A carbon credit is a tradable instrument representing one metric ton of carbon dioxide — or its greenhouse-gas equivalent — kept out of the atmosphere, and understanding how the carbon credit market works means understanding two very different systems running in parallel. Government-mandated compliance markets force covered polluters to hold allowances for every ton they emit. The voluntary market lets any business, organization, or individual buy credits to offset emissions they haven’t eliminated. Credits in both systems get created by projects, verified by third-party auditors, logged on digital registries, traded on exchanges or privately, and permanently retired when a buyer claims the environmental benefit.
Two Markets, Two Different Reasons to Buy
Compliance markets exist because a regulator forces them into existence. The standard design is cap and trade: the government sets a ceiling on total emissions for covered industries, issues a limited number of allowances worth one ton each, and shrinks the cap over time. Companies emitting less than their allotment can sell surplus allowances. Companies over their limit must buy more or face penalties.
The European Union Emissions Trading System is the largest and oldest example, covering power generation, heavy industry, and intra-EU aviation. A company that fails to surrender enough allowances pays a penalty of €100 per excess tonne of CO₂, adjusted for inflation, and still has to buy and surrender the missing allowances the following year.1International Carbon Action Partnership. EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) With EU allowances trading around €69 per tonne in early 2026, the penalty effectively doubles the cost of each uncovered ton. Other compliance markets run in parts of North America, China, South Korea, and the United Kingdom, each with its own cap schedule and penalty structure. The declining cap is the engine: as supply shrinks, prices rise, pushing covered companies toward cleaner operations.
The voluntary market has no government mandate. Businesses buy credits to meet net-zero pledges or corporate sustainability goals, airlines offset routes, and some platforms let individuals offset personal travel. Voluntary credit prices in 2025 generally ran from around $29 to $55 per ton, with nature-based credits trending toward the higher end as quality standards tighten. That wide spread reflects a real problem the compliance side mostly avoids: not every voluntary credit represents the same quality of climate action, and the market increasingly prices them accordingly.
How a Credit Gets Created
Every credit begins as a project. A developer submits documentation showing a measurable reduction in greenhouse gas emissions: baseline measurements of what would have happened without the project, projected reductions, monitoring plans, and evidence that the project depended on credit revenue to proceed. Three technical concepts determine whether what comes out the other end is a credit worth buying.
Additionality
Additionality is the single most important quality test. The emission reduction must not have happened without the financial incentive of selling credits. A forest already legally protected from logging fails the test — the trees were safe regardless. A landfill already required by law to capture methane fails it too. The FTC’s Green Guides apply the same principle from a consumer protection angle: marketers should not advertise a carbon offset if the underlying activity is already legally required.2Federal Trade Commission. Environmental Claims: Summary of the Green Guides A genuinely additional project might be a methane capture system at a dairy farm that would be too expensive to build without credit revenue, or reforestation on degraded land with no commercial timber value.
Permanence and Buffer Pools
For projects that store carbon physically — in trees, soil, or geological formations — the carbon has to stay locked away for decades. The Climate Action Reserve requires a 100-year permanence commitment, reasoning that CO₂ persists in the atmosphere for roughly that long.3Climate Action Reserve. One Hundred Years of Permanence? Other programs offer periods of 25 or 100 years, with shorter commitments generating fewer credits per ton stored.
Nature doesn’t honor contracts. A reforestation project can burn in a wildfire. Soil carbon can be lost after a drought or a change in farming practice. Registries handle this by requiring developers to set aside a risk-adjusted percentage of their credits into a buffer pool, which functions as an insurance reserve. Verra’s Verified Carbon Standard, the largest voluntary registry, requires each land-based project to contribute credits to a shared global buffer pool based on the project’s risk profile.4Verra. Frequently Asked Questions Contributions typically run 10 to 20 percent of a project’s credits. If a wildfire destroys a credited forest, the registry draws from the pool to replace the lost credits.
