Fifth Third Bank Fraud: Fake Accounts, Auto Loans, and Reforms

Fifth Third Bank fraud enforcement over the past decade centers on three main problems: employees opening checking, savings, and credit card accounts without customer consent between 2010 and 2016; the bank force-placing unnecessary auto insurance on borrowers who already had coverage, which pushed roughly 1,000 cars into wrongful repossession; and discriminatory auto loan pricing that charged Black and Hispanic borrowers more than similarly qualified white borrowers. Federal regulators have ordered the bank to pay more than $36 million in civil penalties across these actions, plus restitution to affected consumers.

Unauthorized Accounts Opened in Customers’ Names

Between 2010 and 2016, Fifth Third ran a “cross-sell” sales program that paid employees bonuses tied to the number of new products they opened. The per-account incentive was small, as little as $0.33 for a savings account or $1.67 for a checking account, but the pressure produced accounts customers never asked for.1Fifth Third Bank. Fifth Third Fact Sheet The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau sued in March 2020.

The bank’s own count was limited: fewer than 1,100 unauthorized accounts out of more than 10 million, with less than $30,000 in improper charges that it said had already been reimbursed.1Fifth Third Bank. Fifth Third Fact Sheet Fifth Third also reported that 96 employees had been fired or resigned over the six-year period for suspicious openings or quality failures. Regulators believed the real total was higher. The CFPB flagged roughly 6,300 additional accounts during the case, and a bank consultant later identified 800 of those as potentially unauthorized.2American Banker. CFPB’s Tactics in Fifth Third Lawsuit Called ‘Pretty Aggressive’ The bank also admitted to nearly 400 instances of what regulators called abusive practices, including falsifying customer contact information and enrolling customers in overdraft protection without consent.3Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP. In Re Fifth Third Bancorp Derivative Litigation

The case settled on July 18, 2024. A stipulated final judgment required Fifth Third to pay a $15 million civil penalty, submit a redress plan to refund fees and correct adverse credit reporting for customers whose accounts were opened without consent during 2010–2016, stop setting sales goals that encourage unauthorized openings, apply clawback policies to incentive pay tied to such openings, and notify customers promptly whenever a new account is opened in their name.4Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Fifth Third Bank, National Association5Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Proposed Stipulated Final Judgment and Order Fifth Third neither admitted nor denied the allegations.

If you held an account at Fifth Third during that period and suspect something was opened in your name, the redress plan under the settlement covers fee refunds and credit-report corrections for the 2010–2016 window.

Force-Placed Auto Insurance and Wrongful Repossessions

On the same day the accounts case settled, the CFPB issued a separate consent order over Fifth Third’s auto lending. Between 2011 and 2019, the bank force-placed or maintained unnecessary, duplicative insurance on auto loans more than 37,000 times. More than half of those policies went on borrowers who already had active coverage or who had obtained insurance within a 30-day grace period.6Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Fifth Third Bank, N.A. – FPI 2024

Customers paid more than $12.7 million in fees for coverage the CFPB described as worthless because it duplicated insurance borrowers already carried.7Detroit Free Press. Fifth Third Auto Insurance Sales, Car Repo The added charges inflated monthly payments, pushed borrowers into delinquency, and led to roughly 1,000 vehicle repossessions.8Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. CFPB Takes Action Against Fifth Third for Wrongfully Triggering Auto Repossessions and Opening Fake Bank Accounts The bank then reported inaccurate information about those repossessions to credit bureaus.6Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Fifth Third Bank, N.A. – FPI 2024

Regulators also found the bank sent deceptive “right-to-cure” letters that misrepresented how long cancellation would take and misstated the amounts borrowers owed, and that it failed to notify consumers when their preauthorized electronic payments increased because of the added premiums, violating the Electronic Fund Transfer Act.6Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Fifth Third Bank, N.A. – FPI 2024

