How Does Commodities Trading Work: Futures, Settlement, and Taxes

Commodities trading works by buying and selling standardized futures contracts on regulated exchanges, where a small margin deposit controls a much larger quantity of a raw material and prices move with global supply and demand. The most common instrument is the futures contract, and initial margin can run as low as 2% to 12% of a contract’s total notional value. That leverage is what pulls two very different groups into the same marketplace: hedgers who want price certainty and speculators who want to profit from price movement.

What You Are Actually Trading

Commodities fall into two broad groups. Hard commodities are natural resources pulled from the earth: crude oil, natural gas, gold, copper. Soft commodities are grown or raised: wheat, corn, coffee, sugar, cattle.

What makes any of them tradable at scale is fungibility. One unit of a specific grade is interchangeable with any other unit of the same grade. A bushel of No. 2 yellow corn from Iowa is identical, for trading purposes, to one from Nebraska. Because of that, buyers don’t inspect individual shipments before agreeing on a price, and millions of contracts change hands daily across borders without disputes over quality.

A futures contract is a legally binding agreement to buy or sell a specific quantity of that commodity at a set price on a future date. The exchange writes the specifications, not the parties. A standard gold futures contract on the COMEX division of CME Group represents exactly 100 troy ounces of gold assaying to a minimum of 995 fineness.1CME Group. Gold Futures and Options – Contract Specs A WTI crude oil contract on NYMEX represents 1,000 barrels, deliverable at pipeline and storage facilities in Cushing, Oklahoma.2CME Group. Crude Oil Futures Contract Specs Every buyer and seller trades the same product, so the only variable left is price.

Where Commodities Trade and Who Regulates Them

Centralized exchanges provide the regulated environment for commodity trading. The two dominant U.S. platforms are CME Group and the Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), both operating under the oversight of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Federal law makes it illegal to manipulate or attempt to manipulate the price of any commodity in interstate commerce or for future delivery on any registered exchange.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. U.S. Code Title 7 – 9 Prohibition Regarding Manipulation and False Information

Exchanges do two things that make the market function. They deliver price discovery, which is the real-time consensus of what a commodity is worth. And they standardize the contract itself, so participants argue over price and nothing else.

How a Futures Contract Actually Works

You don’t pay the full value of the commodity upfront. You post an initial margin, a good-faith deposit that typically runs from about 2% to 12% of notional value. The gap between what you deposit and what you control is leverage, and it cuts both ways.

Take a crude oil contract for 1,000 barrels at $75 per barrel. Notional value is $75,000, but the initial margin might be roughly $5,000 to $6,000. If oil rises $2 a barrel, the position gains $2,000, a return of more than 30% on the margin deposit. If it falls $2, the loss is just as large. This is where inexperienced traders get burned; a modest move against your position can wipe out a meaningful share of your account in a single session.

A trader who expects prices to rise buys a contract, going long. One who expects a decline sells, going short. Every trading day, the exchange marks positions to market: it recalculates each open position at that day’s settlement price and credits gains or debits losses directly to the trader’s margin account. If the account falls below the maintenance margin threshold, a margin call goes out and additional funds have to be deposited immediately. Miss the call and the exchange liquidates the position. You don’t get to wait and hope for a recovery.

Sitting behind every trade is the exchange’s clearinghouse, which guarantees performance by acting as the buyer to every seller and the seller to every buyer.4Federal Reserve. Central Clearing Counterparties in the Financial Accounts of the United States You never have to worry about whether the person on the other side can pay. The clearinghouse absorbs that counterparty risk.

How Contracts End

Cash Settlement

Most financial traders never touch the physical commodity. In a cash-settled contract, the exchange calculates the difference between your entry price and the final settlement price on the last trading day, then credits or debits your account. No trucks, no warehouses. Most retail brokers automatically roll positions to the next contract month or trigger cash settlement well before expiration, so the typical individual never faces a delivery scenario.4Federal Reserve. Central Clearing Counterparties in the Financial Accounts of the United States

Physical Delivery

Some contracts require the seller to deliver the actual commodity to an exchange-approved facility. For WTI crude oil, that means pipeline or storage facilities in Cushing, Oklahoma, a hub that holds a significant share of U.S. commercial crude storage capacity.5U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). Crude Oil Inventories in Cushing, Oklahoma, Are Down More Than 40% From Start of 2021 For gold, each bar must fall within tight weight and fineness tolerances and carry an approved brand stamp.6CME Group. Chapter 113 Gold Futures – Contract Specifications

Physical delivery is overwhelmingly the domain of commercial participants who actually need the commodity. A retail trader who forgets to close or roll a physically settled contract before expiration can end up contractually obligated to take delivery of a warehouse full of soybeans. Basic position management avoids this entirely.

