Hennion & Walsh: FINRA Sanctions, Arbitrations & Expungements

Complaints against Hennion & Walsh fall into three groups: formal FINRA and NASD sanctions against the firm for supervisory failures and unsuitable sales, customer arbitrations against individual brokers at the firm, and public criticism of the firm’s aggressive use of FINRA’s expungement process to remove complaint records from brokers’ public histories. The firm’s BrokerCheck profile lists 18 total disclosures.

Who Hennion & Walsh Is

Hennion & Walsh, Inc. is a New Jersey broker-dealer founded by Richard Hennion and William Walsh. It registered with the SEC in December 1989 and began operating in 1990, with headquarters in Parsippany. The firm specializes in municipal bonds and sponsors the SmartTrust® line of unit investment trusts. A separate entity, Hennion & Walsh Asset Management, Inc., has been registered with the SEC as an investment adviser since May 2003. Both entities are owned equally by the two founders. Walsh is president of the broker-dealer; Richard Hennion is executive vice president.

FINRA and NASD Sanctions Against the Firm

The regulatory file shows a recurring pattern of supervisory and sales-practice problems.

2004–2005: Unsuitable Trading and Supervisory Failures

Following a routine NASD examination of the firm’s activities from January 2000 through March 2001, a hearing panel found that Richard Hennion had made unsuitable recommendations to a customer, concentrated her account in speculative biotechnology stocks, and exercised discretion without written authorization. The account had an annualized turnover ratio of 6.22 and a cost-equity rate above 19 percent. Walsh was found to have failed to supervise Hennion despite knowing about the unauthorized discretionary trading and warning signs such as a margin balance that reached $178,000.

In February 2005, Hennion was suspended for four months and fined $35,000; Walsh was suspended from supervisory duties for four months and fined $25,000. Both men and the firm were held jointly liable for an additional $40,000 in disgorgement, and both were required to requalify by examination.

A second NASD action in July 2005 cited the firm for failing to establish supervisory systems for mutual fund switches and fixed-income sales. The firm was fined $35,000 and barred from closed-end mutual fund underwriting for 30 days. Hennion and Walsh each took additional fines of $15,000. In 2006, Illinois required Hennion to withdraw his salesperson registration for two years.

2011: Municipal Bond Pricing

In November 2011, the firm was found to have violated MSRB rules by buying and selling municipal securities at prices that were not fair and reasonable. It was censured, fined $25,000, and ordered to pay $8,980.29 in restitution plus interest.

2017: Municipal Bond Sales Below Minimum Denominations

In August 2017, FINRA sanctioned the firm for executing 65 municipal bond transactions below minimum denominations between December 2013 and March 2015. The firm failed to disclose this to customers in all but two of those trades and also sold bonds restricted to qualified institutional buyers to retail investors who didn’t qualify. FINRA cited violations of MSRB rules covering confirmations, fair dealing, suitability, supervision, and time-of-trade disclosure. The firm agreed to pay $55,000 without admitting or denying the findings.

2019: Unsuitable SmartTrust UIT Switching

The largest regulatory penalty came in January 2019. FINRA ordered the firm to pay $165,000 in fines and $305,438.83 in restitution to customers after finding that it had failed to supervise brokers who recommended unsuitable series-to-series switches of the firm’s proprietary SmartTrust® UITs. Between December 2011 and December 2016, 29 brokers recommended 645 early exchanges across 438 customer accounts, moving clients from one series of a UIT into a substantially similar successor series and generating fresh sales charges of up to 3.95 percent each time, with no meaningful change in investment strategy.

FINRA found that the principal responsible for daily trade review had no training on evaluating series-to-series exchanges and did not account for the added costs, and that the firm failed to enforce its own written procedures requiring switch disclosure forms. The firm accepted the sanctions through a letter of acceptance, waiver, and consent without admitting or denying the findings.

Customer Arbitrations

Several individual investors have pursued claims through FINRA arbitration against the firm and its brokers.

Claims Against William Hennion

William Hennion, a vice president at the firm and the son of Richard Hennion, has three customer disputes on his BrokerCheck record. In FINRA Case No. 15-02021, a customer alleged negligence, breach of fiduciary duty, and unsuitable transactions in municipal debt; the panel awarded $155,935.45 in compensatory damages, for which he was held jointly and severally liable, with an individual contribution of roughly $78,000. A July 2019 complaint alleging unsuitable recommendations in municipal bonds, mutual funds, and UITs between 2015 and 2018 claimed $300,000 in damages and settled in December 2020 for $260,000. A third complaint, alleging poor portfolio management and fiduciary violations, settled for $104,500. His broker statement notes that the allegations in one case were later ordered expunged.

