A forfeitable bonus is taxed as ordinary income in the year you receive it, even though a clawback provision may force you to return the money later. The IRS applies the “claim of right” doctrine: money you can spend freely is taxable now, regardless of any future repayment obligation.1Internal Revenue Service. Publication 525 – Taxable and Nontaxable Income If you later have to pay the bonus back, the tax code offers ways to recover what you paid, but the relief is uneven and depends heavily on when you repay and how much.
Why the Tax Hits Right Away
A bonus is “forfeitable” when your right to keep it depends on something that hasn’t happened yet, usually staying with the employer through a set date. Signing bonuses, retention bonuses, and relocation payments are the common examples. If you leave early, quit, get fired for cause, or breach a non-compete, the clawback clause in your employment agreement lets the company demand some or all of the money back.
None of that changes the tax treatment at payment. Under the claim of right doctrine, income you receive without restriction on how you use it is taxable that year, even if there’s a real chance you’ll return it.1Internal Revenue Service. Publication 525 – Taxable and Nontaxable Income Your employer treats the payment like any other bonus: the full pre-tax amount goes on your W-2 as wages, and withholding comes off the top.
How the Bonus Is Withheld
Bonuses are supplemental wages. Your employer will typically withhold federal income tax at a flat 22%, or 37% on any portion that pushes your total supplemental wages for the year above $1 million.2Internal Revenue Service. Publication 15 – Employer’s Tax Guide Social Security and Medicare tax also come out of the gross figure.3eCFR. 26 CFR 31.3402(g)-1 – Supplemental Wage Payments The number that hits your bank account is substantially smaller than the number on the offer letter, and that gap becomes a problem the moment a clawback is triggered.
You Usually Owe Back the Gross, Not the Net
Most employment agreements require repayment of the gross bonus, not the smaller net amount you actually received. On a $30,000 bonus, that can mean writing a check for the full $30,000 even though only about $21,000 landed in your account. The employer’s position is that it sent the withheld portion to the IRS on your behalf, so from its side, you received the full amount.
You’ll be out of pocket for the difference between gross and net until you recover the overpaid taxes. How fast that happens depends entirely on the calendar.
Repaying in the Same Calendar Year
Same-year repayment is the clean path. Your employer adjusts your year-end W-2 to remove the repaid amount from wages, along with the associated federal income tax and FICA withholding, as if the bonus had never been paid. You don’t claim any special deduction, because the income never gets reported.
If the repayment lands so late in the year that there isn’t enough remaining payroll to absorb the withholding reversal, the employer should refund the excess income tax and FICA withholding directly to you before December 31 so the W-2 comes out clean. If you know a clawback is coming and you can influence the timing, closing everything out before year-end avoids the more painful process that applies to later-year repayments.
Repaying in a Later Tax Year
Once the calendar year closes, you’ve already filed a return reporting that bonus as income and paid tax on it. You can’t amend the original return to unwind it, because at the time you filed, the income was correctly reported under the claim of right doctrine. Relief for later-year repayments runs through Internal Revenue Code Section 1341, but only when the amount you repay exceeds $3,000.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1341 – Computation of Tax Where Taxpayer Restores Substantial Amount Held Under Claim of Right
Repayments Over $3,000
Section 1341 gives you two ways to figure your tax for the repayment year. Compute both and use whichever produces the lower bill.1Internal Revenue Service. Publication 525 – Taxable and Nontaxable Income
The first method is a deduction. You claim the repaid amount as an itemized deduction on Schedule A, line 16, as an “other itemized deduction.” It is not a miscellaneous itemized deduction, so it survives the current-law elimination of that category. The tradeoff: you have to itemize. If the standard deduction still beats your total itemized deductions with the repayment added in, this method is worthless to you.
The second method is a credit. You refigure your original-year tax as if you had never received the bonus. The difference between what you actually paid that year and what you would have paid becomes a credit against your current-year tax. If the credit is larger than your current-year tax, the excess is treated as an overpayment and refunded.
An example: you received a $40,000 bonus in 2024 and repaid it in 2026. Figure your 2026 tax first without any deduction for the repayment. Then recompute your 2024 tax pretending the $40,000 was never included in income. The reduction in your 2024 tax is your credit; subtract it from your 2026 tax to get your final liability.1Internal Revenue Service. Publication 525 – Taxable and Nontaxable Income
The credit method usually wins when you were in a higher bracket the year you received the bonus than the year you repay it, because you get back tax at the higher rate. It’s worth running both calculations rather than assuming.
Repayments of $3,000 or Less
Below the $3,000 threshold, Section 1341 does not apply.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1341 – Computation of Tax Where Taxpayer Restores Substantial Amount Held Under Claim of Right These repayments used to be claimable as miscellaneous itemized deductions, but the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act eliminated those in 2018 and the One Big Beautiful Bill Act of 2025 made that permanent.1Internal Revenue Service. Publication 525 – Taxable and Nontaxable Income If you repay $3,000 or less in a later year, you get no federal income tax relief at all. You paid tax on money you had to return, and there is no remedy.
The threshold looks at the total you repay on that year’s return, not each installment. Two $2,000 repayments in the same year combine to $4,000 and qualify for Section 1341.
Getting the Social Security and Medicare Tax Back
Section 1341 only touches income tax. The Social Security and Medicare tax withheld from the original bonus has to be recovered separately.
The normal route is through your employer. After a clawback, the employer can file a corrected payroll tax return on Form 941-X to recover the FICA it overpaid, then refund your employee share.5Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 843 This is the cleanest option, but it requires the employer to cooperate.
If they won’t, you can file Form 843 yourself to claim the refund directly from the IRS. The form’s instructions permit an employee-filed claim only when the employer refuses to make the adjustment.5Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 843 Keep the paper trail: the employer’s clawback demand, proof of payment, canceled checks, bank statements. The IRS will want to verify the repayment before releasing anything.
What Happens to 401(k) Contributions
If a portion of the original bonus was deferred into your 401(k), the clawback creates complications the regulations don’t cleanly address. Once contributions are in the plan, there’s no established way to pull them back out simply because the underlying wages were forfeited. Employer matching is a little more workable: on a same-year repayment, the employer can reduce your gross earnings and forfeit the excess match, applying it against future matches for other participants.
Some plans define eligible compensation to exclude certain incentive payments, which sidesteps the problem entirely. If a clawback is on your horizon and contributions came out of the bonus, ask the plan administrator how your plan document defines compensation. This is a good moment to bring in a tax professional.
Whether the Clawback Is Even Enforceable
All of the relief above assumes the clawback is valid and you actually pay it. That isn’t automatic. Courts require the employment agreement to spell out the repayment amount and the specific triggering events in clear terms; vague forfeiture clauses have been struck down. A growing number of states have enacted “stay-or-pay” laws restricting employer clawbacks tied to signing bonuses, retention pay, relocation, and training costs, and state wage laws often bar employers from taking repayments out of your paycheck without written consent. As of 2026, roughly half a dozen states have some form of restriction, with more considering similar bills. What’s enforceable in one state may be void in another, and courts have treated demands based on fraud or non-compete breaches more favorably than demands based purely on an early departure. Before you write the check, get the clause reviewed under the law of the state where you work.