FAS 91: Accounting for Nonrefundable Loan Fees and Costs

Under FAS 91, now codified as ASC 310-20, the accounting for nonrefundable loan fees and costs works on a single principle: originating a loan is not a moment that produces instant income or expense. The nonrefundable fees you collect from the borrower and the direct costs you incur to make the loan get netted together, deferred into the loan’s carrying value, and released into interest income over the loan’s life as a yield adjustment. Straight recognition at closing is not permitted for standard loans.

Getting this right depends on sorting every dollar into the correct bucket at origination, applying the interest method correctly through the loan’s life, and knowing which events cut the amortization short.

What Gets Deferred

Two categories of amounts qualify for deferral. Everything else is expensed or recognized as it hits the books.

Nonrefundable Origination Fees

These are the charges the borrower pays at or near closing and will not get back. Points on a mortgage, administrative processing fees, and application fees all belong here. They represent income received but not yet earned, so ASC 310-20 requires deferral rather than immediate recognition.1FASB. Summary of Statement No. 91

Direct Origination Costs

Direct origination costs are expenses the lender would not have incurred if a specific loan had never been made. The standard lists the qualifying activities: evaluating the borrower’s financial condition, reviewing and recording collateral and guarantees, negotiating terms, preparing and processing loan documents, and closing the transaction.2FASB. Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 91

Third-party costs are the easy piece. An appraisal fee paid to an outside firm or legal fees for document preparation tie directly to one loan and defer cleanly. Internal costs take more work. The standard allows deferral of the portion of an employee’s total compensation and payroll-related fringe benefits that corresponds to time actually spent on the qualifying activities listed above. Salary, bonuses attributable to that work, payroll taxes, and benefits all count.2FASB. Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 91

Employee-time allocation is where most implementation problems occur. Lenders need a defensible method for measuring how much of each loan officer’s day goes to deferrable activities versus non-deferrable work like soliciting new business, servicing existing loans, or sitting in training. Many institutions run time studies or activity-based costing models and apply the resulting percentages to total compensation. The method does not need to be perfect, but it does need to hold up when auditors or regulators ask.

What Never Qualifies

Indirect costs stay out of the deferral no matter how closely they relate to lending. General overhead, advertising, branch rent, training, and executive compensation are all expensed as incurred. So is compensation tied to soliciting borrowers, servicing existing loans, and idle time.

Costs on loans that never close cannot be deferred either. Weeks of underwriting on a deal that falls through go straight to expense, because there is no loan to attach them to. Legal fees spent on litigation over a commitment protect against loss rather than create a loan, so they are also expensed as incurred.3OCC. Bank Accounting Advisory Series

Netting Fees and Costs on Each Loan

Once the fees and direct costs for a loan are identified, ASC 310-20 requires them to be netted against each other. You do not defer the fee in one account and the costs in another. They combine into a single number for each loan.3OCC. Bank Accounting Advisory Series

If fees exceed direct costs, the excess is a net deferred fee, an unearned income component that reduces the loan’s carrying value. If direct costs exceed fees, the excess is a net deferred cost that adds to the carrying value. Either way, the net amount rides with the loan and cannot hit current-period income.

The standard calls for this netting loan by loan. Institutions holding large pools of similar loans, such as consumer installment loans or residential mortgages, may use averages if the result would not be materially different from a loan-level calculation.3OCC. Bank Accounting Advisory Series

Amortizing With the Interest Method

The net deferred amount is released over the loan’s life as a yield adjustment, not as a separate line of fee income or cost amortization. The required technique is the interest method, sometimes called the effective yield method. You compute a single constant interest rate that, applied to the loan’s net carrying amount each period, produces the actual economic return after accounting for the deferred fees or costs.1FASB. Summary of Statement No. 91

Each period, interest income equals that effective yield rate times the carrying amount. The difference between that number and the cash interest actually received under the stated rate is the period’s amortization of the deferred fee or cost. Because the carrying amount changes as principal is repaid, the dollar amortization shifts over time even though the effective yield rate stays constant.

Straight-line amortization is generally not permitted for standard loans, because it fails to reflect the true economic yield. Credit card fees are the notable exception, discussed further below.

Variable-Rate Loans

For adjustable-rate loans, the effective yield is calculated using the contract rate in effect at origination. When the rate resets, the lender recalculates the effective yield prospectively using the new contract rate and the remaining unamortized balance. Prior periods are not restated.4FASB. ASU 2017-08 – Receivables Nonrefundable Fees and Other Costs Subtopic 310-20

Pooled Prepayment Estimates

As a general rule, you assume contractual payments and ignore expected prepayments in the effective yield calculation. The exception applies when a lender holds a large number of similar loans and prepayments are probable with timing and amounts that can be reasonably estimated. Then the lender may build those estimates into the yield calculation for the pool.4FASB. ASU 2017-08 – Receivables Nonrefundable Fees and Other Costs Subtopic 310-20 This is common for residential mortgage portfolios with strong historical prepayment data. Individual commercial loans rarely qualify.

