ASC 718 stock compensation accounting requires a company to measure share-based awards at their grant-date fair value and recognize that amount as compensation expense over the period the recipient earns the award. The standard applies to stock options, restricted stock, restricted stock units, stock appreciation rights, and similar instruments issued to employees and non-employees in exchange for goods or services. The mechanics get involved once you look at classification, vesting conditions, taxes, and modifications, but the core is that single sentence.
What ASC 718 Covers
The standard reaches every transaction where a company issues shares, options, or other equity instruments to acquire goods or services used in its own operations. Both employee and non-employee awards fall inside its scope. ASU 2018-07 eliminated the separate framework that had governed non-employee awards under ASC 505-50, so nearly all non-employee grants are now measured at the grant date on the same basis as employee grants.
Two situations sit outside ASC 718. Share-based payments used as sales incentives to customers are accounted for under ASC 606. Awards structured to provide financing to the issuer, rather than compensation for goods or services, are also excluded.
Grant Date and Fair Value Measurement
The grant date is the anchor of the whole model. It is established when four things line up at the same moment: the employer and recipient share a mutual understanding of the key terms, the company becomes contingently obligated to issue shares upon vesting, board approval has occurred where required and is not merely perfunctory, and the recipient begins to benefit from or be adversely affected by changes in the company’s stock price. For an employee grant, the grant date cannot precede the employee’s first day of employment.
Once the grant date is set, the fair value of an equity-classified award is fixed and never revisited. That is one of the sharpest lines in ASC 718. Liability-classified awards work the opposite way: they are remeasured at fair value every reporting period until settlement, and reported compensation expense fluctuates with the instrument’s value.
Equity Versus Liability Classification
Classification drives the entire downstream accounting, so the terms of each award deserve close reading. An award is classified as a liability when any of the following is true:
- The award requires, or could require, cash settlement, unless the cash contingency is both not probable and outside the employee’s control.
- A share award carries a repurchase feature that lets the employee put the shares back to the company within six months of vesting, so the employee never bears normal equity ownership risk.
- The payout is indexed to something other than the company’s own stock price and is not a standard market, performance, or service condition.
- The company must settle a fixed-dollar obligation by issuing a variable number of shares, or the obligation’s value is tied predominantly to something other than the company’s share price.
Who holds the settlement choice matters. If the employee can choose between cash and stock, the award is a liability, because the company cannot avoid a potential cash outflow. If the company holds the choice and has enough authorized shares to deliver, equity classification is appropriate.
One practical carve-out affects almost every plan. Shares withheld to cover tax withholding remain equity-classified as long as the amount withheld does not exceed the maximum statutory tax rate in the employee’s jurisdiction and the employer has a statutory obligation to withhold.
Valuing the Award
The valuation approach depends on the instrument. Restricted stock units are the simpler case. Their grant-date fair value is the observable market price of the underlying shares, adjusted for any dividends the holder will not receive during vesting.
Stock options require an option-pricing model, because their value turns on the interaction of exercise price, time, and volatility. Both the Black-Scholes-Merton closed-form model and lattice models such as binomial trees are acceptable. ASC 718 does not mandate a specific model, but whichever model is used must incorporate six inputs:
- Current stock price on the grant date.
- Exercise price the holder must pay to exercise the option.
- Expected volatility over the option’s expected term. Established public companies typically derive this from historical trading data; newer companies may blend historical and implied volatility or use a peer group.
- Expected term, the estimated time the option will remain outstanding before exercise or expiration. Historical exercise behavior is the primary basis.
- Risk-free interest rate, the yield on a zero-coupon U.S. Treasury instrument with a maturity matching the option’s expected term.
- Expected dividends over the expected term. Companies paying no dividends use zero; those with a dividend history project the annualized rate, which reduces the calculated value.
The first two inputs are directly observable. The other four require management judgment, and the assumptions behind them draw both auditor scrutiny and investor attention.
The Simplified Method for Expected Term
Estimating expected term is difficult when a company lacks exercise history, as with recent IPOs or firms that materially changed their grant structure. SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin Topic 14 provides a simplified method for “plain vanilla” options in these situations: expected term equals the midpoint of the vesting period and the contractual term. An option that vests over four years with a ten-year contractual life would have a simplified expected term of seven years.1U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 110
The SEC staff has said companies with sufficient historical exercise data should not use the shortcut. The simplified method also requires footnote disclosure, including which grants it was applied to and why more refined estimates were unavailable.2U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Codification of Staff Accounting Bulletins – Topic 14
Multiplying the per-unit fair value by the number of options granted gives the total compensation cost to be recognized over the service period.
Recognizing Expense Over the Service Period
Total grant-date fair value is recognized as compensation expense over the requisite service period, with a corresponding credit to additional paid-in capital for equity-classified awards. The service period is defined by the vesting schedule, and the pattern of recognition depends on what kind of vesting condition is attached.
