Filing a Freight Claim: Deadlines, Documents, and Recovery

To file a freight claim, send the carrier a written demand that identifies the shipment, asserts the carrier is liable, and states a specific dollar amount you are owed, backed by the bill of lading, delivery receipt, invoice, and photos. Federal law puts carriers under near-strict liability for the cargo they haul, so once you show the goods left in good condition and arrived damaged, lost, or late, the burden shifts to the carrier to prove a defense applies.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 49 USC 14706 – Liability of Carriers Under Receipts and Bills of Lading The paperwork and timing matter: a technically deficient claim gives the carrier grounds to reject it outright.

What Counts as a Valid Claim

Federal regulations set a floor for what a claim document has to do. It must be a written communication that identifies the shipment, asserts the carrier’s liability for the loss or damage, and demands payment of a specific dollar amount.2eCFR. 49 CFR 370.3 – Filing of Claims Damage notations scribbled on a freight bill or delivery receipt do not count as a filed claim on their own. You need a separate written demand.

To win on that demand, you have to prove three things: the goods were in good condition when the carrier took possession, they arrived damaged, lost, or late, and you suffered a specific dollar amount in losses.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 49 USC 14706 – Liability of Carriers Under Receipts and Bills of Lading A clean bill of lading signed by the driver at pickup is your strongest proof of the first point. Damage noted on the delivery receipt before you sign is your strongest proof of the second.

Deadlines You Cannot Miss

Carriers cannot require you to file a written claim in fewer than nine months from the date the loss or damage occurs.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 49 USC 14706 – Liability of Carriers Under Receipts and Bills of Lading A bill of lading or tariff can set a longer window, never a shorter one. File quickly anyway. Evidence degrades, memories fade, and packaging gets thrown out. The nine months is a safety net, not a target.

Concealed damage has a separate, much tighter clock. Under the National Motor Freight Classification, you generally have only five business days from delivery to report concealed damage to the carrier. Miss that window and you will likely have to prove the damage did not happen after delivery, which is a far harder case. Reporting within five days preserves the presumption that the carrier caused it; you then still have the nine-month window to file the formal claim.

If a shipment is visibly damaged on arrival, note the specific damage on the delivery receipt before you sign. “Dented corner on pallet 2, crushed box on pallet 4” is far more useful than “damaged.” A delivery receipt signed without exceptions is treated as evidence that the goods arrived in good order.

Documents to Include

Every item in the claim package does specific work, and a missing piece can stall things for weeks.

  • Bill of lading. The foundational contract between shipper and carrier. It proves what was shipped, where, and in what condition at origin. A driver’s signature without exception notations works in your favor.
  • Delivery receipt with exception notations. Your primary proof that something went wrong in transit. Without those notations, the carrier can argue the damage happened after delivery.
  • Commercial invoice. Establishes the replacement cost or wholesale value of the goods and anchors the dollar amount you are claiming.
  • Photographs and video. High-resolution images of the outer container, internal packing materials, and the damaged goods themselves. Capture them as soon as you discover the problem, before anything is moved.
  • Claim form with an itemized breakdown. Many carriers provide their own form; an industry-standard form originally approved by the Interstate Commerce Commission is also widely accepted. List each damaged item with model number, quantity, unit cost, and any salvage value. The claimed amount should reflect original value minus what you can salvage.
  • Proof of freight charges. If you are also seeking a refund of shipping costs, include the freight bill or proof of payment.

For delay claims, you additionally need documentation of measurable monetary losses: missed production schedules, lost sales, penalties owed to your own customers. Vague claims about inconvenience will not hold up.

Protect the Goods and Allow Inspection

After discovering damage, keep the original packaging and damaged products exactly where they are. Do not discard packing material, move the freight, or attempt repairs until the carrier gives you written permission.3U.S. General Services Administration. Freight Damage Claims FAQs Throwing out a crushed box might feel like cleaning up, but it destroys evidence the carrier needs to evaluate the claim.

You also have a legal duty to protect damaged cargo from further loss. Perishables with a broken refrigeration seal cannot simply be left to spoil at full-value cost to the carrier. Take reasonable steps to minimize the damage, and include those costs in your claim. Appraisals, repairs, and reconditioning are recoverable mitigation expenses.3U.S. General Services Administration. Freight Damage Claims FAQs

Carriers have the right to send their own inspector. Refusing inspection is one of the fastest ways to get a claim denied.3U.S. General Services Administration. Freight Damage Claims FAQs Cooperate, but document the inspection on your own side: notes on what the inspector examines, photos of the same items.