Leakage
Leakage is what happens when a project prevents emissions in one place but causes them to increase somewhere else. The textbook case: a developer pays a landowner to stop logging and sells credits for the preserved carbon, but the logging company simply moves to a neighboring forest. The net climate benefit is zero. Project developers must submit monitoring plans that identify leakage risks and track whether emissions are actually shifting rather than disappearing.
Verification and Registries
A credit has no value until an independent auditor confirms the project does what it claims. Third-party verification bodies accredited under ISO standards inspect project sites, review monitoring data, and check financial records to confirm additionality, permanence, and leakage requirements. For soil carbon projects this can mean verifying GPS-logged sample locations, checking that lab analysis used proper techniques, and independently recalculating a sample of emissions data.
The two dominant voluntary market registries are Verra, which administers the Verified Carbon Standard, and the Gold Standard. Verra describes the credits it certifies as “real, measurable, additional, permanent, independently verified, conservatively estimated, uniquely numbered, and transparently listed.”5Verra. Verified Carbon Standard The Gold Standard uses approved third-party validation and verification bodies, with emphasis on stakeholder engagement and co-benefits beyond carbon reduction.6Gold Standard. Certification Process Step-by-Step The Climate Action Reserve and the American Carbon Registry are other significant players, particularly for North American projects.
Once a credit passes verification, the registry assigns it a unique serial number and records it in a digital ledger. The number tracks the credit through issuance, sale, transfer, and retirement. Serialization is what prevents double counting: once a credit is sold, it cannot simultaneously be claimed by another buyer. When a company uses a credit to offset emissions, the registry permanently deactivates the serial number so it can never be traded again.
How Credits Are Bought, Sold, and Retired
Registered credits become tradable assets. Xpansiv operates as a spot marketplace where credits trade through standardized contracts. The Intercontinental Exchange offers carbon credit futures and runs an auction service connecting developers with institutional buyers.7ICE. Global Carbon Pricing Mechanisms and Their Interaction with Carbon Markets CME Group lists physically-delivered carbon credit futures based on Xpansiv’s standardized contracts, including GEO (Global Emissions Offset), N-GEO (nature-based), and C-GEO (CORSIA-eligible), with forward months extending into 2026 and beyond.
Not every deal runs through an exchange. Many large transactions happen over the counter, where buyer and seller negotiate directly on price, volume, project type, and vintage (the year the emission reduction occurred). OTC contracts allow a buyer to specify something narrow, such as forestry credits from a particular region, but they lack the price transparency exchanges provide.
Registry fees for all this activity are modest. The Climate Action Reserve charges $0.20 per credit at issuance, $0.03 per credit for transfers, and $0.03 for cancellations, with retirement itself carrying no fee.8Climate Action Reserve. Fee Structure The real cost of bringing credits to market lies in project development and verification. A credit’s lifecycle ends at retirement: once the serial number is deactivated, the environmental benefit has been claimed and the credit permanently leaves circulation.
The Credit Quality Problem
The voluntary market has a credibility problem, and any buyer should understand it before writing a check. Academic researchers and journalists have found that some widely sold credits represent reductions that never actually happened or were significantly overstated. Terms like “junk credits” have entered mainstream vocabulary around offsets. The concern is straightforward: if a credit doesn’t represent a real ton of CO₂ kept out of the atmosphere, the company using it to claim neutrality is engaged in expensive greenwashing.
Most quality failures trace back to the fundamentals. Projects that lack genuine additionality, overestimate baselines, or face unmonitored leakage all produce credits that look legitimate on a registry but don’t deliver real benefits. Over-crediting is especially hard to catch because it involves getting the math wrong rather than outright fraud.
Buyers trying to avoid these problems should focus on credits verified under rigorous standards like Verra’s VCS and the Gold Standard, look for projects with conservative baseline methodologies, and pay attention to vintage. Older credits sitting unsold for years sometimes signal that sophisticated buyers already passed on them. Price is also a signal: credits priced far below market averages should prompt questions about why they’re cheap.
What Happens When a Project Fails
Buying a credit doesn’t automatically mean the underlying reduction is permanent, and who bears the loss when a project fails depends on how it failed. For unintentional reversals from natural disasters, such as a wildfire destroying a reforestation project, the registry’s buffer pool absorbs the loss by replacing the invalidated credits. The buyer’s offset claim typically survives.
