The experience modification rate calculation divides your company’s actual workers’ compensation losses over a set three-year window by the losses that would be expected for a business of your size and industry classification, then applies stabilizing adjustments so a single bad claim doesn’t distort the result. The output is a multiplier: 1.0 means your losses match the industry average, below 1.0 means you pay less than the manual premium, above 1.0 means you pay more. On a $50,000 base premium, the gap between a 0.85 and a 1.15 mod is $15,000 a year, which is why the mechanics of the number are worth understanding in detail.
What Goes Into the Formula
Two sides sit on the scale: actual losses from your claims and expected losses built from your payroll. Expected losses come from applying industry-specific loss rates to every $100 of payroll, broken out by job classification code. A clerical office worker (class code 8810) carries a much lower expected loss rate than a residential carpenter (class code 5645) because the injury risk is different.1National Council on Compensation Insurance. ABCs of Experience Rating When a company employs people in multiple classifications, each group’s payroll is multiplied by its own rate and the totals are combined.
This is why accurate payroll reporting matters so much. Misclassified employees or wrong payroll figures distort the expected-loss side of the equation and produce an inaccurate mod that can follow you for years. Insurance carriers submit payroll data along with detailed claim cost reports (Unit Statistical Reports) to the rating bureau, which runs the final math.1National Council on Compensation Insurance. ABCs of Experience Rating
Each classification code also carries a D-ratio, or discount ratio, representing the share of expected losses that fall into the primary category (explained below). The rating bureau multiplies your expected losses by the D-ratio to get expected primary losses; the remainder is expected excess losses.1National Council on Compensation Insurance. ABCs of Experience Rating A classification with many small claims has a higher D-ratio than one where injuries are rare but costly when they happen.
In most states, the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) handles the calculation. California, New York, Pennsylvania, Delaware, and New Jersey run their own independent rating bureaus with different formulas, though the core concept is the same everywhere.
How Each Claim Enters the Math: The Split Point
The formula does not treat every dollar of a claim equally. Each claim is divided at a threshold called the split point. The portion below the split point is the primary loss. The portion above it is the excess loss. Primary losses carry far more weight in the formula because they reflect how often injuries happen; excess losses reflect how expensive a single injury got.1National Council on Compensation Insurance. ABCs of Experience Rating
The split point was historically a single countrywide figure of $18,500, but NCCI is transitioning to state-specific split points that reflect each state’s actual claim cost levels. Under that change, a state with higher-than-average claim severity might use a split point around $25,000, while a lower-cost state might use $15,000.2National Council on Compensation Insurance. Experience Rating Plan Methodology Update FAQs Check with your state’s rating bureau for the figure that applies to your policy.
Once each claim is split, the mod formula divides your adjusted actual losses by your adjusted expected losses. Both sides include a stabilizing value, which combines expected excess losses with a ballast factor. The ballast acts as an anchor, limiting how much any single large claim can swing the final number.
Employer size changes how the two sides are weighted. Smaller employers get a lower weighting on excess losses, so their mods are driven almost entirely by claim frequency rather than claim size. Larger employers see excess losses weighted more heavily because their bigger payroll base provides enough data for severity to be statistically meaningful.1National Council on Compensation Insurance. ABCs of Experience Rating
The Medical-Only Discount
Claims where an injured worker receives medical treatment but no lost-time indemnity payments get a built-in break in the calculation. Most states reduce the impact of these medical-only claims by 70%, meaning only 30% of the primary and excess portions enter the formula.1National Council on Compensation Insurance. ABCs of Experience Rating The discount exists because a claim that doesn’t produce missed work is treated as a less serious indicator of workplace risk.
The practical consequence is direct: if an injured employee can stay on the job in modified duty rather than going out on disability, the claim may be reported as medical-only and get the 70% reduction. The same injury handled differently can enter the mod formula at full value or at 30% of value.