How to Submit the Claim

Use a method that creates a verifiable delivery record. Many carriers run online portals where you upload documents and get a confirmation number right away. Where no portal exists, certified mail with return receipt is the standard fallback. Address the submission to the specific claims department listed in the carrier’s tariff or service guide, not a general customer service inbox.

Keep a complete copy of everything you send, including the claim form, every supporting document, and proof of delivery to the carrier’s office. Claims do get lost, and rebuilding a file from scratch months later is far harder than the five-minute copy job up front.

What the Carrier Owes You After You File

Once the carrier receives a valid written claim, federal regulations require written acknowledgment within 30 days, unless the carrier pays or denies the claim within that same period.4eCFR. 49 CFR 370.5 – Acknowledgment of Claims The acknowledgment should list any additional documentation the carrier needs from you. Read it carefully and respond promptly.

From there, the carrier has 120 days to pay the claim, deny it, or make a firm written settlement offer. If it cannot resolve the claim within 120 days, it must send a written status update explaining the delay and keep sending updates every 60 days until a decision is reached.5eCFR. 49 CFR 370.9 – Disposition of Claims If the updates stop, follow up in writing and cite the 120-day and 60-day requirements.

Resolution comes in three forms: full payment, a partial settlement where the carrier accepts liability but disputes value or applies a tariff cap, or a denial. In each case, the carrier must give its decision in writing with reasons.

How Much You Can Actually Recover

Payout often depends on the liability level selected when the shipment was booked, not just the real value of the goods. This is the most common source of disappointment in freight claims.

Released value is the minimum level of carrier liability and usually costs nothing extra. Under released value, the carrier’s exposure is capped at a set rate per pound per item, often as low as 60 cents per pound.6Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. Understanding Valuation and Insurance Options A 10-pound electronic component worth $2,000 would be covered at $6.00 under that rate.

Full value protection makes the carrier liable for the replacement value of lost or damaged goods. The carrier can repair the item, replace it with a similar one, or pay current market replacement cost.6Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. Understanding Valuation and Insurance Options It costs more, but for high-value freight it usually pays for itself. Items valued above $100 per pound may need to be listed separately on shipping documents to be fully covered.

Check the bill of lading before you file. If it shows released value, recovery is capped no matter how strong the evidence is.

Why Claims Get Denied

Once you prove the goods were handed over in good order and arrived damaged, the carrier can still escape liability by showing one of five recognized defenses caused the loss: a natural disaster, the shipper’s own conduct, the inherent nature of the goods, a public enemy, or action by a government authority.

Two of these come up constantly. The shipper’s conduct defense is the one carriers reach for most: poor packaging, improper loading, or mislabeling means you caused your own loss. Documentation of your packing methods and materials pushes back on that argument. The natural disaster defense requires the carrier to show an unforeseeable weather event and that no reasonable precaution could have prevented the damage; a hurricane without warning may qualify, a seasonal rainstorm probably will not. Inherent vice applies when the goods themselves are prone to deterioration in transit (certain produce, chemicals, live animals) and the carrier shows the loss came from the goods’ nature rather than mishandling. Public enemy and government authority defenses are vanishingly rare in modern commercial shipping.

If the Carrier Denies the Claim

A denial is not the end of the matter. Federal law guarantees at least two years from the date of written denial to file a lawsuit against the carrier.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 49 USC 14706 – Liability of Carriers Under Receipts and Bills of Lading The clock starts when the carrier sends written notice disallowing any part of the claim, and the notice must state the reasons. A settlement offer alone does not count as a denial unless the carrier explicitly states in writing that the remaining portion is disallowed.

Household goods shipments have their own path. Carriers of household goods must offer neutral arbitration as a condition of their federal registration.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 49 USC 14708 – Dispute Settlement Program for Household Goods Carriers For claims of $10,000 or less, if you request arbitration, the result binds both sides. For claims above $10,000, arbitration binds only if the carrier agrees. The carrier cannot charge you more than half the cost of the proceeding, the arbitrator must be independent of both parties, and the carrier cannot require you to agree to arbitration before a dispute arises.

Commercial freight claims are a different story. Arbitration may be available if the carrier’s tariff or your contract provides for it, but there is no federal mandate like the household goods rule. Smaller denied claims often go to small claims court; larger disputes head to federal court. The Carmack Amendment preempts state-law claims, so a lawsuit will be grounded in federal law regardless of venue. If the denied amount justifies the expense, bring in a transportation attorney before the two-year window gets short.