A fair rate on a personal loan between individuals sits above the IRS Applicable Federal Rate (currently 3.59% to 4.72% depending on the term) and below your state’s usury cap, with the exact figure tuned to the borrower’s credit, any collateral, and what the money could earn you elsewhere. Deciding how much interest to charge on a personal loan is really about staying inside those two legal boundaries and then pricing the risk you’re taking. Go lower than the federal floor and the IRS will tax you on interest you never collected. Go higher than your state’s ceiling and a court can wipe out your right to the interest, and in some states the principal too.
The Federal Floor: Applicable Federal Rates
Federal tax law sets the lowest defensible rate. Under 26 U.S.C. ยง 7872, any loan between individuals that charges interest below the Applicable Federal Rate is treated as a “below-market loan.”1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 7872 – Treatment of Loans With Below-Market Interest Rates The IRS treats the forgone interest as if you’d given it to the borrower as a gift, and the borrower paid it back to you as interest. You owe income tax on that phantom interest, and you may trigger gift tax reporting on top.
The AFR is published monthly and comes in three tiers based on the loan’s length:2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1274 – Determination of Issue Price in the Case of Certain Debt Instruments Issued for Property
- Short-term (three years or less): 3.59% annually
- Mid-term (over three years, up to nine): 3.93% annually
- Long-term (over nine years): 4.72% annually
Those are the March 2026 figures, and they move each month.3Internal Revenue Service. Revenue Ruling 2026-6 – Applicable Federal Rates Check the current revenue ruling before you finalize anything. For a fixed-rate term loan, the rate in effect the month you fund locks in for the life of the note.
When the AFR Doesn’t Apply
Two carve-outs matter for most private lenders.
If the total you’ve lent one person is $10,000 or less, Section 7872 doesn’t apply at all, and you can charge zero interest without any imputed income.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 7872 – Treatment of Loans With Below-Market Interest Rates The exception vanishes if the borrower uses the money to buy stocks, bonds, or other income-producing assets, and the threshold is measured across all your outstanding loans to that person, not each one separately.
For gift loans at or below $100,000, the imputed interest you’d owe tax on is capped at the borrower’s actual net investment income for the year.4Internal Revenue Service. Publication 550 (2025) – Investment Income and Expenses If the borrower’s investment income is under $1,000, it’s treated as zero, and nothing gets imputed. This cap doesn’t apply if a principal purpose of the arrangement is dodging federal tax.
Even where imputed interest technically applies, actual gift tax is rare. The 2026 annual gift tax exclusion is $19,000 per recipient. On a $50,000 interest-free loan, the forgone interest at the mid-term AFR comes to about $1,965 a year, comfortably under the exclusion. Anything over the annual exclusion counts against your $15,000,000 lifetime exemption before any gift tax actually comes due.5Internal Revenue Service. What’s New – Estate and Gift Tax
The State Ceiling: Usury Caps
Every state caps how much interest a private lender can charge. The limits vary widely. Some states hold the ceiling in the single digits for noncommercial loans; others allow more. Caps for personal loans outside special lending statutes generally fall somewhere between 5% and 15%.
Charging above the cap carries steep consequences. Depending on the state, a court may strip away all the interest the borrower owes and leave you with just the principal. In harsher jurisdictions you can lose the right to collect even the principal. Some states impose damages of two or three times the excess interest you collected. These issues usually surface during a payment dispute or a bankruptcy, when a judge takes a close look at the original terms. Look up the usury statute for the state where the borrower lives or where the loan is signed before you set a number.
Picking a Rate Between the Floor and the Ceiling
The AFR is the lowest rate you can defend; the usury cap is the highest rate you can legally charge. Everything in between is judgment, and the sensible anchor is not either boundary but what banks are actually charging.
Start From the Prime Rate
The prime rate, which banks charge their most creditworthy customers, sits at 6.75% as of early 2026.6Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. Bank Prime Loan Rate (DPRIME) Institutional personal loans start just under 7% for borrowers with excellent credit and climb from there. Prime is a better reference point than the AFR floor because it reflects what the borrower would actually pay a bank.
Price the Risk
A borrower with steady income and solid credit justifies a rate close to prime, or lower if you’d lend to them regardless. Someone with uneven earnings or a history of missed payments justifies more. That’s arithmetic, not punishment. A 10% default probability on a five-year, $20,000 loan is a $2,000 expected loss before you account for inflation, and the rate has to carry that risk.
Collateral changes the calculation. A loan secured by a vehicle title or real estate is meaningfully safer than an unsecured promise, because you have a recovery path if the payments stop. Secured loans belong near the AFR. Unsecured loans to riskier borrowers belong closer to the state cap.
Account for Inflation and What Else the Money Could Do
Money repaid in five years buys less than money today. If inflation runs around 3% over the life of the loan, a 3.93% mid-term AFR barely breaks even in real terms. Weigh the alternatives too. If a high-yield savings account pays 4.5%, lending at 3.59% means you’re losing ground against the easiest substitute. Your rate should at least match your next-best option, with a premium on top for the risk that the borrower won’t pay.
Putting the Rate in Writing
Whatever rate you choose only holds up if it’s documented. A handshake loan is nearly impossible to enforce and creates problems with the IRS, which looks for signs that a “loan” was really a gift. In most states a promissory note doesn’t need to be notarized to be binding, but notarization helps if the borrower later denies signing.
At a minimum the note should state:
- The principal amount.
- The annual interest rate, whether it’s fixed or variable, and the benchmark if variable.
- The interest calculation method. Simple interest is calculated only on the original principal; compound interest adds unpaid interest to the balance and grows faster. On a $20,000 loan at 6% for five years, simple interest totals $6,000, while monthly compounding comes to about $6,400. Specify the method and the accrual frequency (daily, monthly, or annually).
- The payment schedule and maturity date.
- Late fees as a specific dollar amount or percentage. Many states cap these, and they’re only enforceable if they appear in the agreement.
- What counts as default and what happens if one occurs, including whether you can accelerate the full balance.
- Signatures and the date, ideally with a witness.
A clear interest rate in a signed note also protects you if the loan goes bad. If you lent money with the understanding that the borrower might never repay it, the IRS treats the whole thing as a gift, and gifts aren’t deductible if they’re never returned.7Internal Revenue Service. Topic No. 453 – Bad Debt Deduction A real rate, written down, is the clearest evidence that both of you intended a genuine debt.
Reporting the Interest You Collect
Interest you receive on a personal loan is taxable, even if the borrower is a sibling and no bank ever touched the money.
If your total taxable interest from all sources tops $1,500 for the year, you file Schedule B with your Form 1040, listing each payer and the amount received. If you financed the sale of a home that the buyer uses as a personal residence, you also report the buyer’s name, address, and Social Security number on Schedule B, and leaving that out can draw a $50 penalty per occurrence.8Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Schedule B (Form 1040)
You generally don’t need to issue a 1099-INT. The IRS exempts interest paid on obligations issued by an individual from 1099-INT reporting.9Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Forms 1099-INT and 1099-OID You still owe tax on the interest and have to report it on your own return, but the paperwork is lighter than most people assume.
If you charged less than the AFR and the loan is over $10,000, the IRS expects you to report the forgone interest as income even though you never received it. The imputed figure is the difference between what you charged and what the AFR would have produced. On a $75,000 interest-free loan at the mid-term AFR of 3.93%, that’s roughly $2,948 of phantom income taxed each year. This is where most private lenders get caught, because the obligation stays invisible until an audit surfaces it. Setting the rate at or above the AFR from the start avoids the whole problem.