Form 42 is the informal name for HMRC’s Other Employment-Related Securities Annual Return, the yearly filing that UK companies use to report non-tax-advantaged share and securities transactions with employees or directors. If your company granted unapproved options, issued shares below market value, lifted a restriction on restricted shares, or did anything else that moved value to staff through securities outside a registered tax-advantaged scheme, you need to file one. The deadline is 6 July after the end of the tax year, and penalties start at £100 the day after.
When You Have to File
The UK tax year runs from 6 April to 5 April, and any “reportable event” involving employment-related securities in that window has to appear on the return. The four tax-advantaged schemes — Company Share Option Plans, Save As You Earn, Share Incentive Plans, and Enterprise Management Incentives — each have their own dedicated returns. Form 42 is the catch-all for everything else.
The categories of reportable event under ITEPA 2003 Part 7 are broad:1GOV.UK. Employment Related Securities and Arrangements (480: Chapter 23)
- Granting, exercising, assigning, releasing, or lapsing of unapproved options, and any cash or benefit received in connection with one.
- An employee or director acquiring shares for less than market value, including nil-cost awards.
- Any event that lifts, varies, or changes a restriction on restricted securities — for example, a forfeiture clause falling away at the end of a vesting period.
- Conversion events on convertible securities.
- Any artificial increase or decrease in the market value of securities that creates a tax charge.
- Discharge of a notional loan arising when securities were acquired below market value.
- Disposal of securities for more than they are worth, where the excess is employment income.
Bonus issues, rights issues, and share-for-share exchanges involving employees can also be reportable even when the immediate tax outcome is neutral. The test is whether the transaction is connected to someone’s employment, not whether it produces an immediate tax bill.
Register the Scheme Before You Try to File
You cannot file until the underlying scheme or arrangement is registered on HMRC’s ERS online service, and this is where companies most often run out of time. Registration runs through PAYE Online, so your company needs an active PAYE registration first.2GOV.UK. PAYE Online for Employers HMRC then sends an activation code by post within 10 days, and you have 28 days from the date on the letter to use it.
Every distinct arrangement needs its own registration: a one-off share award to a director, an ongoing option plan, a restricted share agreement. Starting the process the week before 6 July is a common reason for a first late filing.
What Data You Need
HMRC provides a template with separate tabs for each category of event — option grants, option exercises and releases, acquisitions, restricted securities, benefits from securities, convertibles, notional loan discharges, artificial enhancement of value, and disposals above market value.3GOV.UK. Other Employment Related Securities: Technical Note You only populate the tabs you need, but each demands granular detail: employer PAYE reference, employee name and National Insurance number, class and number of securities, exact date of the event, market value at the time, and any consideration paid.
Restricted securities carry a specific trap. You need the initial unrestricted market value, the actual market value after taking the restrictions into account, a description of the restrictions themselves, and the consideration paid. When a restriction is later lifted, that is a fresh reportable event needing a fresh valuation. One award can generate entries across several tax years.
Companies without a system for tracking share movements throughout the year routinely find gaps when they sit down to prepare the return. A simple spreadsheet logging every award, exercise, and lapse as it happens is far easier than reconstructing events from board minutes and email months later.
Valuing Shares in a Private Company
For listed companies the market value is the quoted price on the relevant date. For private companies, valuation is where most of the risk sits. The figure on your return is the one HMRC will scrutinise if they open a compliance check, and getting it wrong creates an underpayment that attracts both interest and a behaviour-based penalty.
HMRC’s own guidance is pragmatic: for the return itself, you do not need a formally agreed valuation. The market value should be “the best available value at the time of the particular transaction.”4GOV.UK. Employment Related Securities Manual – ERSM140090 – Reporting Requirements – Form 42 In practice that means a recent funding round price, an accountant’s valuation, or a documented directors’ assessment.
If you want certainty before filing, HMRC’s Shares and Assets Valuation unit will agree valuations in advance for EMI schemes on form VAL231, valid for 90 days.5GOV.UK. Get a Share Scheme Valuation From HMRC For non-tax-advantaged arrangements there is no equivalent formal clearance, but the unit can be approached informally to agree a methodology, which helps with complex share structures. Keep the valuation report, the underlying financial data, and any correspondence. HMRC can request the evidence years later.
How to Submit
Filing goes through the ERS online service. You can key data directly into the portal or upload a file. The system accepts ODS files (either HMRC’s downloadable template or your own file matching the specification) and CSVs that conform to the same structure.3GOV.UK. Other Employment Related Securities: Technical Note Column headers and sheet names must match HMRC’s specification exactly. A misnamed tab or an extra column will fail validation.
