GASB Statement No. 68: Net Pension Liability and Disclosures

GASB Statement No. 68 requires state and local governments to report the full net pension liability for their defined benefit pension plans directly on the balance sheet, rather than disclosing only the annual required contribution in footnotes. Issued by the Governmental Accounting Standards Board and effective for fiscal years beginning after June 15, 2014, the standard sets a single measurement framework so that pension obligations can be compared consistently across jurisdictions.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68 For anyone reading a city, county, school district, or state financial statement, it is the reason the pension number is now large, prominent, and impossible to ignore.

Which Governments and Plans Are In Scope

GASB 68 applies to state and local governmental employers that provide defined benefit pensions through a qualifying trust. The trust must meet three conditions: contributions and investment earnings are irrevocable, plan assets are dedicated solely to paying member pensions, and those assets are legally protected from creditors of the employer and the plan administrator.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68 State governments, counties, cities, public school districts, and public universities all fall within scope when they issue financial statements under the GASB framework.

How an employer reports depends on which of three plan structures it participates in:

  • Single-employer plans, where one employer maintains its own plan and trust and reports the full net pension liability directly.
  • Agent multiple-employer plans, where employers pool assets for investment but each has a separate account and its own actuarial valuation, so each reports its own specific liability.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68
  • Cost-sharing multiple-employer plans, where all participating employers share one pooled obligation and any plan assets can pay benefits for any participant’s employees. Each employer reports a proportionate share of the collective liability rather than a separately calculated amount.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68

Cost-sharing is the most common structure for statewide retirement systems, and it carries reporting rules unique to that arrangement.

How the Net Pension Liability Is Calculated

The net pension liability is the number GASB 68 puts on the balance sheet. It equals the total pension liability minus the pension plan’s fiduciary net position.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68 In plain terms, take the present value of all future benefits employees have already earned through their service, then subtract the current fair value of the plan’s investment assets. The gap is what the employer reports as a long-term liability.

The total pension liability is the harder side of that subtraction. It captures benefits owed to current retirees already collecting checks, former employees who earned benefits but haven’t retired yet, and active employees for the portion of their careers completed so far. Getting it right depends on the cost method GASB 68 mandates and the assumptions the plan’s actuary selects.

The Entry Age Normal Method

GASB 68 permits only one actuarial cost method: entry age normal.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68 The method calculates, for each individual employee, a level percentage of pay that if contributed from hire date through expected retirement would fund the employee’s full projected benefit. Mandating one method was a deliberate choice. Under the prior framework, employers could pick from several acceptable methods, and two otherwise identical governments could report very different liabilities.

The Discount Rate

No assumption moves the reported liability more than the discount rate. A higher rate shrinks the present value of future payments; a lower rate inflates it. GASB 68 requires a single rate that may blend two components: the long-term expected rate of return on plan investments and a tax-exempt, high-quality municipal bond rate.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68

The plan projects future benefit payments and future asset balances year by year. Payments in years where assets are projected to be sufficient are discounted at the expected investment return. Payments in any year where assets are projected to be exhausted are discounted at the municipal bond rate. The two pieces combine into a single blended rate.

Most well-funded plans never reach a projected depletion point, so their discount rate equals the full expected investment return, typically in the 6.5% to 7.5% range. The municipal bond rate is considerably lower, often 3.0% to 4.5%. When a plan is severely underfunded and assets are projected to run out, the blended rate drops and the reported liability jumps. The mechanism is intentionally conservative: underfunding makes the balance-sheet liability grow faster as plan health deteriorates.

Other Assumptions

Beyond the discount rate, the total pension liability depends on economic and demographic assumptions the plan’s actuary selects. Assumed inflation is the baseline for projecting benefits and salary growth. Salary increase assumptions add merit and promotion increases on top. Mortality tables determine how long retirees are expected to collect, and turnover and retirement-timing assumptions affect when payments begin.

GASB 68 does not set these assumptions itself. It requires plans to select assumptions that reflect their covered population and to disclose them. Actuarial experience studies, typically performed every five to ten years, support or revise the selections. When any assumption changes, the resulting shift flows through the financial statements over time via the deferred flows described below.

