FAS 159 Fair Value Option: Election, Presentation, and Disclosures

The fair value option originally issued as FAS 159 and now codified in ASC Topic 825 lets an entity elect to measure eligible financial assets and liabilities at fair value, with changes running through earnings each period. The requirements and disclosures under the FAS 159 fair value option cover which instruments qualify, when and how the election is made, how FVO items appear on the balance sheet and income statement, and an extensive footnote package that includes methods, assumptions, credit-risk effects, and management’s rationale. The election is irrevocable for the life of each elected instrument, so the mechanics matter from day one.1ASC 825

Instruments Eligible for the Election

The FVO is available for most recognized financial assets and liabilities. That includes held-to-maturity and available-for-sale debt securities, equity-method investments, firm commitments that involve only financial instruments, and written loan commitments. Hybrid financial instruments containing an embedded derivative are also eligible, and electing fair value for the entire hybrid eliminates the need to bifurcate the embedded derivative from the host contract. Avoiding bifurcation is one of the most common practical reasons entities use the FVO.

The “involves only financial instruments” condition on firm commitments does real work. A commitment to deliver a nonfinancial item does not qualify under that provision, though written loan commitments have their own separate eligibility.

Items That Cannot Use the Fair Value Option

ASC 825-10-15-5 carves out categories that are ineligible regardless of intent:

  • Investments in subsidiaries the entity must consolidate, and interests in variable interest entities the entity must consolidate.
  • Employee benefit obligations, including pensions, other postretirement benefits, postemployment benefits, stock option and stock purchase plans, and other deferred compensation arrangements.
  • Financial assets and liabilities recognized under lease guidance. Guarantees of third-party lease obligations and contingent obligations from cancelled leases are not excluded.
  • Demand deposit liabilities of banks, savings and loan associations, credit unions, and similar depository institutions.
  • Financial instruments classified by the issuer as a component of shareholders’ equity, including temporary equity.

A separated host financial instrument resulting from bifurcation of an embedded nonfinancial derivative is also ineligible.2ASC 825-10-15-5

How and When the Election Is Made

The election can only occur on specific qualifying dates identified in ASC 825-10-25-4:

  • When the entity first recognizes the eligible item.
  • When the entity enters into an eligible firm commitment.
  • When financial assets previously reported at fair value through earnings under specialized guidance (such as investment company accounting) cease to qualify for that treatment.
  • When an investment becomes subject to equity-method accounting.
  • When an event requires fair value remeasurement but would not otherwise require ongoing fair value measurement, including business combinations, consolidation or deconsolidation of a subsidiary or VIE, and significant modifications of debt.

The election is instrument-by-instrument. Two identical loans in a portfolio can be treated differently. But the election covers the entire instrument; a single contract cannot be split into pieces with fair value applied to only part.3ASC 825-10-25-4

Concurrent Documentation

The election must be supported by concurrent documentation or a preexisting written policy for automatic election. Concurrent means at the moment the instrument is acquired, issued, or subject to a remeasurement event. Documentation created after the fact does not cure the omission, and the record must remove any ambiguity that the entity intended fair value measurement for that specific instrument.

The Election Is Irrevocable

Once made, the election stays in place for the life of the instrument unless a new election date occurs. There is no mechanism to reverse it because performance disappointed or because management reconsidered its reporting strategy. That permanence is why the concurrent documentation requirement is not a formality.

Balance Sheet Presentation

ASC 825-10-45-1B requires FVO items to be presented so readers can distinguish them from similar items measured on a different basis. Two approaches are allowed:

  • Combine FVO and non-FVO amounts in the same line item and parenthetically disclose the fair value portion.
  • Show FVO and non-FVO carrying amounts on separate lines.

The same presentation rules apply to hybrid financial instruments measured at fair value under ASC 815-15. Whichever approach the entity uses, a reader should be able to tell how much of any line is measured at fair value under the FVO.4ASC 825-10-45-1B

Income Statement Treatment

All fair value changes on FVO items flow through earnings each period. Unrealized gains and losses from remeasurement hit the income statement directly, which is the substantive difference from available-for-sale treatment, where unrealized changes bypass earnings and sit in other comprehensive income until realized.

Own Credit Risk on Financial Liabilities

ASC 825-10-45-4 requires the total fair value change on an FVO liability to be split. The portion attributable to changes in the instrument-specific credit risk goes to other comprehensive income. The remainder, driven by things like benchmark interest rate movements, flows through net income. The entity must apply a consistent method for identifying the credit-risk portion from period to period and disclose that method.