When Amortization Stops Early

Prepayment

When a borrower pays off a loan before maturity, the entire remaining unamortized net fee or cost is recognized immediately. There is nothing left to spread because the loan no longer exists.1FASB. Summary of Statement No. 91

Charge-Off

When a loan is charged off, any unamortized net deferred fees or costs adjust the loan’s carrying value and therefore adjust the amount of the charge-off recorded. They are not recognized separately as income or expense; they simply roll into the loss calculation as part of the loan’s cost basis.3OCC. Bank Accounting Advisory Series

Non-Accrual Status

Placing a loan on non-accrual stops interest accrual, and that includes the amortization of deferred net loan fees or costs. Regulatory guidance treats fee amortization and discount accretion as components of interest accrual, so all three cease together. The one exception is a loan that is both well-secured and in the process of collection, which may keep accruing under some regulatory frameworks.5Federal Register. Loan Workouts and Nonaccrual Policy and Regulatory Reporting of Troubled Debt Restructured Loans

Transfer to Held for Sale

The amortization framework applies to loans held for investment. Loans classified as held for sale still have origination fees and direct costs netted and deferred, but the deferred amount is not amortized. It sits as part of the loan’s cost basis until the loan is sold, then flows through the gain or loss on sale.3OCC. Bank Accounting Advisory Series

When a loan initially held for investment is later transferred to held for sale, amortization stops at the transfer date. The remaining unamortized balance carries over as part of the cost basis, and the loan is then measured at the lower of cost or fair value.3OCC. Bank Accounting Advisory Series

Modifications and Refinancings

When a loan’s terms change, the treatment of the existing deferred fees depends on whether the modification is a new loan or a continuation of the old one. ASC 310-20 sets up a two-part test. Both conditions must be met for new-loan treatment: the new terms must be at least as favorable to the lender as terms it would offer a comparable borrower, and the modifications must be more than minor.

“More than minor” has a quantitative benchmark. If the present value of cash flows under the new terms differs by at least 10 percent from the present value of remaining cash flows under the original terms, the modification is more than minor.6FASB. ASU 2022-02 – Financial Instruments Credit Losses Topic 326 Below 10 percent, the lender uses judgment based on the specific facts.

If the modification qualifies as a new loan, the lender recognizes any remaining unamortized deferred fees or costs from the original loan and starts fresh with any new fees and costs. If the modification is only a continuation, the unamortized net fees or costs carry forward as part of the net investment in the modified loan, and the effective yield is recalculated prospectively.6FASB. ASU 2022-02 – Financial Instruments Credit Losses Topic 326

Premiums and Discounts on Purchased Loans

ASC 310-20 also governs the accounting when a lender buys a loan at a price above or below face value. The premium or discount is economically the same as a deferred origination fee or cost: it adjusts the lender’s actual yield. Premiums and discounts on purchased loans are amortized over the loan’s life using the interest method, just like deferred origination fees.1FASB. Summary of Statement No. 91

One refinement applies to purchased callable debt securities held at a premium. Under ASU 2017-08, the premium is amortized to the earliest call date rather than to maturity. If the security is not called on that date, the lender resets the effective yield based on the remaining payment terms. That change eliminated the surprise losses that occurred under the old rules when a callable security was redeemed early and the lender had to write off unamortized premium all at once. Discounts on callable securities continue to be amortized to the maturity date.4FASB. ASU 2017-08 – Receivables Nonrefundable Fees and Other Costs Subtopic 310-20

Commitment Fees and Credit Card Fees

Loan Commitment Fees

Fees collected for a commitment to lend, such as a standby commitment or a construction loan commitment, follow one of three paths depending on what happens next.

  • If the commitment is exercised, the fee becomes part of the resulting loan. It is netted with direct origination costs and amortized over the loan’s life using the interest method, like any other origination fee.
  • If the commitment expires undrawn, the fee is recognized as income on the expiration date, since no loan was created to attach it to.1FASB. Summary of Statement No. 91
  • Commitment fees on revolving lines of credit and similar facilities, where the fee compensates for the general availability of credit rather than a specific funding, are amortized straight-line over the commitment period. Income recognized this way is reported as service fee income, not interest income.

Credit Card Fees

Annual credit card fees get a modified treatment. The net amount of the card fee minus direct origination costs is amortized straight-line over the privilege period, which is the period during which the fee entitles the cardholder to use the card. When a significant annual fee is charged, the privilege period runs for the year that fee covers. When there is no significant fee, the privilege period defaults to one year. Straight-line amortization is required here rather than the interest method used for traditional loans.

How the Numbers Show Up on the Financials

Deferred net origination fees and costs are not presented as a separate asset or liability. They are embedded in the carrying amount of the loan on the balance sheet. A net deferred fee reduces the carrying value; a net deferred cost increases it. The unamortized balance is not classified as a deferred charge.3OCC. Bank Accounting Advisory Series

On the income statement, periodic amortization flows through interest income as a yield adjustment, not as a separate fee-income or cost-amortization line. That presentation reflects the economic reality that the origination fees and costs are inseparable from the interest the loan generates. The exception again is commitment fees on revolving arrangements, which are reported as service fee income because they compensate for credit availability rather than for a funded loan.