Filling Out the American Equity Annuity Surrender Form: Taxes and Alternatives

To cash out an American Equity annuity, you submit the company’s written surrender request form. You can download the American Equity annuity surrender form from the service forms page at american-equity.com/forms, request it inside the policyholder portal at myportal.american-equity.com, or call customer service at (888) 221-1234, Monday through Friday, 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. CST, to have it mailed or emailed to you.1American Equity. Contact Us Before you sign it, know that surrender charges, a possible market value adjustment, and federal and state taxes will all come out of what you receive.

What to Have in Front of You

Pull these together before you open the form. Missing any one of them is the fastest route to a delay or an outright rejection.

  • Your contract or policy number, taken from your most recent annuity statement.
  • Your Social Security number or Taxpayer Identification Number. American Equity reports every distribution to the IRS, so this has to match their records.
  • Your current residential address and phone number. If you have moved since you bought the contract, update the address with American Equity before or alongside the surrender request; a mismatch can flag the file for fraud review.
  • Banking details if you want Electronic Funds Transfer: your bank’s routing number, your account number, and usually a voided check.
  • If the contract has a joint owner, that person’s full legal name, Social Security number, and signature.

Every name on the form must appear exactly as it does on the original contract. A middle initial on one and a full middle name on the other is a common snag that sends the paperwork back to you.

Owner Information

The top of the form verifies that you have authority over the contract. Enter your full legal name, Social Security number, contract number, current address, and daytime phone number. A joint owner fills in the same fields in a separate section. Check every digit of your contract number and SSN against your most recent statement. Transposed numbers are the single most common data-entry error on these forms, and they will delay processing.

How You Want to Be Paid

The form asks you to choose between a paper check mailed to your address of record and an Electronic Funds Transfer deposited directly into your bank account. EFT is faster, with funds arriving within a few business days of processing, but you have to provide a routing number, account number, and usually a voided check so American Equity can confirm the account. A mailed check adds transit time on top of the processing window.

Tax Withholding Elections

Federal law requires American Equity to withhold income tax from the taxable portion of your payout unless you specifically elect otherwise. If you leave the withholding section blank, the default is 10 percent on nonperiodic distributions.2Internal Revenue Service. Pensions and Annuity Withholding You can request a higher rate if you expect a large tax bill, or opt out of withholding altogether. Opting out does not eliminate the tax; it only delays when you pay it.

There is a separate state tax withholding election. Some states require mandatory withholding on annuity distributions regardless of your preference; others let you choose. If your state mandates withholding, the form will say so and you will not be able to opt out.

What a Full Surrender Will Cost You

American Equity annuities carry a surrender charge schedule that declines over time, with a surrender period that typically runs seven to ten years depending on the product.3American Equity. American Equity IncomeShield Fixed Index Annuity Surrendering early in the contract means a larger percentage is deducted. The exact percentages vary by product and by state, so look at your original contract or disclosure documents for the schedule that applies to you.

Most American Equity products allow a penalty-free withdrawal of up to 10 percent of your contract value each year, typically beginning in the second contract year.4American Equity. American Equity GuaranteeShield Fixed Annuity A full surrender cashes out the entire balance, so the surrender charge applies to everything above that penalty-free allowance.

Some American Equity contracts also include a Market Value Adjustment. An MVA shifts your surrender value based on how interest rates have moved since you purchased the annuity: if rates have risen, the MVA reduces your payout; if rates have fallen, it increases it. Whether your contract has an MVA depends on the product, so check your disclosure pages.

A full surrender also eliminates any optional riders on the contract. A lifetime income benefit rider, an enhanced death benefit, an unvested premium bonus — all of it is forfeited when you cash out. The benefit base used to calculate guaranteed income is a hypothetical figure, not a lump sum you can collect; what you actually receive is the account value minus charges.

What You Will Owe in Taxes

Surrendering an annuity is a taxable event, and how much you owe depends on whether the contract is qualified (funded with pre-tax dollars, like a traditional IRA rollover) or nonqualified (purchased with after-tax money).

