How Are RESP Withdrawals Taxed? EAPs, AIPs, and the 20% Penalty

RESP withdrawals are taxed based on which of three pools the money comes from. Your original contributions come back tax-free. Government grants and investment growth paid out while the beneficiary is in school are taxed as income to the student, who usually pays little or nothing thanks to the basic personal amount. And if the beneficiary never pursues post-secondary education, the growth comes out to you as the subscriber, taxed at your marginal rate plus an additional 20% federal penalty (12% in Quebec). Knowing which bucket a withdrawal draws from is the difference between a nearly tax-free payout and losing more than half of it to the CRA.

The Three Pools Inside Your Plan

Every RESP holds three distinct types of money, and each follows its own tax rules on the way out:

  • Your contributions — after-tax dollars you deposited over the years.
  • Government grants — mainly the Canada Education Savings Grant, worth 20% of annual contributions up to $500 per year and $7,200 over the beneficiary’s lifetime, with additional CESG available to lower-income families.1Canada Revenue Agency. Canada Education Savings Grant2Government of Canada. Registered Education Savings Plans and Related Benefits
  • Investment earnings — interest, dividends, and capital gains that grew tax-free inside the plan.

When a student is enrolled in a qualifying program, the grants and earnings come out together as an Educational Assistance Payment (EAP), while contributions come out separately. That split determines who pays tax and how much.

Withdrawing Your Contributions: No Tax

Pulling out your original contributions triggers no tax, regardless of whether the beneficiary is in school and regardless of who receives the money. You already paid income tax on those dollars before depositing them. No T4A slip is issued, and the amount never appears on anyone’s return.3Canada.ca. T4A Slip – Information for Payers

There’s no CRA-imposed cap on the size of a contribution withdrawal. You could pull the entire contribution balance in a single transaction. Most families pair contribution withdrawals with EAPs to cover student expenses while keeping the student’s taxable income low.

One caution. If you withdraw contributions when no beneficiary is eligible for an EAP, the plan may have to repay a proportional amount of CESG to the government.4Justice Laws Website. Canada Education Savings Regulations – Section 11 When a student is enrolled and receiving EAPs, this isn’t a concern. Otherwise, ask your RESP promoter whether a grant clawback will be triggered before you request the withdrawal.

Withdrawals for School: EAPs Taxed to the Student

Educational Assistance Payments are the taxable side of an RESP withdrawal. An EAP bundles all accumulated grants and investment earnings into a single payment made to the beneficiary. The student reports the full amount as income for the year they receive it, and the RESP promoter issues a T4A slip.3Canada.ca. T4A Slip – Information for Payers

This is where the RESP design pays off. Most full-time students have little other income. The federal basic personal amount for 2026 shelters roughly the first $16,400 of income from federal tax, and provincial credits add more room on top. A student receiving $10,000 or even $15,000 in EAP income in a year without significant employment earnings will often owe little or no tax. Growth and grants accumulate tax-free inside the plan, then come out taxed to someone in a very low bracket.

How Much You Can Take as an EAP

The CRA caps EAP withdrawals during the first 13 consecutive weeks of enrollment. For a full-time student the cap is $8,000. For a part-time student in a specified educational program, the cap is $4,000 per 13-week period.5Canada Revenue Agency. Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP) Bulletin No.1R3 These limits were set by legislation in 2023 and aren’t indexed.

Once a full-time student completes 13 consecutive weeks of enrollment, the per-period cap disappears. If the student then goes 12 months without a 13-week enrollment stretch, the $8,000 cap resets.5Canada Revenue Agency. Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP) Bulletin No.1R3

Even after that first period, an annual reasonableness threshold still applies. For 2026 that threshold is $29,459. If total EAP withdrawals in a calendar year exceed this amount, the promoter must verify the expenses are reasonable and may ask for receipts before releasing more.5Canada Revenue Agency. Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP) Bulletin No.1R3

The Six-Month Window After Leaving School

A beneficiary can still receive EAPs for up to six months after they stop being enrolled, as long as the payment would have qualified as an EAP immediately before enrollment ended.6Canada Revenue Agency. Registered Education Savings Plans Payments, Transferring and Rolling Over Registered Education Savings Plans Property This gives graduates a window to draw down remaining EAP funds at student tax rates. Miss it, and the ability to take EAPs is gone — anything still inside the plan has to come out through the far more expensive routes below.