Measurement Date vs. Reporting Date

GASB 68 draws a distinction that trips up first-time readers. The measurement date is when the net pension liability is actually calculated. The reporting date is the end of the employer’s fiscal year, when financial statements are issued. The measurement date must be no earlier than the end of the employer’s prior fiscal year.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68

For a government with a June 30 fiscal year, the measurement date can be June 30 of the current year or June 30 of the prior year. Many employers use the prior-year measurement date because the plan’s actuarial valuation takes time to complete. When the measurement date falls before the reporting date, the employer separately accounts for contributions, benefit payments, and investment activity in the gap between those dates.

Actuarial valuations of the total pension liability must be performed at least every two years, though annual valuations are encouraged. If no valuation exists as of the measurement date, the employer rolls forward the most recent valuation using update procedures, provided that valuation was performed no more than 30 months and one day before the employer’s most recent fiscal year-end.2GASB. GASB Statement No. 68 – Accounting and Financial Reporting for Pensions If significant changes occur between the valuation date and the measurement date, professional judgment governs whether a full new valuation is required instead of a mechanical roll-forward.

Pension Expense and Deferred Flows

Annual pension expense under GASB 68 is not simply the year-over-year change in the net pension liability. Expense is built from distinct components, some recognized immediately and others spread over future periods. The immediate components include service cost (the present value of benefits newly earned during the year), interest on the total pension liability, projected earnings on plan investments, and the effect of any benefit term changes.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68

The deferred components smooth out volatility. Two categories of changes get spread over future years rather than hitting the income statement all at once:

  • Differences between expected and actual experience, and changes in actuarial assumptions, are amortized over the average expected remaining service lives of all employees in the plan.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68
  • Differences between projected and actual investment earnings are amortized over a fixed five-year period.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68

The five-year period for investment variances is shorter than the service-life period for demographic and assumption changes. Investment returns swing widely year to year but tend to normalize faster than long-term demographic trends, so a bad market year is spread over five years rather than concentrated into one.

Deferred Outflows and Deferred Inflows

The portions of these changes not yet recognized in expense sit on the balance sheet as deferred outflows of resources or deferred inflows of resources. Deferred outflows are future costs waiting to be recognized. Deferred inflows are future reductions to pension expense.

One deferred outflow deserves special attention: employer contributions made after the measurement date but before the reporting date. Because the net pension liability was calculated as of the measurement date, contributions made in the gap are not yet reflected in it. They are reported as a deferred outflow and reduce pension expense in the following period.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68

On the balance sheet, deferred outflows appear after assets but before liabilities. Deferred inflows appear after liabilities but before net position. The net pension liability itself is a long-term liability and is often the single largest obligation on a governmental balance sheet.

Reporting for Cost-Sharing Employers

Cost-sharing multiple-employer plans cover a large share of public employees, especially through statewide retirement systems, and the reporting mechanics for participating employers differ from single-employer and agent plans. No employer owns a discrete slice of the obligation. Instead, each employer reports its proportionate share of the collective net pension liability.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68

GASB 68 encourages basing the proportion on each employer’s projected long-term contribution effort compared to total projected contributions of all employers. In practice, many plans use actual contributions paid as the allocation basis. An employer that contributes 2% of the system’s total contributions reports 2% of the system-wide net pension liability, along with 2% of the collective deferred outflows and inflows.

When an employer’s proportion changes from one year to the next, the effect must be recognized in pension expense over the average remaining service lives of all plan members. The same treatment applies when the employer’s actual contributions during the measurement period differ from its proportionate share of total contributions.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68 These additional deferred items are unique to cost-sharing employers and can make their pension disclosures considerably more complex than those of single-employer or agent employers.

Required Disclosures

GASB 68 requires extensive information beyond the numbers on the face of the financial statements. That information is split between notes to the financial statements and required supplementary information, and both are necessary to make sense of a government’s pension position.

Notes to the Financial Statements

The notes must describe the pension plan, including the types of benefits provided and how employer contributions are determined. All significant actuarial assumptions used to calculate the total pension liability must be disclosed: the inflation rate, salary growth, mortality tables and dates of experience studies, and a full explanation of how the discount rate was determined, including the inputs and the projection of asset sufficiency.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68 The date of the actuarial valuation and the measurement date must also be stated.