Claims Against Richard Hennion

Richard Hennion’s record shows two customer disputes beyond his regulatory events. One arbitration alleged churning for commissions and misappropriation of a bond, with $25,000 in requested damages; the panel awarded $11,000. A second dispute alleged inappropriate trading from 1997 through 2001, with $100,000 in requested damages; it settled for $150,000.

Other Broker Complaints

In February 2021, an investor filed a complaint against advisor John Dalby alleging fraud, negligence, and breach of fiduciary duty and claiming $5 million in damages. Dalby stated in a broker comment that there were “no substantive allegations against him” and said he intended to defend himself vigorously. As of early 2022 the matter was listed as pending.

In 2016, the Soreide Law Group filed a FINRA arbitration on behalf of a retired woman in her sixties who alleged her portfolio had been concentrated in high-risk holdings including Puerto Rico bonds, a proprietary SmartTrust UIT, master limited partnerships, and high-yield gold and oil investments after she requested capital preservation and income. The claim sought $75,000 in compensatory damages for negligence, breach of fiduciary duty, and negligent supervision.

The Expungement Controversy

A separate line of criticism involves how Hennion & Walsh has used FINRA’s expungement process to clear customer complaint records from BrokerCheck, the public database investors use to check a broker’s history.

In at least four FINRA arbitration cases (Nos. 22-02288, 20-03138, 22-02294, and 22-02286), Hennion & Walsh brokers sought expungement by filing claims against their own firm for one dollar in damages. Framing the matter as a monetary dispute rather than a request for non-monetary relief qualified the brokers for a single arbitrator instead of the three-person panel normally required and avoided higher non-monetary fees. In each hearing, the one-dollar claim was dismissed and the arbitrator granted the expungement. Law professor Benjamin P. Edwards called the tactic “ethically dubious” and argued the nominal claims lacked a genuine legal basis, potentially violating professional-conduct rules against frivolous filings.

In all four cases, the firm’s in-house counsel, Jennifer Woods Burke, represented both the broker seeking expungement and Hennion & Walsh as the named respondent. Edwards argued this arrangement created a “concurrent conflict of interest” under the ABA Model Rules and called the conflict “nonconsentable” because the clients’ interests were directly adverse. No formal disciplinary action against Burke has been reported.

After obtaining the expungements, Hennion & Walsh sent cease and desist letters to law firms that had published information about past customer complaints involving its employees. The letters asserted that because the complaint records had been “ordered to be expunged” and the orders “confirmed in a court of competent jurisdiction,” continued publication was an “illegal” false statement about individuals’ character and reputation. Edwards described the effort as an attempt to “force everyone else to pretend that no complaints were ever raised.”

FINRA overhauled its expungement rules in April 2023. Expungement now requires a unanimous vote from a three-person panel of specially qualified arbitrators, and parties can no longer stipulate to a single arbitrator. Brokers must appear in person or by video, and customers must be notified of hearings. When the underlying customer arbitration was settled, the broker must file a separate proceeding instead of having the original panel decide expungement, and panels must review settlement documents for signs that customers were pressured not to oppose. FINRA is also required to notify state securities regulators of expungement requests so they can participate. Research cited by Edwards found that brokers who obtain expungements are 3.3 times as likely to engage in new misconduct as the average broker.

The SmartTrust UIT Product at the Center of the Record

SmartTrust® unit investment trusts sit at the center of the firm’s business and its largest fine. UITs are fixed portfolios of securities with set termination dates, typically two years out, and the SmartTrust line covers themes including healthcare innovation, technology, and municipal bonds. A typical SmartTrust UIT carries a maximum sales charge of 2.75 percent, split between a deferred sales charge and a creation and development fee; some older series charged up to 3.95 percent. Costs can compound when a UIT holds other funds. In the New York Municipal Portfolio trust, total estimated annual costs reached 2.13 percent. The firm’s own prospectuses warn that investors could achieve similar exposure by buying the underlying securities directly without paying the trust’s additional fees. The 2019 FINRA action targeted the practice of rolling customers from one SmartTrust series into a nearly identical successor and charging fresh sales loads each time.

Checking a Broker’s Record Yourself

Before opening or keeping an account with any brokerage, you can look up both the firm and individual brokers on FINRA’s BrokerCheck. The reports list regulatory actions, customer disputes, employment history, and in some cases broker comments responding to allegations. Keep in mind that expunged complaints no longer appear on BrokerCheck even when the underlying events happened; the public record you see is the record that survived the expungement process in effect at the time.