Service Conditions
The most common condition is simple continued employment for a set duration. Expense is recognized over that period, with the attribution method following the vesting structure. For cliff vesting, straight-line recognition is appropriate. For graded vesting, where portions vest at different dates, the company makes a policy election: treat the entire award as one unit and recognize expense straight-line over the longest tranche, or treat each tranche as a separate award and recognize expense on an accelerated basis. The policy must be applied consistently to similar awards.
Performance Conditions
A performance condition ties vesting to an operational target unrelated to stock price, such as reaching a revenue milestone or completing a product launch. Compensation cost is recognized only when achieving the target is considered probable, using the same “likely to occur” threshold applied to contingencies under ASC 450. If the assessment changes from improbable to probable partway through the service period, the company records a cumulative catch-up adjustment so that total recognized expense reflects the revised expectation. The probability assessment is revisited each reporting period.3Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. ASC 718 – Share-Based Payment Awards: Vesting Conditions
Market Conditions
A market condition links vesting or exercisability to the company’s stock price or total shareholder return relative to a peer group. The accounting is fundamentally different. A market condition is not treated as a vesting condition under ASC 718. Instead, the probability of achieving the market target is baked directly into the grant-date fair value, typically through a Monte Carlo simulation. Because the probability is already reflected in the measured fair value, compensation cost is recognized regardless of whether the stock price target is ever hit, as long as the employee completes the requisite service.4Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Share-Based Payment Awards – Multiple Conditions for Employee Awards
This distinction trips up a lot of people. A revenue target that isn’t met can eliminate the expense entirely. A stock price target that isn’t met cannot. The option-pricing model already discounted for the possibility of failure, so the company paid for that risk upfront in the valuation.
Awards with graded vesting that include a market or performance condition must use accelerated attribution, treating each tranche separately. The straight-line policy election is available only for awards with service conditions alone.
Forfeiture Accounting
When employees leave before vesting, the company has recognized expense on shares that will never be issued. ASU 2016-09 introduced a policy election. A company can estimate forfeitures in advance and adjust expense each period, or it can recognize expense as if all awards will vest and reverse it when forfeitures actually occur.
Under the estimation approach, the company projects a forfeiture rate from historical turnover and recognizes expense only on awards expected to vest, with true-ups each period as the estimate is refreshed. Under the actual-forfeiture approach, previously recognized expense is reversed in the period the forfeiture occurs. Both methods produce the same cumulative result once all awards have either vested or been forfeited; only the timing pattern differs. The chosen policy must be applied consistently and disclosed in the footnotes.
One nuance: previously recognized expense is never reversed when a vested option simply expires unexercised. Once the employee has earned the award by completing the service period, the compensation cost stands regardless of whether the option is ultimately exercised.
Modifications, Cancellations, and Acceleration
Post-grant changes to an award’s terms, such as repricing, extending the contractual life, or accelerating vesting, are treated as modifications. The accounting follows a comparison. Measure the fair value of the modified award and the fair value of the original award immediately before the modification, both using inputs as of the modification date. Any excess of the modified value over the original value is incremental compensation cost, recognized over the remaining service period.5Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Share-Based Payment Awards – Accounting for the Effects of Modifications
The original grant-date fair value is a floor. If a modification reduces value, total compensation cost cannot drop below what it would have been under the original terms. A company repricing underwater options to a lower strike will often record additional expense; a company shortening an option’s life or adding a performance hurdle cannot reduce previously measured compensation below the original amount.
Cancellations
Cancelling an unvested award without granting a replacement triggers immediate recognition of all remaining unrecognized compensation cost on the cancellation date. The company has effectively accelerated the employee’s benefit by releasing them from the service obligation, so the full cost is reflected immediately.6Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Share-Based Payment Awards – Cancellations
When a cancellation is paired with a replacement grant, the transaction is treated as a modification rather than two separate events. Incremental cost is the excess of the replacement award’s fair value over the cancelled award’s fair value at the cancellation date, and the original award’s unrecognized cost carries into the new recognition schedule. This prevents companies from sidestepping expense recognition by cancelling underwater options and reissuing at a lower strike.
Vesting Acceleration
Accelerating vesting eliminates the remaining service requirement, which commonly happens in change-in-control transactions, layoffs, or executive separations. When a company voluntarily accelerates vesting for an employee who would otherwise have forfeited the award on departure, that is a modification from improbable to probable vesting. Incremental cost equals the full fair value of the modified award on the modification date, and recognition may be immediate if no further service is required.
Income Tax Effects
Share-based compensation creates a temporary difference between book expense and the tax deduction. The interaction between ASC 718 and ASC 740 has a real impact on the effective tax rate.
Deferred Tax Asset During Vesting
As compensation expense is recognized each period, the company simultaneously builds a deferred tax asset equal to cumulative book expense multiplied by the applicable tax rate. This deferred tax asset represents the future tax deduction expected when the award settles. The deferred tax benefit flows through the income statement in parallel with the compensation cost.
