Form 1004D Completion Inspection and Certification: Triggers and Alternatives

Form 1004D, the Appraisal Update and/or Completion Report, is the document a lender uses to either confirm your property’s value hasn’t dropped since the original appraisal or verify that repairs and construction flagged in that appraisal have actually been finished. Fannie Mae calls it Form 1004D; Freddie Mac calls the same document Form 442.1Fannie Mae. Submitting Appraisal Update and/or Completion Report Which half of the form your lender needs, and why, determines whether you’re facing a quick drive-by, a return visit from the appraiser, or a brand-new appraisal.

The Two Jobs the Form Does

Part A is an appraisal update. The appraiser inspects the exterior of the property from the street, reviews recent comparable sales and market data, and reports whether value has declined since the original appraisal date. No interior inspection is required.2Fannie Mae. Appraisal Update and/or Completion Report If the appraiser finds a decline, the lender has to order a new appraisal. If not, the loan moves forward.3Fannie Mae. Appraisal Age and Use Requirements

Part B is a completion report. The appraiser verifies that specific repairs, alterations, or new construction identified in the original appraisal have been finished. This is what most borrowers mean when their lender says the property needs a “final inspection” before closing. The appraiser compares the current state of the property against the original requirements and certifies the work.4Fannie Mae. Requirements for Verifying Completion and Postponed Improvements

When an Appraisal Update Is Required

Appraisals don’t stay valid forever. Fannie Mae measures age from the effective date of the original appraisal to the date of the note and mortgage:

  • Under four months old: the appraisal is current and no update is needed.
  • Four to twelve months old: the lender must order a Part A update on Form 1004D, and the update itself has to occur within four months of the note and mortgage date.
  • Over twelve months old: the appraisal is expired regardless of whether an update was performed, and a completely new appraisal is required.

Desktop appraisals follow a tighter rule. If the original desktop appraisal is more than four months old, a new appraisal is required outright with no update option.3Fannie Mae. Appraisal Age and Use Requirements

This timing matters more than borrowers often realize. A loan that drags on for five or six months can suddenly require a Part A update that adds cost and a week or more to the timeline. If the update reveals a value decline, you’re looking at a full re-appraisal, which can change the loan terms entirely.

What Triggers a Completion Inspection

The original appraiser flags a property as “subject to” completion of repairs when deficiencies affect safety, structural soundness, or livability. Fannie Mae’s selling guide specifically names conditions like pest infestation, dampness, and abnormal settlement as triggers that require either repairs or a professional inspection before the loan can close.5Fannie Mae. Property Condition and Quality of Construction of the Improvements

Not every imperfection triggers a mandatory repair. Worn carpet, minor plumbing drips, holes in window screens, and cracked glass count as minor conditions an appraiser can note without a “subject to” designation. The line is whether the issue threatens structural integrity or safety. A cracked window pane is cosmetic; a cracked foundation is not.5Fannie Mae. Property Condition and Quality of Construction of the Improvements

Properties with severe damage receive a C6 condition rating and cannot be sold to Fannie Mae at all. Any deficiency driving a C6 rating must be repaired to reach at least C5 before the lender can deliver the loan. New construction and proposed construction also require a Part B completion report to verify the home was actually built according to the plans referenced in the original appraisal.5Fannie Mae. Property Condition and Quality of Construction of the Improvements

How the Inspection Works

For a Part B completion inspection, the appraiser schedules a visit once the homeowner or contractor confirms the required work is done. The visit focuses only on the items flagged in the original report, so it runs shorter than a full appraisal, often fifteen to thirty minutes. The appraiser walks the property, checks each “subject to” item, and takes photographs that correspond to the original requirements.

Verification doesn’t have to be on-site. Fannie Mae allows the appraiser to complete the form based on virtual inspections, digital photos, site videos, or other technology-based methods.4Fannie Mae. Requirements for Verifying Completion and Postponed Improvements That flexibility can speed things up when the work is straightforward and easily documented.

The completed form links back to the original appraisal through the property address, the original appraiser’s name and report date, and the lender’s case number. Photographs must clearly show the finished work and match the specific conditions in the original report. Discrepancies between what was required and what was done must be noted. The appraiser signs the form, and the report is submitted through an Appraisal Management Company or directly into the lender’s digital portal.

A completion inspection typically costs between $125 and $260, depending on your market. The borrower usually pays this fee at the time the inspection is requested.