The liability picture changes with human-caused reversals. When a landowner deliberately overharvests a credited forest, the seller is generally liable to replace the reversed credits. For credits invalidated because of fraud, material measurement errors, or regulatory non-compliance, some programs shift liability to the buyer, meaning the company that retired the credit may need to replace it with a new one to maintain its offset claim. That provision turns due diligence into financial risk management, not just an ethical choice.
Well-drafted purchase agreements address these scenarios directly. Common contractual protections include seller warranties that the credits have clear title and are free of encumbrances, indemnification clauses requiring the breaching party to cover losses from misrepresentation, and fraud provisions that survive termination. Any buyer purchasing in significant quantities should make sure the agreement explicitly allocates reversal risk and specifies who replaces credits under each failure scenario.
U.S. Regulatory Oversight
Carbon markets sit at the intersection of environmental regulation, securities law, and commodity trading, and several federal agencies have staked out territory.
CFTC and Carbon Derivatives
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission treats carbon credit derivatives as commodities under its jurisdiction. In 2024 the CFTC issued final guidance for exchanges that list voluntary carbon credit derivative contracts, outlining factors those exchanges should consider to ensure the contracts aren’t susceptible to manipulation.9Federal Register. Commission Guidance Regarding the Listing of Voluntary Carbon Credit Derivative Contracts The agency has also brought enforcement actions against fraud in the voluntary market, including charges against a carbon credit project developer’s former CEO. In those actions the CFTC seeks civil penalties, disgorgement of profits, restitution, and permanent trading bans.10Commodity Futures Trading Commission. CFTC Charges Former CEO of Carbon Credit Project Developer with Fraud Involving Voluntary Carbon Credits The CFTC’s Whistleblower Office actively solicits tips related to carbon market misconduct.
FTC and Marketing Claims
Any company advertising itself as “carbon neutral” or marketing products as “carbon offset” is making an environmental claim regulated by the FTC. Under the Green Guides, marketers must have competent scientific evidence to support offset claims, use proper accounting methods, avoid selling the same reduction more than once, and disclose when purchased offsets won’t produce emission reductions for two or more years.2Federal Trade Commission. Environmental Claims: Summary of the Green Guides The Green Guides were last updated in 2012, and the FTC has signaled review is ongoing as carbon-neutral marketing claims have proliferated.
CORSIA for Aviation
International aviation operates under its own framework, CORSIA (Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation), administered by the International Civil Aviation Organization. Airlines must cancel “CORSIA Eligible Emissions Units” in quantities equal to their offsetting requirements for each compliance period.11ICAO. CORSIA Eligible Emissions Units The program is in its first mandatory phase (2024–2026), with only credits from approved programs eligible for compliance. CORSIA is effectively a hybrid: airlines are required to offset, but the credits they buy come from voluntary market project types that meet ICAO’s quality criteria.
Tax Treatment for Sellers and Developers
The IRS has not issued comprehensive guidance on income from voluntary carbon credit sales, which creates genuine uncertainty for landowners and project developers. Based on existing tax principles, credit payments received by a landowner operating a farm or timber business are generally treated as ordinary income reported on the business return. If the land is held as a passive investment, payments would be reported as other income. Upfront costs like legal fees and consultant expenses to set up a carbon project are capital in nature and should be amortized over the life of the carbon contract rather than deducted in the year paid.
Industrial carbon capture has clearer guidance. The Section 45Q tax credit provides a per-ton credit for qualified carbon oxide captured and stored in secure geological formations or used in qualifying industrial processes.12Internal Revenue Service. Treasury, IRS Provide Safe Harbor for Taxpayers Claiming the Carbon Capture Credit That is a different mechanism from selling voluntary market credits — it’s a direct tax credit, not income from a market transaction — but it’s the most developed piece of IRS guidance in the carbon space. Anyone receiving substantial payments from carbon credit sales should work with a tax professional familiar with the still-evolving treatment of these payments.