When No One Goes to School: AIPs and the 20% Penalty

If the beneficiary never pursues post-secondary education, the investment growth inside the plan doesn’t vanish. It comes out to you as the subscriber through an Accumulated Income Payment (AIP), and the tax treatment is deliberately harsh.

An AIP contains only investment growth. All government grants must be repaid to the federal government first.4Justice Laws Website. Canada Education Savings Regulations – Section 11 The AIP itself is added to the subscriber’s income for the year and taxed at your marginal rate. On top of that, an additional 20% federal tax applies under Part X.5 of the Income Tax Act. Quebec residents pay 12% instead of 20%.7Canada Revenue Agency. RESP – Accumulated Income Payments For a subscriber in a high tax bracket, the combined bite can easily exceed half the AIP amount. The government wants RESPs used for education, not as general tax shelters.

You Can’t Take an AIP Whenever You Want

The subscriber must be a Canadian resident, and the payment can only go to one subscriber. On top of that, at least one of the following must be true:8Canada Revenue Agency. Registered Education Savings Plans (RESPs)

  • The plan is past its 9th anniversary, every living beneficiary is at least 21, and no beneficiary currently qualifies for an EAP.
  • The plan has reached its 35th anniversary (40th for a specified plan where the beneficiary qualifies for the Disability Tax Credit).
  • All beneficiaries have died.

These conditions block subscribers from pulling the plug early. If the beneficiary is 18 and might still enroll, an AIP isn’t available.

Cutting the AIP Tax With an RRSP Transfer

The most effective way to soften the AIP hit is to transfer the money into your RRSP, pooled registered pension plan, or specified pension plan. The lifetime cap on this transfer is $50,000, and you need enough contribution room in the receiving plan to absorb it. The transfer has to happen in the year of the AIP or within the first 60 days of the following year.6Canada Revenue Agency. Registered Education Savings Plans Payments, Transferring and Rolling Over Registered Education Savings Plans Property

You claim a deduction on your return that offsets the AIP income, which also removes the 20% Part X.5 penalty on the transferred portion. The money moves from one tax-sheltered account to another without immediate tax. Any AIP amount beyond $50,000, or beyond your available contribution room, is taxed in full with the penalty.

If the beneficiary qualifies for the Disability Tax Credit and is also the beneficiary of a Registered Disability Savings Plan, the AIP can instead be rolled into the RDSP on a tax-deferred basis. The beneficiary must be a Canadian resident, under 60, and eligible for the DTC, and the RDSP holder must consent.6Canada Revenue Agency. Registered Education Savings Plans Payments, Transferring and Rolling Over Registered Education Savings Plans Property

Family Plans Can Avoid the Problem Entirely

Families with more than one child often use family RESPs, which let a younger sibling use the funds if an older beneficiary doesn’t need them. Naming a younger sibling as beneficiary keeps the EAP option open and takes the AIP tax off the table, as long as at least one beneficiary is pursuing post-secondary education.

If You or the Beneficiary Move Abroad

Residency changes the tax answer. A beneficiary must be a Canadian resident to receive the CESG or Canada Learning Bond portion of an EAP.8Canada Revenue Agency. Registered Education Savings Plans (RESPs) If they become non-resident, grant portions of the EAP may become unavailable or need to be repaid. The growth portion may still be payable but can face non-resident withholding, and the beneficiary’s new country of residence may tax the income as well.

The subscriber’s residency matters too. An AIP can only be paid to a subscriber who is a Canadian resident at the time of withdrawal.8Canada Revenue Agency. Registered Education Savings Plans (RESPs) If you’ve moved abroad and want to wind up the plan, the AIP route may be blocked until you re-establish residency. Families planning an international move should draw the RESP down strategically before leaving.