A preferential payment in bankruptcy is money or property the debtor transferred to a creditor shortly before filing that left that creditor better off than they would have been in a normal bankruptcy distribution. Federal law lets the bankruptcy trustee claw those payments back and redistribute the funds to all creditors on equal terms. For ordinary creditors, the look-back window is the 90 days before the filing date. For insiders such as relatives, business partners, and company officers, it stretches to a full year. Whether you are a debtor thinking about timing or a creditor who just opened a demand letter, the rules below decide whether the money stays where it is.
The Five Elements of a Preference
A trustee can undo a pre-bankruptcy payment only by proving every part of a five-element test in the Bankruptcy Code. Miss one, and the payment stands.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 11 USC 547 – Preferences
- The debtor transferred property to a creditor.
- The transfer paid down a debt that already existed when the payment was made. Settling last month’s invoice counts; cash at the register for today’s purchase does not.
- The debtor was insolvent at the time, meaning total debts exceeded the fair value of non-exempt property.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 11 USC 101 – Definitions
- The transfer happened within 90 days before filing, or within one year if the creditor was an insider.
- The creditor ended up with more than they would have received in a Chapter 7 liquidation.
That last element does most of the work. If unsecured creditors would collect 15 cents on the dollar in a Chapter 7 case and one creditor got paid in full on the eve of filing, that creditor plainly came out ahead, and the trustee can recover the difference. The same math explains why payments to fully secured creditors are usually safe. A creditor whose collateral already covers the debt would be paid in full in liquidation anyway, so paying them early changes only the timing. The fifth element fails and the claim collapses.
The Insolvency Presumption
The trustee does not have to prove insolvency from a cold start. Federal law presumes the debtor was insolvent throughout the 90 days before filing. In practice, that shifts the burden to the creditor: if you want to argue the debtor was actually solvent when they paid you, you need the financial records to show it. The presumption does not extend to the insider window between 90 days and one year, so for those older transfers the trustee has to prove insolvency on the actual date of each payment.
Who Counts as an Insider
The one-year window reaches people and entities close enough to the debtor to have had inside knowledge or influence over who got paid. The Bankruptcy Code defines insiders by the type of debtor involved:3Cornell Law School. 11 USC 101 – Definitions
- For an individual debtor: relatives, general partners, and any corporation where the debtor is a director, officer, or person in control.
- For a corporate debtor: directors, officers, controlling persons, general partners, and the relatives of any of them.
- For a partnership debtor: general partners, their relatives, and anyone controlling the partnership.
Affiliates and managing agents are also swept in. The person must have been an insider at the time of the transfer, not just at some later point.
Dollar Thresholds That Block a Claim
Not every small payment is worth chasing, and federal law sets floors below which the trustee cannot pursue a preference at all.
- If the debtor’s debts are primarily consumer debts, the trustee cannot recover a transfer worth less than $600.
- If the debts are not primarily consumer debts, the threshold is $8,575 as of April 2025. The statutory base figure was $5,000, and the amount adjusts periodically for inflation.
A payment below the applicable threshold is a complete defense on its own. You do not need to argue ordinary course or anything else; the trustee simply cannot bring the claim.
How the Trustee Comes After the Money
The bankruptcy trustee is the court-appointed official in charge of collecting the estate’s assets and distributing them to creditors. The preference recovery process usually runs in two stages.
First, the trustee reviews bank statements, payment records, and the debtor’s financial schedules, picks out transfers that look like preferences, and sends a demand letter. Since 2020, federal law has required the trustee to perform “reasonable due diligence” before pursuing a claim, including a look at the defenses the creditor might raise. The provision was aimed at the practice of mass-mailing demand letters without any underlying investigation, though some courts treat a bare allegation of due diligence in the complaint as enough, so the protection is thinner than it sounds. Demand letters often include a discounted settlement figure to avoid the cost of litigation on both sides.
If the creditor refuses or ignores the letter, the trustee files an adversary proceeding, which is a lawsuit inside the bankruptcy case with its own procedural rules.4Cornell Law School. Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure Rule 7001 – Types of Adversary Proceedings The trustee has to prove all five preference elements. If the trustee carries that burden, the creditor then has to prove any defenses. Ignoring the complaint invites a default judgment, after which the trustee can collect.
Defenses That Protect the Payment
Even when all five elements are present, several defenses can keep the money with the creditor. The creditor raises them as affirmative defenses and carries the burden of proof.
Ordinary Course of Business
A payment made on the same timing and terms the two parties always used, or on terms standard in the industry, qualifies for the ordinary course defense. A vendor paid on 30-day terms who kept being paid on 30-day terms is not being preferred, just paid. The creditor only has to satisfy one of the two prongs; either the parties’ own history or the industry norm will do.
Contemporaneous Exchange for New Value
When both sides intend a transaction to be a swap of payment for goods or services at the same time, the transfer is protected. Cash at the counter is the textbook example. Both sides get what they bargained for at once, and the estate is no worse off.
Subsequent New Value
If a creditor received a payment and then provided more goods, services, or credit to the debtor afterward, the later value offsets the earlier preference. The rule exists to encourage vendors to keep shipping to a struggling customer. The new value has to be unsecured; if the creditor took a lien to protect the new delivery, the defense is lost.
Purchase-Money Security Interests
When a lender advances funds specifically so the debtor can buy a particular asset, and the debtor uses the money for exactly that, the resulting security interest is protected so long as it is perfected within 30 days after the debtor receives the property. Equipment loans and vehicle financing typically qualify.
Domestic Support Obligations
Payments for child support or alimony are fully protected from preference recovery, as long as the payment was made in good faith. The exemption reflects a policy that family support outranks equalizing creditor distributions.
If You Receive a Preference Demand Letter
A letter from a trustee is the opening move, not the final word. Work the basics first. Was the payment actually inside the 90-day window, or 91 days or more before the filing date? Is the amount above the applicable threshold of $600 or $8,575? Were you fully secured at the time? Any one of those can knock the claim out, and a short response letter may be enough to resolve it.
Then pull your records. Invoices, payment histories, shipping documents, and emails are what prove ordinary course, contemporaneous exchange, or subsequent new value. Creditors who answer with organized documentation and a clear defense theory negotiate from a much stronger position than creditors who panic or go silent.
Settlement is the usual outcome. Trustees know litigation is expensive and uncertain, and most preference claims resolve without trial. Opening offers sometimes come in around a 20% discount off the demand, but a creditor with real defenses can often do considerably better. The lever is responding on time, laying out the evidence, and making the trustee decide whether the case is worth bringing.
What Happens After You Return the Money
Paying back a preference, whether through settlement or judgment, does not leave you empty-handed. Federal law lets you file an unsecured claim against the estate for the amount you returned, and the claim is treated as if it existed before the bankruptcy filing, so it rides along with other unsecured claims in the distribution.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 11 USC 502 – Allowance of Claims or Interests
Realistically that often means pennies on the dollar, since unsecured creditors in most cases collect only modest distributions. But the claim preserves whatever share the estate does pay out. One important catch: a creditor who owes money to the estate under a preference judgment and refuses to pay can have their claim disallowed entirely until the obligation is satisfied. Ignoring a preference judgment costs more than the judgment amount; it can wipe out any distribution you would otherwise have received.