Excess Tax Benefits and Deficiencies
The actual tax deduction on exercise or vesting is based on intrinsic value at that date, which almost never matches cumulative book expense. If the stock has appreciated substantially, the deduction exceeds book expense and produces an excess tax benefit. If the stock has fallen, the deduction falls short, producing a tax deficiency.
Under the framework set by ASU 2016-09, both excess tax benefits and tax deficiencies are recognized in income tax expense in the period the deduction is determined. That creates a permanent difference and directly affects the effective tax rate. Before ASU 2016-09, excess tax benefits were routed through additional paid-in capital and never touched the income statement. The current approach is more transparent but introduces quarter-to-quarter noise in the tax line, especially for companies with large option programs and volatile stock. For cash flow reporting, the tax effects of excess benefits and deficiencies are classified as operating activities.
Impact on Earnings Per Share
Outstanding awards represent potential common shares that must be considered in diluted EPS under ASC 260. The method depends on the type of award.
Treasury Stock Method for Options
Stock options enter diluted EPS through the treasury stock method. Options are assumed exercised at the beginning of the period, and the proceeds are assumed used to repurchase shares at the average market price. Proceeds are not just the exercise price; they also include the average unrecognized compensation cost attributable to future service. Incremental dilutive shares equal shares issuable upon exercise minus shares assumed repurchased with those total proceeds.
When assumed proceeds exceed the average stock price, the options are anti-dilutive and are excluded from the diluted EPS calculation. That commonly occurs with deeply out-of-the-money options or awards with substantial remaining unrecognized cost. The calculation uses actual outstanding options that have not yet been forfeited, regardless of whether forfeitures are estimated or recognized as they occur for expense purposes.
Restricted Stock and RSUs
Unvested restricted stock and RSUs that vest based solely on continued service are generally treated as contingently issuable shares. They are included in diluted EPS if inclusion is dilutive, using a similar treasury stock approach in which assumed proceeds consist of the unrecognized compensation cost.
Private Company Simplifications
Nonpublic entities have a harder time applying ASC 718 because their shares do not trade on an active market. The standard and later updates provide several accommodations.
Intrinsic Value Election for Liability Awards
A nonpublic entity can make an entity-wide policy election to measure all liability-classified awards at intrinsic value rather than fair value. Intrinsic value is easier to compute: the difference between the current stock price and the exercise price, without an option-pricing model. Awards are still remeasured at each reporting date until settlement, and the election applies to all liability awards, not selectively. A company that initially elects fair value cannot later switch to intrinsic value; ASC 250 treats fair value as the preferable method for accounting-change purposes.7Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Intrinsic-Value Practical Expedient for Nonpublic Entities
Current Price Input Practical Expedient
ASU 2021-07 addressed one of the most expensive pain points for private companies: determining the current price of their shares when using an option-pricing model. The practical expedient lets nonpublic entities determine the current price input using a “reasonable application of a reasonable valuation method” rather than a full independent appraisal. Relevant factors include tangible and intangible asset values, present value of anticipated future cash flows, market value of comparable companies, and recent arm’s-length transactions in the company’s stock.8Financial Accounting Standards Board. FASB Accounting Standards Update 2021-07 – Compensation Stock Compensation Topic 718
A valuation performed under Treasury Regulation Section 1.409A-1(b)(5)(iv)(B), the same 409A valuation many private companies already obtain, qualifies. The valuation cannot be more than twelve months old as of the measurement date and must be updated for any material subsequent information. The expedient can be elected on a measurement-date-by-measurement-date basis but must be applied consistently to all awards with the same underlying shares and measurement date. Use of the expedient requires disclosure.
Required Financial Statement Disclosures
Footnote disclosure is extensive so that investors and analysts can evaluate the assumptions behind reported compensation expense and the dilutive impact of outstanding awards.
Companies must describe their share-based compensation plans, including vesting conditions, maximum contractual terms, shares authorized, and the valuation method used. The forfeiture accounting policy election must also be disclosed.
For stock options and similar awards, a rollforward for the most recent income statement period is required, showing beginning and ending balances along with grants, exercises, forfeitures, and expirations, each with weighted-average exercise prices. For fully vested awards and those expected to vest, aggregate intrinsic value and weighted-average remaining contractual term must also be disclosed as of the balance sheet date.
For restricted stock and other non-option awards, a parallel rollforward is required showing nonvested shares at the beginning and end of the period along with shares granted, vested, and forfeited, each with weighted-average grant-date fair values.
For option-pricing models, the specific inputs used must be disclosed: expected volatility, expected term, risk-free interest rate, and expected dividend yield. Companies must also disclose the weighted-average grant-date fair value of awards granted during the period, total intrinsic value of options exercised and shares vested, total compensation cost recognized in income, the related tax benefit, unrecognized compensation cost for unvested awards, and the weighted-average period over which that remaining cost is expected to be recognized. Cash flow disclosures include cash received from option exercises and the tax benefit realized.