One of the most useful required disclosures is the discount rate sensitivity analysis. The employer must present the net pension liability at three rates: the rate actually used, a rate one percentage point lower, and a rate one percentage point higher.3GASB. Post-Implementation Review Report – GASB Statements No. 67 and 68 A plan whose liability jumps sharply with a one-point rate decrease is more exposed to market risk than one where the change is modest.

The notes must also detail the amounts and sources of all deferred outflows and inflows, breaking them into categories such as experience differences, assumption changes, and investment variances, and stating the period over which each component will be amortized into pension expense.

Required Supplementary Information

The RSI section provides historical trend data showing whether the pension situation is improving or deteriorating. GASB 68 requires these schedules to present data for the 10 most recent fiscal years.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68 For single and agent employers, the RSI includes schedules of the sources of changes in the net pension liability, the components of the liability and related ratios such as funded percentage, and the net pension liability as a percentage of covered payroll.

If employer contributions are actuarially determined, a schedule of contributions must compare what the actuary recommended to what the employer actually paid. For cost-sharing employers, the RSI includes 10-year schedules showing the employer’s proportionate share of the net pension liability and related ratios, along with contribution information if applicable.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68 The contribution schedule is where the separation between funding and accounting is most visible. A government can fully comply with GASB 68 while consistently underfunding its actuarially determined contribution, and the RSI schedule will reveal that pattern.

How GASB 68 Relates to GASB 67, 71, and 82

GASB 68 does not stand alone. GASB Statement No. 67 was issued alongside it and shares the same measurement framework, but it governs financial reporting by the pension plan itself, while GASB 68 governs reporting by the employer that participates in the plan.4GASB. Summary – Statement No. 67 GASB 67 sets the rules for the retirement system’s own financial statements; GASB 68 sets the rules for every city, county, and school district paying into it.

A design choice worth understanding runs through both standards: funding and accounting are separate. Before GASB 68, annual pension cost for accounting was tied directly to the actuarially determined contribution for funding. GASB 68 breaks that link.1GASB. Summary – Statement No. 68 Pension expense on the income statement reports the economic cost of pensions earned this year. The actuarially determined contribution disclosed in supplementary schedules reflects what the plan’s actuary recommends the employer pay to keep the plan healthy over time. The two numbers rarely match, and they are not supposed to.

GASB Statement No. 71 addressed a transition problem. When governments first implemented GASB 68, many did not have all the historical deferred flow data the standard contemplates. GASB 71 required governments to recognize a beginning deferred outflow for pension contributions made between the measurement date and the implementation date, even where other deferred amounts could not be practically determined.5GASB. GASB Statement No. 71 – Pension Transition for Contributions Made Subsequent to the Measurement Date Without that fix, those interim contributions would have vanished from the balance sheet during transition, unfairly penalizing governments that were keeping up with funding.

GASB Statement No. 82, issued later, made targeted amendments to both GASB 67 and GASB 68, including clarifications to payroll-related measures used in the RSI schedules and the presentation of covered payroll. It did not change the core measurement framework.

GASB 68 covers defined benefit pensions provided through a qualifying trust. Other postemployment benefits such as retiree healthcare are addressed by separate GASB standards, and defined contribution plans are outside the framework described here.

What Changed on Government Balance Sheets

The most immediate effect of implementation was a sharp reduction in unrestricted net position for many governments. Before the standard, pension obligations sat largely in the footnotes. Moving them onto the balance sheet turned modestly positive net positions into deeply negative ones for governments with large unfunded pension liabilities. A negative unrestricted net position does not mean the government is insolvent. It means available resources would fall short if all long-term obligations had to be satisfied today. Because pension benefits are paid over decades, the negative position is a warning signal rather than an emergency.

For bond analysts and rating agencies, GASB 68 provides far more usable data than the old framework. The funded ratio (fiduciary net position divided by total pension liability), the trend in net pension liability over time, and the gap between actuarially determined and actual contributions all appear in standardized formats that allow direct comparison across governments. Whether a government consistently underfunds its pension obligation, or leans on optimistic investment assumptions to minimize its reported liability, is now visible in the financial statements rather than buried in actuarial reports few people read.

The standard does not tell governments how much to contribute. It tells them how to measure and report what they owe. When a plan lowers its assumed rate of return, the total pension liability jumps, pension expense rises, and the balance sheet deteriorates in view of every reader of the financial statements. That visibility is what GASB 68 was built to produce.