When the file passes, the system generates an acknowledgement receipt. Save it. That receipt is your proof of timely submission if HMRC later claims the return was not filed. The deadline for the 2025–26 tax year is 6 July 2026.6GOV.UK. Employment Related Securities Bulletin 64
Keep the submitted return and the supporting documents for the current tax year plus six years. HMRC can ask for evidence supporting the market values, employment status, or any other detail as part of a routine check.7GOV.UK. Employment Related Securities Bulletin 63
Nil Returns and Closing a Scheme
If your company has a registered scheme but no reportable events during the year, you still have to file a nil return by 6 July. HMRC treats a missing nil return the same as a missing return with transactions, and the full penalty regime applies.6GOV.UK. Employment Related Securities Bulletin 64 This catches companies that set up a scheme, never used it, and assumed silence was enough.
To end that obligation, close the scheme through the ERS online service by entering a final event date. You still have to file a return for the tax year in which that date falls.8GOV.UK. Employment Related Securities: Submit Returns If you have already ceased your PAYE scheme, check the ERS scheme separately. Closing one does not automatically close the other.
Penalties for Late Filing
The late filing regime is automatic and escalating. HMRC does not issue a warning first, and the penalties are charged by the calendar regardless of whether any tax is ultimately due:9GOV.UK. Check How to Deal With an Employment Related Securities Penalty
- £100 the day after 6 July, even if the return is only one day late.
- A further £300 at three months late.
- Another £300 at six months late.
- Daily penalties of £10 per day may apply once the return is nine months late, until it is submitted.
Penalties apply per scheme. A company with three registered schemes and three late returns faces three separate streams, and the numbers compound quickly. Paying the £100 does not buy time. The return still has to be filed to stop the clock.10GOV.UK. Employment Related Securities Manual – ERSM140080
On top of the filing penalties, any income tax or National Insurance that should have been collected through PAYE accrues late payment interest. As of January 2026 the rate is 7.75%, calculated as the Bank of England base rate plus 4%.11GOV.UK. HMRC Interest Rates for Late and Early Payments The interest runs from the date the tax should have been paid until it is paid, and it is not capped.
Penalties for Getting the Numbers Wrong
Filing on time but reporting inaccurate figures creates a separate penalty exposure. Under the general inaccuracy framework, penalties are a percentage of the potential lost revenue — the tax that would have been underpaid had the error gone undetected:12UK Parliament. Finance Act 2007, Schedule 24 – Penalties for Errors
- Careless error: up to 30%.
- Deliberate but not concealed: up to 70%.
- Deliberate and concealed: up to 100%.
The percentage drops if you tell HMRC about the error before they find it themselves. For tax-advantaged scheme returns, a separate fixed penalty of up to £5,000 applies for a material inaccuracy.13GOV.UK. Penalty for an Inaccuracy – CC/FS32 The practical implication is that a share valuation error is not just a paperwork problem. If HMRC decides your reported market value was too low, the resulting underpayment carries both interest and a behaviour-based penalty on top.
Appealing a Penalty
You can challenge a penalty notice if you believe you had a reasonable excuse. The appeal normally has to be made within 30 days of the date the penalty was issued, though HMRC may accept a late appeal where the delay was minimal or a reasonable excuse also stopped the appeal being lodged sooner.14GOV.UK. Disagree With a Tax Decision or Penalty
HMRC’s published examples of what may count as a reasonable excuse include:15GOV.UK. Disagree With a Tax Decision or Penalty: Reasonable Excuses
- Serious or life-threatening illness, or an unexpected hospital stay that prevented you dealing with the filing.
- The death of a partner or close relative shortly before the deadline.
- A computer or software failure while preparing the return, or problems with HMRC’s own online service.
- A fire, flood, or theft that destroyed the records you needed.
- Unpredictable postal delays.
What does not qualify: finding HMRC’s online system difficult, not receiving a reminder, lack of funds, or simply making a mistake on the return. Relying on someone else who then failed to file is listed as a potential excuse, but HMRC scrutinises those claims closely, and you have to show you took reasonable care choosing and monitoring the person. Once the excuse no longer applies, file the return without further delay.
Overseas Employers With UK Staff
Overseas companies that provide securities to UK-based employees have the same reporting obligation as UK employers. Any entity operating an employee share scheme under which UK employees receive awards has to file an end-of-year ERS return.6GOV.UK. Employment Related Securities Bulletin 64 There is a carve-out for short-term business visitors covered by an EP Appendix 4 arrangement where no UK income tax or National Insurance would be due, but if the visitor was UK resident when the options were granted, or UK tax is due for any other reason, the reporting obligation remains.
A non-UK company that does not run a UK PAYE scheme cannot access the ERS online service in the usual way. In those limited circumstances HMRC allows paper submission, but the company has to contact HMRC directly to request the form and a postal address. Start that conversation well before 6 July. Postal filing takes longer, and a delay caused by unfamiliarity with the UK system is unlikely to qualify as a reasonable excuse.