Farhy v. Commissioner is the federal tax case that decided how the IRS can collect penalties from people who fail to file Form 5471 and other international information returns. In April 2023, the U.S. Tax Court held that the IRS had no authority to assess these Section 6038(b) penalties administratively. In May 2024, the D.C. Circuit reversed, restoring the agency’s long-standing practice of assessing and collecting the penalties directly. For anyone with unfiled foreign business filings, the practical result is that the IRS can move straight to liens and levies, and your only route to a judge is to pay first and sue for a refund.
What the Case Was About
Alon Farhy, a U.S. citizen, owned two Belize corporations and was required to file Form 5471 for each of them for tax years 2003 through 2010. He didn’t. The IRS imposed the initial $10,000 penalty per unfiled form, added continuation penalties after he ignored notices, and eventually issued a notice of intent to levy his property when the balance—by then in the hundreds of thousands—went unpaid.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 US Code 6038 – Information Reporting With Respect to Certain Foreign Corporations and Partnerships
Farhy conceded he owed the penalties. What he challenged was the process. His argument: the IRS never had authority to assess these penalties on its own books in the first place, so the levy couldn’t stand.
Why the Collection Route Matters
Federal tax law gives the IRS two very different ways to collect money, and the difference is the whole fight.
The first is the deficiency process. The IRS sends a formal notice of deficiency by certified mail, and you can petition the U.S. Tax Court to contest the amount before paying anything.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 US Code 6212 – Notice of Deficiency Filing fees are low. You can often represent yourself.
The second is direct assessment. The IRS records the penalty, sends a bill, and if you don’t pay it can proceed with liens, levies, and wage garnishment. Your only way to challenge the amount in court is to pay in full and then sue for a refund in federal district court or the Court of Federal Claims.3Internal Revenue Service. 2024 Purple Book – Provide That Assessable Penalties Are Subject to Deficiency Procedures Those courts have higher fees, tougher rules, and generally require a lawyer. When penalties run into six figures, the pay-first requirement alone can put judicial review out of reach.
Section 6038(b) doesn’t say which route applies. It sets a $10,000 initial penalty per unfiled form, adds up to $50,000 in continuation penalties after a 90-day IRS notice, and never uses the word “assess.”1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 US Code 6038 – Information Reporting With Respect to Certain Foreign Corporations and Partnerships Farhy said that silence meant the IRS had to go through deficiency procedures, or refer the case to the Department of Justice for a civil suit. The IRS said its assessment authority under Section 6201 covers the penalties by default.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 US Code 6201 – Assessment Authority
The Tax Court Ruling
In April 2023, the Tax Court read the statute strictly and ruled for Farhy. Congress had explicitly labeled many other penalties throughout the code as assessable. It hadn’t done that for Section 6038(b). The court treated that silence as the absence of authority the IRS was claiming, and concluded the agency could only collect these penalties by referring them to DOJ for a civil suit.5Justia. Farhy v. Cmsnr. IRS
The practical effect was dramatic. DOJ litigation is slow and resource-heavy, and the government rarely pursues individual penalty cases that way. Taxpayers who had already paid Section 6038(b) penalties started looking at refund claims.
The D.C. Circuit Reversal
The IRS appealed, and in May 2024 the D.C. Circuit reversed. The appellate court looked at the text, structure, and history of Section 6038 together rather than asking only whether the word “assess” appeared. Fixed dollar penalties triggered by specific failures, with no connection to any tax deficiency, fit the profile of an assessable penalty. And the IRS had been assessing these penalties for more than 40 years without Congress correcting the practice.5Justia. Farhy v. Cmsnr. IRS
Within the D.C. Circuit, that ruling is binding. The IRS is applying it nationwide as confirmation of the practice it never stopped. If you fail to file Form 5471, you should expect direct collection action, and no chance to argue the penalty in Tax Court before paying.
Other Forms in the Same Position
Section 6038(b) isn’t the only international reporting penalty with this structure. Fixed-dollar penalties for failing to file Form 5472 (foreign-owned U.S. corporations), Form 8865 (foreign partnerships), and Form 8938 (foreign financial assets) share the same statutory design. Form 5472 penalties start at $25,000 per failure with no statutory cap on continuation charges.6Internal Revenue Service. International Information Reporting Penalties
Under the D.C. Circuit’s reasoning, all of these are likely assessable. Under the Tax Court’s, none of them are. The IRS is treating them all as assessable in the meantime.
The 90-Day Trap for Reasonable Cause
If you have unfiled forms, one detail matters more than most taxpayers realize. Treasury regulations let you avoid the initial $10,000 penalty by showing reasonable cause—a legitimate reason for the failure, such as bad advice from a tax professional or a genuine misunderstanding of the rule.
The reasonable cause defense stops working once the IRS sends its notice and the 90-day compliance clock expires. After that, the additional $10,000-per-month continuation penalties accrue up to the $50,000 cap regardless of your reasons.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 US Code 6038 – Information Reporting With Respect to Certain Foreign Corporations and Partnerships Reasonable cause won’t cut them. If you receive an IRS notice about a missing international return, the response window is short and the cost of missing it is fixed.
Why the Statute of Limitations Never Closes
The normal three-year limit on IRS assessments doesn’t help you with unfiled international information returns. Under IRC Section 6501(c)(8), the clock doesn’t start until the IRS actually receives the required information. If you never file Form 5471, the IRS can assess the penalty—and any related tax liability—at any point in the future, with no expiration.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 US Code 6501 – Limitations on Assessment and Collection
A filing gap from 15 years ago is still live. The exposure grows with each year that passes rather than shrinking.
If You Have Unfiled Returns
Two IRS programs can limit your exposure, but only if you come forward before the IRS contacts you.
The Delinquent International Information Return Submission Procedures let you file the missing forms with amended returns and a reasonable cause statement. The IRS may still assess penalties, and you may need to argue reasonable cause in response to a penalty notice, but voluntary submission puts you in a materially better position than waiting.8Internal Revenue Service. Delinquent International Information Return Submission Procedures
The Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures are for taxpayers whose failure to file was non-willful—the product of negligence, mistake, or a good-faith misunderstanding rather than a deliberate choice to ignore the rules. Terms are more favorable, but you aren’t eligible once the IRS has opened a civil examination or criminal investigation.9Internal Revenue Service. Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures
Neither guarantees penalty-free treatment. Both close the moment the IRS initiates contact.
Where the Law Goes Next
The Tax Court hasn’t accepted the D.C. Circuit’s reasoning. In Mukhi v. Commissioner, the court reconsidered its position in light of the appellate reversal and reaffirmed its original conclusion that the IRS lacks authority to assess Section 6038(b) penalties.10United States Tax Court. Mukhi v. Commissioner
Mukhi is appealable to the Eighth Circuit, which hasn’t ruled on this question.10United States Tax Court. Mukhi v. Commissioner If the Eighth Circuit disagrees with the D.C. Circuit, the resulting circuit split is exactly the kind of conflict the Supreme Court steps in to resolve. Until then, the IRS’s collection practice stands, and the safest assumption for any taxpayer with foreign reporting gaps is that a penalty, once assessed, will be collected the hard way.