Alternatives to a Formal 1004D

Not every completion verification requires a formal 1004D. Fannie Mae accepts several alternatives for straightforward repairs:2Fannie Mae. Appraisal Update and/or Completion Report

  • A letter from the original appraiser that includes the original report file number, property address, a statement confirming the work was completed as required, photographs of the finished improvements, and a signed date.
  • A signed borrower letter confirming the work was completed per the appraisal requirements, with photographs of the improvements.
  • A signed third-party inspection report from a building inspector or licensed contractor, with photos.

Each option must include photographs and a clear statement that the improvements were completed according to the original appraisal conditions. Lenders don’t all accept every alternative. Some keep stricter internal policies and insist on a formal 1004D regardless of what Fannie Mae permits.

There’s also a separate path when the lender obtains a professionally prepared report from a qualified specialist confirming a specific condition has been corrected. In that case the appraiser doesn’t need to re-inspect or provide a 1004D at all, though the lender must document its reasoning in the loan file.5Fannie Mae. Property Condition and Quality of Construction of the Improvements

Closing Before the Work Is Finished

Sometimes a lender needs to close before every last item is done, particularly with new construction when weather or material delays push minor tasks past the closing date. Fannie Mae allows this under specific conditions. The postponed items must be part of the sales contract, delayed for a legitimate reason such as bad weather or supply shortages, and must not prevent the property from getting an occupancy permit. The cost of the remaining work also cannot exceed 10% of the property’s appraised value.4Fannie Mae. Requirements for Verifying Completion and Postponed Improvements

When a lender sells the loan before postponed items are finished, it must set up a completion escrow by withholding 120% of the estimated cost of the remaining work from the purchase proceeds. If the contractor provides a guaranteed fixed-price contract, the escrow only needs to equal the full contract price. Either way, the improvements must be completed within 180 days of the note date.4Fannie Mae. Requirements for Verifying Completion and Postponed Improvements The 20% buffer exists because construction costs routinely come in higher than estimates.

FHA and VA Loans Follow Different Rules

Government-backed loans use their own completion inspection rules, and those rules are generally stricter than conventional requirements.

FHA

FHA loans add an extra layer when a property is under construction. If the home is less than 90% complete at the time of the appraisal, an FHA Fee Inspector must perform a final inspection and document the results on Form HUD-92051, certifying that the new dwelling appears to conform with the submitted construction plans.6U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Archives. HOC Reference Guide – Construction and New Homes: Final Inspection on Properties

If the home is 100% complete at the time of appraisal, the appraiser’s original report can serve as the final inspection without a separate HUD-92051, but only if several conditions are met. The appraiser must have had the full plans and specifications along with the Builder’s Certification (HUD-92541), verified general conformance with those plans, inspected for health and safety violations, and taken additional corner photographs showing grading and drainage. All utilities must be on and fully functional during inspection, or the property is not considered complete.6U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Archives. HOC Reference Guide – Construction and New Homes: Final Inspection on Properties

VA

VA appraisers can use Form 1004D Part B, Freddie Mac Form 442, or their own letterhead to certify that required repairs have been completed. Part A of Form 1004D is not acceptable for VA purposes.7U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. Circular 26-14-8 – Repair Inspection Processing Procedures

VA completion reports carry additional requirements beyond conventional loans. The report must re-list every item from the Notice of Value that needed repair, certify that quality materials were used and the work was completed in a workmanlike manner, and include photos of the finished repairs. If any repair wasn’t properly completed, the appraiser must identify the deficiency and include photos of the noncompliant items. The completed report is uploaded to the VA’s WebLGY system.7U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. Circular 26-14-8 – Repair Inspection Processing Procedures

What Happens If the Work Isn’t Done

When an appraiser arrives and the work isn’t finished, the loan stalls. The lender cannot verify completion and therefore cannot sell the loan to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac until every “subject to” condition is cleared.4Fannie Mae. Requirements for Verifying Completion and Postponed Improvements The borrower doesn’t get a clear-to-close, the closing date slips, and a second inspection trip means another fee.

This is where deals fall apart more often than you’d expect. A contractor says the work is done, the appraiser arrives to find a half-finished repair, and the closing date everyone agreed on is suddenly meaningless. The fix is simple but easy to skip: confirm with the contractor that every flagged item is genuinely finished before scheduling the inspection. “Almost done” costs another inspection fee and another week.

If repairs drag on, the original appraisal may age out of its validity window. An appraisal more than twelve months old requires a completely new report, resetting the clock and the cost. Even before that point, delays beyond four months can trigger a Part A update requirement on top of the Part B completion inspection.3Fannie Mae. Appraisal Age and Use Requirements