The credit-risk amounts accumulated in AOCI are not permanently excluded from earnings. They reclassify into earnings either over the life of the instrument or when the liability is settled, whichever comes first. The OCI treatment is timing, not exclusion.5ASC 825-10-45-4

Interest and Dividends

Interest and dividends on FVO instruments belong in the appropriate income statement line items. The standard does not prescribe a measurement method; entities typically use the contractual rate or the effective interest method. The chosen approach must be applied consistently and disclosed, along with the line where the amounts appear.

Up-Front Costs and Fees

When fair value is elected, transaction costs such as debt issuance costs, origination costs, and origination fees are not capitalized into the initial measurement. Costs are expensed as incurred and fees are recognized in earnings when received. The deferral and amortization rules under ASC 310-20 do not apply to instruments carried at fair value through earnings. Loan systems built around deferring origination fees over the life of the loan need to be adjusted, because the entire fee lands in earnings on day one.6ASC 310-20

Footnote Disclosures

The disclosure package is where the FVO creates the most ongoing work. ASC 825-10-50-28 through 50-31 organize the requirements across several categories, all aimed at letting readers compare entities that elect fair value with those that do not.7ASC 825-10-50-28 through 50-31

Balance Sheet

For each balance sheet line that contains FVO items, disclose the carrying amount at fair value and give readers enough information to tie the line to the broader fair value disclosures. Where the entity elected fair value for only some eligible items within a group of similar instruments, explain which were elected, which were not, and why. Disclose the aggregate carrying amount of non-eligible items in each line as well.

Income Statement

For each period presented, disclose the gains and losses from fair value changes included in earnings, broken out by balance sheet line, and identify the specific income statement line where those amounts appear. Describe how interest and dividends are measured and where they show up.

Loans and Long-Term Receivables Held as Assets

For loans and long-term receivables under the FVO, disclose the difference between aggregate fair value and aggregate unpaid principal balance. For loans 90 days or more past due, separately report aggregate fair value and the gap between that fair value and unpaid principal. The same applies to loans in nonaccrual status if the entity’s policy is to recognize interest income separately from other fair value changes.

Methods, Assumptions, and Credit Risk

For annual periods, disclose the methods and significant assumptions used to estimate fair value for FVO instruments, and categorize each measurement within the ASC 820 fair value hierarchy: Level 1 (quoted prices in active markets), Level 2 (observable inputs other than quoted prices), or Level 3 (unobservable inputs).8ASC 820

For financial liabilities, disclose the fair value change attributable to instrument-specific credit risk during the period, the cumulative amount, and how those amounts were determined. For loans and receivables held as assets, disclose the estimated gains or losses attributable to changes in instrument-specific credit risk and the method used.

Reasons for Electing

Explain, for each class of instrument, why the FVO was elected. Auditors and regulators expect a substantive economic rationale: reducing accounting mismatch between related assets and liabilities, aligning with risk management practices, or simplifying accounting for complex instruments. Boilerplate language about better reflecting economic reality without instrument-specific context tends to draw questions.

Level 3 Measurement Issues

Many FVO loans and structured instruments end up in Level 3 because the entity’s own projected cash flows are significant to the fair value estimate, even where components of the model use observable data such as benchmark interest rate curves. The measurement objective does not change: it is still an exit price from the perspective of a market participant, with appropriate risk adjustments. The entity may use its own data, such as projected cash flows or earnings forecasts, but must adjust that data if reasonably available information suggests market participants would use different assumptions.

There is no blanket exemption for FVO instruments from the requirement to disclose quantitative information about significant unobservable inputs used in Level 3 measurements. Entities are not required to create quantitative data they did not develop as part of their valuation process. Using a third-party pricing service without adjustment does not force an entity to reverse-engineer the service’s inputs. But if the entity built its own discounted cash flow model with assumptions about default rates and prepayment speeds, those inputs must be disclosed. The line is between creating new information solely for disclosure and disclosing information already developed.

  • 1
    ASC 825
  • 2
    ASC 825-10-15-5
  • 3
    ASC 825-10-25-4
  • 4
    ASC 825-10-45-1B
  • 5
    ASC 825-10-45-4
  • 6
    ASC 310-20
  • 7
    ASC 825-10-50-28 through 50-31
  • 8
    ASC 820