For a nonqualified annuity, the IRS taxes withdrawals on an earnings-first basis. Your gains come out before your original investment does, so the early dollars you receive are fully taxable as ordinary income. You reach the tax-free return of principal only after all accumulated earnings have been distributed.5Internal Revenue Service. Publication 575 (2025), Pension and Annuity Income For a qualified annuity, the entire distribution is generally taxable because the original contributions were never taxed.

If you are younger than 59½, the IRS adds a 10 percent additional tax on the taxable portion of the surrender, on top of ordinary income tax. Exceptions exist for distributions made after the contract holder’s death, due to disability, or as part of a series of substantially equal periodic payments over your life expectancy.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 72 – Annuities; Certain Proceeds of Endowment and Life Insurance Contracts Between surrender charges, state and federal income tax, and the early withdrawal penalty, a policyholder who surrenders in the first few contract years can lose a substantial share of the account value.

Signatures and Verification

American Equity requires the owner’s signature, plus the joint owner’s signature if there is one. Standard practice in the annuity industry calls for notarization on surrender requests, and higher-value surrenders may require a Medallion Signature Guarantee from a bank, credit union, or brokerage firm instead of or in addition to notarization. The Medallion Signature Guarantee is a stronger form of identity verification used for large financial transactions. Your form or the accompanying instructions will specify which level applies to your payout amount. If you are not sure, call American Equity at (888) 221-1234 before submitting; sending a form with the wrong signature verification is one of the most common reasons for rejection.1American Equity. Contact Us

Where to Send It

Mail the completed surrender form to American Equity’s Des Moines office:1American Equity. Contact Us

American Equity Investment Life Insurance Company
1150 Locust Street, Suite 101
Des Moines, IA 50309

You can also fax the form to (515) 226-3129.1American Equity. Contact Us Some signature guarantees and notarized documents may still need to follow by mail even if you fax; confirm with customer service whether your faxed submission is sufficient or whether originals are required. The policyholder portal at myportal.american-equity.com may also accept document uploads for certain service requests. Keep a copy of everything you send, including fax confirmations or courier tracking numbers.

After You Submit

American Equity reviews the form for completeness, verifies signatures, calculates applicable surrender charges and any market value adjustment, and runs compliance checks. If anything is missing or wrong — a joint owner signature, a withholding box, a name that does not match the contract — they will contact you by mail or through the portal, and the processing clock restarts when you return the corrected paperwork.

Once the file clears, funds go out through the method you chose. EFT arrives faster than a mailed check. American Equity sends a final statement showing the total payout, charges deducted, taxes withheld, and the formal termination of the contract. Save it. You will need it at tax time, and American Equity will also send a 1099-R to you and the IRS reporting the distribution.

Alternatives Worth Considering First

A full surrender is final and often expensive. Before you send the form, see whether one of these options does what you need with less financial damage.

Partial Withdrawal

Most American Equity products let you take up to 10 percent of the contract value each year without a surrender charge, starting in the second contract year.4American Equity. American Equity GuaranteeShield Fixed Annuity If you need some cash but not the whole balance, a partial withdrawal keeps the contract in force, preserves your riders, and avoids the surrender charge on the amount withdrawn. You still owe income tax on any earnings distributed, and the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty still applies if you are under 59½.

1035 Exchange

If what you really want is a different annuity, a 1035 exchange transfers the full value from one annuity contract to another with no income tax on the transfer. The funds have to move directly from American Equity to the new insurance company; if you take a check and hand it over yourself, the IRS treats it as a taxable distribution.7Internal Revenue Service. Rev. Rul. 2007-24 A 1035 exchange avoids the tax hit, but American Equity’s surrender charges still apply if you are inside the surrender period. The receiving insurance company usually initiates the paperwork.

Waiting Out the Surrender Period

If the surrender period ends in the next year or two, waiting may save you thousands. Once it expires, you can withdraw the full balance with no surrender charge and no MVA. The contract keeps earning interest in the meantime.