Why Frequency Hurts More Than Severity
Because primary losses sit below the split point and carry heavier weight, multiple small claims damage your mod more than a single expensive one. A company with eight separate $2,000 claims will see a worse mod than a company with one $16,000 claim, even though the total dollar amount is the same. Each of the eight claims contributes its full amount as primary losses (assuming each stays under the split point). The single large claim contributes only its primary portion, with the excess heavily discounted.
The reasoning behind the design: a pattern of frequent injuries signals a systemic hazard likely to keep producing claims. A single severe injury is more likely to be an isolated event.
Open Claims, Reserves, and Valuation Dates
The mod calculation does not wait for claims to close. Open claims are valued at what has been paid plus what the carrier has set aside in reserves for future costs. If a claims adjuster estimates that an open knee injury will ultimately cost $45,000 and sets reserves at that level, the full $45,000 enters your mod calculation, not just the $12,000 paid so far.
Reserves on open claims are one of the most common and least visible drivers of a high mod. If a carrier sets reserves high and does not adjust them down as a claim resolves, you pay premium surcharges on projected costs that may never materialize.
The data feeding the formula comes from a specific window called the experience period, usually the three oldest policy years out of the most recent four. The gap between that window and your current policy year exists because the most recent year’s claims have not had time to develop reliable cost estimates.1National Council on Compensation Insurance. ABCs of Experience Rating
Within the experience period, claim data is frozen at specific valuation dates. The first valuation happens 18 months after the policy effective date, with subsequent valuations every 12 months after that.3National Council on Compensation Insurance. Introduction to Unit Reporting 2026 Whatever the claim costs and reserves show on the valuation date is what enters the formula, regardless of what happens afterward. The timing of settlements and reserve adjustments relative to those dates meaningfully affects the result.
How the Finished Mod Changes Your Premium
The mod is a straight multiplier on the manual premium. The basic calculation: payroll divided by 100, multiplied by the classification rate, multiplied by the experience mod. A business with a 0.80 mod pays 20% less than the manual rate. A business with a 1.25 pays 25% more.
In dollars: if your manual premium works out to $40,000 and your mod is 0.85, you pay $34,000. If the mod climbs to 1.15, you pay $46,000. That $12,000 gap comes from the same payroll and the same classification codes; the only variable is loss history. The mod recalculates every year, so a bad claim year can push premiums up for the three-plus years that data stays in the experience period.
Who Actually Gets a Mod
Not every employer has one. Experience rating is mandatory for businesses that meet their state’s minimum premium threshold; businesses below that threshold pay the standard manual rate with no adjustment.1National Council on Compensation Insurance. ABCs of Experience Rating The dollar amount varies by state. To qualify, you generally need to meet the premium threshold either within the most recent 24 months of payroll or on average across the full experience period.
New businesses that haven’t operated long enough to accumulate the required data receive a unity mod of 1.0 by default, which means you pay exactly the manual rate until enough history exists for a real calculation.1National Council on Compensation Insurance. ABCs of Experience Rating
Checking the Calculation on Your Worksheet
The Experience Rating Worksheet is the detailed document showing every input in your mod: each claim, its primary and excess portions, the payroll figures, classification codes, expected losses, D-ratio, and the final math.4National Council on Compensation Insurance. Experience Rating Worksheet Overview In NCCI states, NCCI issues the worksheet. In independent-bureau states, the state rating organization issues it.
Most employers can access the worksheet through NCCI’s online portal using their federal employer identification number, or by requesting it through their agent or broker. Worksheets are typically issued 60 to 90 days before policy renewal, which leaves time to identify and dispute errors before the mod takes effect.
Errors worth looking for: claims listed as open that have actually been closed, claims attributed to your company that belong to a different entity, inflated reserves on open claims, and payroll amounts that don’t match your audited records. The rating bureau is only as accurate as the data carriers submit, and discrepancies reported promptly can produce a revised mod and an immediate premium reduction.