FRTB compliance requirements apply to banks with material trading activity and center on four duties: classify every position correctly between the trading book and the banking book, calculate market risk capital under the Standardized Approach, optionally seek desk-by-desk approval for the Internal Models Approach, and support both with the data, backtesting, documentation, and reporting the framework prescribes. The Fundamental Review of the Trading Book was developed by the Basel Committee as part of Basel III to replace a market risk framework that badly underestimated losses during the 2007–2009 crisis.1Bank for International Settlements. Basel III: International Regulatory Framework for Banks What follows is what in-scope banks have to do, and by when.
Which Banks Are In Scope
Internationally, FRTB applies to all internationally active banks, but national regulators decide which domestic institutions are covered. The scope turns on whether trading activities are large enough to pose meaningful risk, regardless of whether the bank is a Global Systemically Important Bank.2Financial Stability Board. 2025 List of Global Systemically Important Banks (G-SIBs) Many non-G-SIBs with active trading desks fall within scope.
In the United States, the March 2026 joint proposal from the OCC, Federal Reserve, and FDIC targets Category I and II banking organizations and any bank with “significant trading activity.”3Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. Regulatory Capital: Category I and II Banking Organizations, Banking Organizations With Significant Trading Activity, and Optional Adoption for Other Banking Organizations The proposal would raise the dollar-based threshold for mandatory market risk capital rules from $1 billion to $5 billion in trading assets and liabilities, index that figure to inflation, and let other banking organizations opt in voluntarily. The comment period closes June 18, 2026, so the final threshold is not yet settled.
Scope also reaches beyond traditional banks to entities that actively trade securities, derivatives, or foreign exchange at a material scale, which prevents firms from parking risky positions in lightly regulated subsidiaries.
Implementation Deadlines by Jurisdiction
Compliance dates diverge across the major jurisdictions, which forces global banks to run parallel programs.
European Union
The EU initially planned FRTB application under the Capital Requirements Regulation III from January 1, 2025. That date was postponed first to January 1, 2026, and then again to January 1, 2027 through a European Commission delegated act.4European Commission. Commission Proposes to Postpone by One Additional Year the Market Risk Prudential Requirements Under Basel III January 1, 2027 is the current anchor date most global banks are planning against.
United Kingdom
The PRA finalized its Basel 3.1 rules with a general effective date of January 1, 2027, but gave firms an extra year for the Internal Models Approach for market risk, which takes effect January 1, 2028.5Bank of England. PS1/26 – Implementation of Basel 3.1: Final Rules UK firms will run the Standardized Approach from 2027 while preparing IMA infrastructure for the following year.
United States
U.S. timing is the least certain. After pushback on the 2023 Basel III Endgame proposal, regulators re-proposed a revised package on March 19, 2026 covering market risk rules alongside G-SIB surcharge changes.3Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. Regulatory Capital: Category I and II Banking Organizations, Banking Organizations With Significant Trading Activity, and Optional Adoption for Other Banking Organizations Comments are due June 18, 2026. A final rule is unlikely before late 2026, with an effective date probably running into 2028 or beyond.
The Standardized Approach: Mandatory for Everyone
Every in-scope bank must calculate market risk capital under the Standardized Approach, even if it also uses internal models for some desks.6Bank for International Settlements. Minimum Capital Requirements for Market Risk The Standardized Approach has three components.
The Sensitivities-Based Method is the largest piece. Banks compute delta, vega, and curvature charges across seven risk classes: interest rates, credit spreads for non-securitizations, credit spreads for securitizations, credit spreads for the correlation trading portfolio, equities, commodities, and foreign exchange. Prescribed risk weights and correlation parameters set by regulators limit modeling discretion.
The Default Risk Charge captures jump-to-default risk that credit spread moves do not reflect. The DRC calculates gross exposure per position, allows netting of long and short exposures to the same obligor, groups net positions into buckets, and applies risk weights with a hedge benefit ratio that partially recognizes shorts.7Bank for International Settlements. MAR22 – Standardised Approach: Default Risk Capital Requirement Bucket-level charges are summed to produce the total.
The Residual Risk Add-On covers instruments whose exotic features slip past the first two components, such as payoffs that depend on multiple underlyings, path-dependent options, and certain correlation-dependent products. These attract a notional-based charge on top of the other calculations.
The Internal Models Approach: Optional, Desk by Desk
Banks with sufficiently sophisticated infrastructure can apply for IMA approval. Approval is granted desk by desk, not for the bank as a whole, so a bank might run internal models on its rates desk while using the Standardized Approach for commodities.8Bank for International Settlements. MAR30 – Internal Models Approach: General Provisions
The core risk measure under IMA is Expected Shortfall at a 97.5% confidence level, replacing Value-at-Risk. ES measures the average loss in the worst 2.5% of scenarios, giving a better picture of tail risk. The ES calculation must be calibrated to a historical stress period: banks identify the worst 12-month window for their current portfolio, with the observation horizon extending back to at least 2007.9Bank for International Settlements. MAR33 – Internal Models Approach: Capital Requirements Calculation Banks use a reduced set of risk factors to compute stressed ES and scale it using the ratio of full-factor to reduced-factor ES under current conditions. The reduced set must explain at least 75% of the variation in the full model.
Each risk factor is also assigned a liquidity horizon reflecting how long it would take to exit the position under stress. The framework uses five tiers: 10, 20, 40, 60, and 120 days.9Bank for International Settlements. MAR33 – Internal Models Approach: Capital Requirements Calculation Major currency pairs and large-cap equities sit at the short end; illiquid credit and small-cap equities at the long end. Longer horizons translate directly into higher capital requirements.