Contango, Backwardation, and Rolling

Futures contracts don’t always trade at the same price as the current spot price. When a futures contract trades at a premium to spot, the market is in contango. When it trades at a discount, it’s in backwardation. As any contract approaches expiration, the futures price converges with the spot price; otherwise traders would exploit the gap through arbitrage.

Contango is the more common condition in many commodity markets, and it creates a hidden drag on returns. Most financial traders don’t hold a contract to expiration. They roll their position by selling the expiring contract and buying a longer-dated one. In a contango market, the longer-dated contract costs more than the one being sold, so each roll chips away at returns even if the underlying commodity price hasn’t moved. This is why some commodity investments underperform the spot price over long stretches. Backwardation works the other way: rolling into a cheaper contract produces a small gain each time.

Who Is on the Other Side of Your Trade

Every functional commodity market needs two kinds of participants, and neither works without the other.

Hedgers are producers and consumers of the physical goods: farmers, mining companies, refiners, airlines, food processors. They use futures to lock in prices and remove uncertainty from business planning. A wheat farmer might sell futures months before harvest, guaranteeing a price that covers production costs regardless of what happens between planting and the crop coming in. An airline might buy crude oil or heating oil futures to stabilize fuel costs, since jet fuel prices correlate closely with those benchmarks.

Speculators have no interest in taking delivery of 1,000 barrels of crude oil. They trade price movement, and they provide something hedgers need: liquidity. Without speculators willing to take the other side, a farmer trying to sell grain futures might not find a buyer at a reasonable price. Speculators absorb price risk hedgers want to shed, and in return they get the chance to profit from correctly anticipating where prices are headed.

Guardrails Built Into the Market

Exchanges impose daily price limits to prevent runaway moves during periods of panic or euphoria. When a commodity hits its limit, different things happen depending on the product: trading may pause while limits are expanded, the contract may stay locked at the limit price, or trading may halt for the rest of the session. Agricultural commodities tend to use fixed dollar limits, while energy and metals products often use dynamic circuit breakers that recalculate limits based on the prior day’s settlement.7CME Group. Price Limits: Ags, Energy, Metals, Equity Index

Separately, the CFTC sets federal limits on how many contracts a single speculator can hold in a given commodity. Limits apply to the spot month, any single delivery month, and all months combined, and they tighten further as a contract approaches expiration.8eCFR. 17 CFR Part 150 – Limits on Positions Commercial hedgers who can show a legitimate need to exceed the limits can apply for exemptions; pure speculators cannot.

How Commodity Trading Is Taxed

Commodity futures get a tax treatment that surprises people coming from stocks. Under Section 1256 of the Internal Revenue Code, regulated futures contracts are marked to market at year-end, meaning every open position is treated as if it were sold on December 31, and any resulting gain or loss is reported that year whether you actually closed the trade or not.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1256 Section 1256 Contracts Marked to Market

The real advantage is the 60/40 rule. Regardless of how long you held the position, 60% of any gain or loss is treated as long-term capital gain and 40% as short-term.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1256 Section 1256 Contracts Marked to Market For a trader in a high bracket, that blended rate is substantially lower than the ordinary income rate that would apply to short-term stock trades. Section 1256 gains and losses are reported on IRS Form 6781.

One more difference matters. The wash sale rule that stops stock traders from claiming a loss if they repurchase a substantially identical security within 30 days does not apply to commodity futures contracts.10Internal Revenue Service. Publication 550 (2025), Investment Income and Expenses You can close a losing futures position and immediately reopen it without losing the deduction. Brokers report commodity trading activity on Form 1099-B, which arrives early in the year following the tax year.11Internal Revenue Service. About Form 1099-B, Proceeds from Broker and Barter Exchange Transactions

Other Ways to Get Commodity Exposure

Futures contracts are the most direct route into commodities, but they aren’t the only one, and for many retail investors they aren’t the best fit. Leverage, margin calls, and expiration mechanics all demand active management and a tolerance for fast losses. A few alternatives offer commodity exposure with less complexity.

  • Commodity ETFs and ETNs track the price of a single commodity or a basket. You buy and sell shares through a standard brokerage account with no margin requirements or expirations to manage. The tradeoff: many commodity ETFs hold futures internally, so they carry the same contango drag, and their long-term performance can lag the spot price.
  • Options on futures give you the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell a futures contract at a specific price. The most you can lose is the premium paid, which caps downside in a way futures don’t. Pricing is more complex, but they’re popular with anyone wanting a defined-risk position.
  • Commodity producer stocks (oil and gas firms, miners, agricultural conglomerates) give indirect exposure. Their prices move with commodities but also with company-specific factors like debt, management, and production costs. They trade in a regular brokerage account and can pay dividends, which futures never do.

Tax treatment, fees, and risk profiles differ across these routes. The 60/40 tax advantage under Section 1256 applies to regulated futures contracts and certain options, but not to commodity ETF shares or producer stocks, which follow standard capital gains rules based on holding period.