The consent order imposed a $5 million civil penalty, bringing the combined July 2024 penalties to $20 million. It required direct refunds to affected borrowers rather than credits applied to loan balances, which had been the bank’s prior practice; any refund applied to a balance now requires the borrower’s affirmative consent. Fifth Third discontinued the force-placed insurance program in January 2019 and, if it ever restarts one, must submit a compliance plan to the CFPB at least 90 days in advance.9Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Fifth Third Bank N.A. Consent Order

If you had a Fifth Third auto loan between 2011 and 2019 and were charged for insurance you did not need, or had a vehicle repossessed after your payment jumped, you can contact the bank at 1-833-644-5317 or FifthThirdCustomerRemediationInquiries24@53.com.6Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Fifth Third Bank, N.A. – FPI 2024

Discriminatory Auto Loan Pricing

In September 2015, the CFPB and the Department of Justice acted together over indirect auto lending that violated the Equal Credit Opportunity Act. From January 2010 through September 2015, Fifth Third let dealers mark up interest rates above the risk-based “buy rate” and keep the difference. The investigation found Black borrowers were charged about 35 basis points more and Hispanic borrowers about 36 basis points more than similarly creditworthy non-Hispanic white borrowers, costing a typical borrower more than $200 in extra interest over the life of the loan.10Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Consent Order, File No. 2015-CFPB-0024

The bank was ordered to pay $18 million in redress, with $5 million to $6 million credited for remediation already provided to roughly 23,000 consumers, and to cap dealer markups at 1.25 percentage points on loans of five years or less and 1 percentage point on longer loans, or adopt a non-discretionary compensation model.11U.S. Department of Justice. Justice Department and Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Reach Settlement to Resolve The same day, a separate CFPB action over deceptive marketing of “Debt Protection” credit card add-ons sold between 2007 and February 2013 required $3 million in relief to about 24,500 customers and a $500,000 civil penalty.12Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. CFPB Takes Action Against Fifth Third Bank for Auto Lending Discrimination and Illegal Credit Card Practices

The 2015 discriminatory lending order is now listed as expired, terminated, or dismissed. Executive Order 14281 in April 2025 set a policy of eliminating disparate-impact liability, and in April 2026 the CFPB issued final amendments to Regulation B stating that the Equal Credit Opportunity Act does not authorize disparate-impact claims, the legal theory on which the original action rested.13Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Fifth Third Enforcement Action

Other Lawsuits Worth Knowing

In Klopfenstein v. Fifth Third Bank, a 2013 class action, borrowers alleged the bank’s “Early Access” cash advance program advertised a 120% APR while actual rates reached as high as 3,650%. In April 2023, an Ohio federal jury found the bank breached its contract with borrowers but awarded no damages under the voluntary payment doctrine. The borrowers said they intended to appeal.14ABA Banking Journal. Ohio Federal Jury Finds Fifth Third Bank Owes No Damages for $444M Cash Advance Suit

Penalty-tracking data records a $50 million payment in 2022 to resolve a private privacy lawsuit and an $85 million U.S. Attorney’s Office penalty in 2015 for toxic securities abuses. Across all categories since 2000, Fifth Third Bancorp has roughly $266 million in recorded regulatory penalties and fines across 41 instances.15Good Jobs First. Violation Tracker – Fifth Third Bancorp

What the Bank Changed

Fifth Third says it removed account openings as a factor in employee performance ratings in 2018 and shifted to customer satisfaction and revenue measures. It added automatic email notifications when new accounts are opened and an electronic consent step that sends a PIN to the customer’s mobile phone for about 80% of branch openings. Unfunded accounts close automatically, and incentive pay is clawed back for accounts that go unused for 90 days.1Fifth Third Bank. Fifth Third Fact Sheet In its statement on the 2024 settlement, the bank described the unauthorized account issue as involving a limited number of accounts opened between 2010 and 2016, and noted it had voluntarily ended the auto collateral protection insurance program in January 2019.16Fifth Third Bank. Fifth Third Enters Into Settlement Agreement With CFPB