Risk Factor Eligibility and NMRFs
Not every risk factor a bank uses is eligible for ES-based treatment. Each must pass the Risk Factor Eligibility Test on a quarterly basis, meeting one of two criteria:10Bank for International Settlements. MAR31 – Internal Models Approach: Model Requirements
- At least 24 real price observations per year over the ES calibration period, with no 90-day stretch in the previous 12 months containing fewer than four observations; or
- At least 100 real price observations over the previous 12 months.
Only one real price observation per day counts, and the test must be monitored monthly. Factors that fail become Non-Modellable Risk Factors, are pulled out of the ES model entirely, and receive a separate stress-scenario-based capital charge that is typically much higher than the ES charge would be. Each NMRF adds a standalone requirement that cannot be diversified away within the model, so banks with exposure to exotic or thinly traded instruments find this is where IMA economics break down.
Trading Book-Banking Book Classification
FRTB tightens the boundary between the trading book and the banking book with prescriptive assignment rules. Positions are allocated at inception based on purpose and characteristics, and transferring a position between books afterward is heavily restricted.11Bank for International Settlements. Basel Framework Any approved transfer triggers a capital impact calculation, and any capital benefit from the switch is disallowed. Regulators can force a re-designation if they find a bank has misclassified positions. This duty applies whether or not the bank uses IMA.
CVA Risk: A Parallel Compliance Stream
Beyond market risk on traded positions, FRTB addresses the risk that a derivatives counterparty’s credit quality deteriorates. Credit Valuation Adjustment risk has its own framework with two approaches:12Bank for International Settlements. Credit Valuation Adjustment Framework
- The Basic Approach (BA-CVA) is the default, which all banks use unless they receive specific supervisory approval for the alternative.
- The Standardised Approach (SA-CVA) is a more risk-sensitive calculation available to banks that can demonstrate adequate CVA risk management, including the ability to compute CVA sensitivities.
Banks approved for SA-CVA can still carve out specific netting sets and calculate them under BA-CVA. The two approaches recognize different hedges for capital relief, and a hedge that reduces economic risk but does not meet the eligibility criteria provides no capital benefit.
The Output Floor
Even with IMA approval, the capital savings are capped. The Basel III output floor requires that a bank’s total risk-weighted assets under internal models cannot fall below 72.5% of the risk-weighted assets the Standardized Approach would produce.13Bank for International Settlements. Finalising Basel III – In Brief In practice, the maximum capital benefit from internal models is 27.5% compared to the standardized calculation. The floor is being phased in across jurisdictions, with full application at 72.5% as the end state.
Backtesting, P&L Attribution, and Keeping IMA Approval
Banks using internal models must continuously prove those models work. Backtesting compares a one-day 99th percentile VaR measure against actual and hypothetical P&L over 250 trading days.14Bank for International Settlements. MAR32 – Backtesting and P&L Attribution Test Requirements An “exception” occurs any day the actual or hypothetical loss exceeds the VaR prediction. Exception counts place the model in one of three zones:
- Green zone (0–4 exceptions): base multiplier of 1.50, no automatic supervisory action.
- Amber zone (5–9 exceptions): multiplier from 1.70 up to 1.92, with regulators presuming problems.
- Red zone (10 or more exceptions): multiplier of 2.00, and supervisors may revoke model approval.
Backtesting also runs at the individual desk level using both 97.5th and 99th percentile VaR measures. A desk that produces too many exceptions can lose IMA approval and be forced onto the Standardized Approach, which almost always raises its capital requirement.
The P&L Attribution Test runs alongside backtesting, comparing hypothetical P&L from the risk model against P&L from the front-office pricing models. If the two diverge too much, the risk model is missing important factors, and the desk again risks losing IMA eligibility.
Documentation and Reporting
Every trading desk must have clearly defined strategies, risk limits, and a list of instruments it is authorized to trade. Because IMA approval is evaluated desk by desk, vague or incomplete desk definitions are one of the fastest ways to lose model approval.
On data, the Risk Factor Eligibility Test requires banks to maintain and continuously monitor real price observation histories for every risk factor, and the stressed ES calibration requires historical data back to at least 2007.10Bank for International Settlements. MAR31 – Internal Models Approach: Model Requirements9Bank for International Settlements. MAR33 – Internal Models Approach: Capital Requirements Calculation Maintaining clean time series across that span, through ticker changes, corporate actions, and shifts in liquidity, is a significant infrastructure task.
Under the Basel framework, banks report Standardized Approach calculations to their supervisor monthly. In the United States, FFIEC 102 is the primary market risk reporting template, collecting risk measures, capital requirements, and trading position data.15Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council. FFIEC 102 Current Information The form will need updating once U.S. FRTB rules are finalized. Accurate completion requires tight integration between front-office trading systems, risk engines, and back-office reporting.
Supervisory Review and Penalties
Reporting submissions trigger supervisory scrutiny of controls, model governance, and reported figures through on-site exams, document requests, and virtual audits.16Bank for International Settlements. Basel Committee on Banking Supervision – International Convergence of Capital Measurement and Capital Standards – Section: Importance of Supervisory Review Backtesting failures trigger the multiplier increases above. Persistent model problems or material inaccuracies can lead to full IMA revocation, forcing affected desks onto the Standardized Approach and raising capital requirements as a de facto penalty before any formal enforcement.
In the United States, the OCC can impose civil money penalties for reporting violations and unsafe practices. For late or inaccurate regulatory reports, penalties reach up to $5,026 per day for first-tier violations, $50,265 per day for second-tier violations, and $2,513,215 per day for third-tier violations involving knowing misconduct.17Federal Register. Notification of Inflation Adjustments for Civil Money Penalties Those are per-day figures, so a prolonged reporting failure accumulates fast. The Federal Reserve and FDIC have comparable authority over their supervised institutions.