auditor learns about your operations, revenue sources, and internal control environment, then identifies which accounts carry the highest risk of material misstatement. High-risk areas get tested more extensively; lower-risk accounts receive lighter scrutiny. Federal grants, restricted endowments, and complex multi-year pledges tend to attract disproportionate attention.

Fieldwork and Testing

During fieldwork, the auditor selects specific transactions and traces them back to original source documents, confirms balances directly with banks, verifies receivables with major donors, and inspects physical assets. Internal controls get tested to see whether the systems in place are adequate. A control weakness gets documented even if no actual misstatement occurred. If the same person who writes checks also reconciles the bank account, that shows up in the report.

Management Representation Letter

Near the end of fieldwork, the organization’s leadership signs a management representation letter confirming that the information provided to the auditor is accurate and complete, and that all relevant financial facts have been disclosed. Auditors will not issue their report without it.4PCAOB. AS 2805 Management Representations

The Audit Report and What Each Opinion Means

The auditor’s report is the deliverable outside parties care about. It contains a formal opinion on whether your financial statements are fairly presented in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. Four outcomes are possible:

An adverse opinion or disclaimer can lead to loss of grant eligibility, increased IRS scrutiny, and reputational damage that takes years to repair. Even a qualified opinion deserves immediate attention, and the underlying issue should be resolved before the next audit cycle.

The Management Letter and Internal Control Findings

Separately from the opinion, the auditor usually issues a management letter addressing internal control weaknesses and other observations that do not rise to the level of a formal qualification but still warrant attention. Findings fall into two categories:

The management letter is where auditors communicate operational improvements the organization needs: tightening approval workflows, improving documentation, or adding oversight to high-risk areas. Every finding should be discussed by the audit committee and assigned to a specific person with a deadline for resolution.

Corrective Action Plans After a Single Audit

Organizations that undergo a Single Audit and receive findings must prepare a written corrective action plan addressing each one. The plan must be a separate document from the auditor’s findings and must include the name of the person responsible for each corrective action, the specific steps to be taken, and the expected completion date. If the organization disagrees with a finding, the plan must explain why in detail.7eCFR. 2 CFR 200.511 – Audit Findings Follow-Up

The corrective action plan is submitted alongside the audit reporting package to the Federal Audit Clearinghouse, and federal agencies review it when making future funding decisions. Receiving the same finding two years running without meaningful action tells federal funders the organization cannot manage their money responsibly.

Note that the audited financial statements are related to, but not the same as, the annual IRS Form 990 filing. Numbers will not always match exactly, because audited financials follow generally accepted accounting principles while Form 990 has its own reporting rules. Form 990 does ask whether the organization obtained independent audited financial statements, so answering yes when no audit occurred is a compliance problem.8Internal Revenue Service. Return of Organization Exempt From Income Tax

What a Nonprofit Audit Costs

Audit fees vary significantly based on the organization’s size, the complexity of its finances, the number of federal programs requiring testing, and geographic location. Smaller nonprofits with straightforward operations often see fees in the low five figures, while larger organizations with multiple federal grants and complex revenue streams can pay well above $50,000. A Single Audit adds substantial cost beyond a standard financial statement audit because of the additional compliance testing involved.

The biggest factor you can control is preparation. Organizations that arrive at fieldwork with complete, organized records and reconciled accounts spend less auditor time on administrative back-and-forth, and auditor time is what drives the bill. Ask for a detailed fee estimate during the RFP process, including how additional hours are billed. Some firms quote a flat fee; others bill hourly against an estimate. Understand what is included before signing the engagement letter.