How Does Bank-Owned Life Insurance Work: Accounts, Taxes, and Rules

Bank-owned life insurance works like this: a bank buys a permanent life insurance policy on a key employee, pays the premium, names itself as both owner and beneficiary, and holds the policy’s growing cash surrender value as an asset on its balance sheet. The employee is the insured life and nothing more. The bank collects the death benefit when the insured eventually dies, and in the meantime the cash value compounds without current income tax. Banks use this structure, usually shortened to BOLI, to help offset the rising cost of pensions, deferred compensation, and retiree healthcare.

Who Owns the Policy and Who Gets Paid

The bank is the policyholder, the premium payer, and the beneficiary. The insured employee has no ownership rights, no access to the cash value, and no ability to name a personal beneficiary. That is the opposite of a personal life insurance policy, where the insured controls the contract. With BOLI, the employee’s only role is being the life that’s insured.

The cash surrender value appears on the bank’s Call Report under “Life Insurance Assets” within other assets, and it grows as the policy earns investment returns.1Community Banking Connections. Bank-Owned Life Insurance: A Primer for Community Banks Banks treat the asset much like a bond holding, and the income it generates helps cover the cost of employee benefit programs on the income statement. BOLI doesn’t fund those benefit plans directly the way a pension trust does; it informally offsets them.

State insurable interest laws also apply. The bank has to face a genuine financial loss from the insured person’s death, which is why BOLI policies cover executives, directors, and other key employees whose departure would materially affect the institution rather than rank-and-file staff.

How the Policy Is Funded

Most BOLI purchases are funded with a single lump-sum premium, often in the millions, that fully funds the policy on day one. Compounding starts immediately, and the bank gets to redeploy excess liquidity out of low-yielding bonds into an asset that earns competitive after-tax returns. Some banks spread premiums over several years to manage liquidity, but that delays the full benefit of tax-deferred growth.

Lump-sum funding almost always makes the policy a Modified Endowment Contract (MEC) under IRC Section 7702A. A policy becomes a MEC when premiums paid in the first seven years exceed IRS limits under the 7-pay test. Banks are generally comfortable with MEC status because they don’t plan to touch the cash value during the insured’s lifetime, but the classification matters if they ever do, because withdrawals and policy loans are taxed less favorably than on a non-MEC policy.

Where the Money Actually Sits: Account Structures

The insurance carrier holds the policy’s assets in one of three account structures, and the choice drives how much credit risk the bank takes on and how returns flow through.

General Account

The bank’s cash value is backed by the carrier’s overall investment portfolio, and the carrier typically guarantees a minimum crediting rate. The trade-off is credit risk: if the insurer becomes insolvent, the bank is an unsecured general creditor.2FDIC. Interagency Statement on the Purchase and Risk Management of Life Insurance – Risk Management of BOLI General account policies also carry interest rate risk because crediting rates reset as the carrier’s underlying bonds roll over.

Separate Account

Assets backing the bank’s cash value are segregated from the carrier’s general assets, so they are protected from the carrier’s creditors if it fails. The bank gets more investment flexibility, but the cash value can fluctuate with market conditions unless the policy includes stable value protection, which smooths returns and provides book-value accounting treatment.

Hybrid Account

Hybrid policies hold assets in separate accounts for creditor protection but use a crediting-rate approach rather than passing investment gains and losses straight through. With a stable value wrap, the bank avoids mark-to-market exposure while keeping the credit protection of a separate account. Many banks find this the best balance of safety and predictability.

Why Banks Buy It: The Tax Math

The tax treatment is the whole point. Three features work together.

First, the cash surrender value grows each year without triggering current income tax. The bank books the growth as income, but the tax liability is deferred as long as the policy stays in force.1Community Banking Connections. Bank-Owned Life Insurance: A Primer for Community Banks A policy earning 3.5 percent tax-free produces the same after-tax income as a taxable bond earning considerably more.

