H5521-037 Aetna Medicare Signature: 2026 Changes and Lawsuits

Aetna Medicare contract H5521 is a Medicare Advantage PPO contract operated by Aetna Life Insurance Company, a CVS Health subsidiary, covering about 1.1 million members across 33 states. For the 2026 contract year, CMS rated it 4.5 out of 5 stars overall, the same score it earned the prior year.1Aetna. 81 Percent Members in 4 Star Plans Higher 2026

What H5521 Covers

H5521 is an umbrella contract rather than a single plan. Dozens of individual plan IDs sit beneath it, each tied to a specific benefit design and service area. All of them share the same 4.5-star summary rating from CMS, but premiums, maximum out-of-pocket limits, drug formularies, and county availability vary from one plan ID to the next.2U.S. News & World Report. Aetna Medicare Advantage Plans

The plan families under H5521 are branded as Aetna Medicare Eagle, Aetna Medicare Signature, Aetna Medicare Enhanced, Aetna Medicare Premier, and Aetna Medicare Signature Care, all structured as PPOs. Many carry $0 monthly premiums. The Aetna Medicare Eagle Giveback plans, for example, all have a $0 premium, with maximum out-of-pocket figures ranging from about $5,900 to $9,250 depending on the specific plan ID and location.2U.S. News & World Report. Aetna Medicare Advantage Plans Because the plan IDs vary so much, your actual costs and network depend on which plan ID appears on your card, not on the H5521 contract number alone.

2026 Plan Name Changes

Aetna reshuffled several plan names within H5521 for 2026, and the renaming can confuse returning members. The former Aetna Medicare Premier (PPO) became Aetna Medicare Signature (PPO). The former Aetna Medicare Discover Value (PPO) was renamed Aetna Medicare Premier (PPO). In some areas, the previous Aetna Medicare Premier (PPO) became Aetna Medicare Enhanced (PPO).3In Good Health. What’s New for Medicare in 2026

The H5521 contract number stayed put, but plan IDs and brand names shifted. If you got a notice about a name change, read the benefit summary carefully. A rebrand does not guarantee that cost-sharing, drug coverage, or the provider network are unchanged.

What the 4.5-Star Rating Means

CMS rates Medicare Advantage contracts on a one-to-five scale, scoring categories such as plan quality, drug plan quality, customer service, and member experience. Within H5521’s 4.5-star summary for 2026, customer service earned five stars across multiple plan IDs, while member experience and drug cost accuracy each came in at four stars.4Q1Medicare. Aetna Medicare Signature Care PPO H5521-500 Benefits The prescription drug plan quality summary for at least one plan variant rose to five stars for 2026, up from 4.5 the prior year.5Q1Medicare. Aetna Medicare Eagle PPO H5521-378 Star Ratings

Ratings have real financial consequences. Plans that reach four stars or higher receive quality bonus payments from CMS, which insurers often use to fund richer benefits or lower premiums. Higher ratings also exempt a plan from certain CMS restrictions that apply to lower-rated contracts. Aetna reported that more than 81 percent of its Medicare Advantage members were enrolled in plans rated four stars or higher for 2026.6CVS Health. Aetna Achieves Over 81% of Medicare Advantage Members in 4 Star Plans

Federal Enforcement Involving Aetna

The H5521 contract itself carries strong ratings, but Aetna and its parent CVS Health have faced recent federal action tied to the broader Medicare Advantage business. Neither matter has produced a finding of liability against Aetna.

$117.7 Million False Claims Act Settlement

In March 2026, Aetna Inc. agreed to pay $117.7 million to resolve allegations that it submitted inaccurate diagnosis codes to CMS and received inflated risk-adjustment payments as a result.7U.S. Department of Justice. Aetna Agrees to Pay $117.7 Million to Resolve False Claims Act Allegations The settlement covered two sets of claims. The first, $11.5 million, resolved whistleblower allegations that for payment years 2018 through 2023, Aetna submitted or failed to delete morbid obesity diagnosis codes when recorded body mass index data did not support them.8U.S. Department of Justice. Aetna Agrees to Pay $117.7 Million to Resolve Allegations It Violated False Claims Act

The larger piece, $106.2 million, concerned the 2015 payment year. The government alleged that Aetna’s “chart review” audits turned up additional codes it submitted for higher payments, while the same reviews produced results showing previously submitted codes were unsupported, which Aetna did not withdraw.8U.S. Department of Justice. Aetna Agrees to Pay $117.7 Million to Resolve Allegations It Violated False Claims Act The settlement was not an admission of liability, and the agreement states that the claims are allegations only.7U.S. Department of Justice. Aetna Agrees to Pay $117.7 Million to Resolve False Claims Act Allegations

Pending Marketing and Kickback Lawsuit

The Department of Justice has also sued Aetna along with Elevance Health, Humana, and brokers eHealth, GoHealth, and SelectQuote, alleging that between 2016 and 2021 the insurers paid brokers hundreds of millions of dollars in kickbacks to steer beneficiaries toward their plans regardless of suitability. The complaint alleges that Humana and Aetna structured broker payments in ways that discouraged enrollment of beneficiaries with disabilities.9Becker’s Payer Issues. Judge Rules Aetna Elevance Humana Must Face Medicare Kickback Allegations

In March 2026, U.S. District Judge Denise J. Casper in Massachusetts largely denied the defendants’ motion to dismiss, allowing the kickback and discrimination claims to move forward. The judge dismissed an unjust enrichment claim, finding that the False Claims Act provided a sufficient path for the government to recover money.10Law360. Insurers, Brokers Can’t Exit Medicare Advantage Steering Suit The case began as a 2021 whistleblower complaint, and the DOJ intervened in 2025.9Becker’s Payer Issues. Judge Rules Aetna Elevance Humana Must Face Medicare Kickback Allegations