Second, when the insured dies, the bank receives the death benefit free of federal income tax, provided the notice-and-consent rules were followed and the insured qualified under one of the status exceptions.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 101 – Certain Death Benefits The death benefit typically exceeds the cash value, so the bank books a lump-sum gain with no tax bill.

Third, and this is the one banks have to respect, early access is expensive. The only ways to pull cash out before the insured dies are to surrender the policy or borrow against the cash value.1Community Banking Connections. Bank-Owned Life Insurance: A Primer for Community Banks A surrender produces ordinary income on the gain above premiums paid, plus surrender charges from the carrier. And because most BOLI policies are MECs, policy loans and withdrawals are taxed last-in, first-out: earnings come out first and are taxed as ordinary income. BOLI is a buy-and-hold asset. Treating it as a liquidity source misunderstands the product.

Who Can Be Insured, and What They Have to Agree To

Federal law requires three things from the employee before the policy is issued. The employee must receive written notice that the bank intends to insure their life, including the maximum face amount. The employee must give written consent to being insured and to coverage continuing after they leave the bank. And the employee must be told in writing that the bank will receive the death benefit.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 101 – Certain Death Benefits These requirements come from the Pension Protection Act of 2006 and sit in IRC Section 101(j).

Skip any of them and the tax exclusion collapses. Instead of excluding the full death benefit, the bank can only exclude an amount equal to the premiums it paid; all gain above that becomes taxable.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 101 – Certain Death Benefits That alone can erase the economics of the program.

Even with proper consent, the tax-free death benefit holds only if the insured falls into one of these categories:

  • Someone employed by the bank at any point during the 12 months before death.
  • A member of the board of directors when the policy was issued.
  • Someone in the top 35 percent of employees by compensation when the policy was issued.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 101 – Certain Death Benefits

In practice, that keeps the insured pool to senior officers, executives, and directors.

What Happens When the Employee Leaves

Banks typically keep BOLI policies in force long after the insured retires or resigns. The cash value keeps growing, and the death benefit will eventually be paid regardless of whether the person still works there. This is why the original consent form has to spell out that coverage can continue after departure.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 101 – Certain Death Benefits

For the death benefit to stay tax-free after the person leaves, the insured must have been employed at some point in the 12 months before death, or must have qualified as a director or highly compensated employee when the policy was originally issued. If an executive leaves and dies more than 12 months later, the exclusion depends on whether they met one of the status-based exceptions at issuance. Banks track qualifying status from the day the policy is written for exactly this reason.

The Rules Banks Have to Follow

Three federal agencies share oversight of bank BOLI holdings: the OCC, the Federal Reserve, and the FDIC. Their joint 2004 Interagency Statement on the Purchase and Risk Management of Life Insurance is still the foundational guidance.

The guidance treats BOLI with an aggregate cash surrender value above 25 percent of the bank’s capital as generally imprudent. A bank that wants to exceed that threshold needs prior board approval and has to justify the concentration to examiners.4FDIC. Interagency Statement on the Purchase and Risk Management of Life Insurance Banks at or near the limit should expect closer scrutiny.

Before buying, the board is expected to review the carrier’s financial strength, the expected yield against alternative investments, the capital impact, and the liquidity constraints of the policy. The board also has to understand the account structure and the credit risk it carries.2FDIC. Interagency Statement on the Purchase and Risk Management of Life Insurance – Risk Management of BOLI Skipping that analysis invites enforcement action.

On the reporting side, banks with BOLI holdings file IRS Form 8925 each year, reporting the number of employees covered under employer-owned life insurance contracts issued after August 17, 2006, and the total coverage in force at year-end.5Internal Revenue Service. About Form 8925 – Report of Employer-Owned Life Insurance Contracts Internally, examiners expect to see the original consent forms for every insured employee, the board’s pre-purchase analysis, ongoing carrier financial reviews, and annual stress testing that looks at how interest rate changes, carrier downgrades, or regulatory shifts could affect the portfolio.4FDIC. Interagency Statement on the Purchase and Risk Management of Life Insurance BOLI-related assets and liabilities also show up in annual financial statements, where examiners review them during routine exams.