An Exchange for Related Positions, or EFRP, is a privately negotiated trade in which one party swaps a futures contract for a connected position in a physical commodity, an OTC swap, or an OTC option. The two sides agree on terms off the public order book, but the futures leg is submitted for clearing through the exchange and remains subject to the same regulatory rules that govern on-screen trades.1CME Group. Exchange for Related Positions (EFRPs) Commercial firms use EFRPs to hedge price risk, manage physical delivery, or move between standardized futures and customized private agreements without the slippage of unwinding one position and rebuilding another in the open market.
How the Trade Is Structured
Every EFRP has two legs that execute at the same time: a futures leg and a related position leg. The related position has to involve the commodity underlying the futures contract or a product with a reasonable degree of price correlation to it.2CME Group. Exchange for Related Positions (EFRP) Overview and Transaction Types You can exchange a crude oil futures contract against physical barrels, a related OTC swap on crude, or an OTC crude option. You cannot exchange it against an unrelated equity.
The quantity on the related position has to be approximately equivalent to the quantity covered by the futures contracts.2CME Group. Exchange for Related Positions (EFRP) Overview and Transaction Types Lopsided sizes draw auditor attention as potentially non-competitive. The futures leg can be priced at any commercially reasonable level the parties agree on, as long as it meets the product’s minimum tick increment, though prices far from the prevailing market invite extra scrutiny.3CME Group. Market Regulation Advisory Notice – Exchange for Related Positions
The accounts on each side have to be independently controlled. Two separate legal entities with different beneficial owners is the clean case, but the rules are more flexible than that. Accounts inside the same legal entity can qualify if they operate as genuinely separate business units with independent decision-making, and accounts owned by different entities that share beneficial ownership are allowed as long as they are independently controlled.2CME Group. Exchange for Related Positions (EFRP) Overview and Transaction Types If both sides answer to the same decision-maker, or if neither party takes on real market risk, the trade fails the bona fide test.
One detail trips up newcomers: the buyer of the futures leg must be the seller of the related position, and the seller of the futures leg must be the buyer of the related position.2CME Group. Exchange for Related Positions (EFRP) Overview and Transaction Types That inversion is what makes the exchange work. Each side shifts exposure from one instrument to the other instead of doubling up in the same direction.
The Four Types of EFRP
EFRPs come in four flavors, each defined by what sits on the related-position side. The structural rules above apply to all of them.
Exchange for Physical (EFP)
The traditional variant. One party trades a futures position against delivery or receipt of the actual physical commodity: barrels of crude, bushels of corn, ounces of gold. Both sides agree on a price reflecting the physical goods while simultaneously establishing or liquidating their futures obligations.1CME Group. Exchange for Related Positions (EFRPs) EFPs are the workhorse of commercial hedging because they let a firm move from a paper hedge into actual ownership of raw materials in one coordinated step.
Exchange for Risk (EFR)
An EFR swaps a futures position for an OTC swap or other OTC derivative in the same or a related instrument.1CME Group. Exchange for Related Positions (EFRPs) No physical goods move. Interest rate desks are heavy users, shifting between Treasury futures and OTC instruments like interest rate swaps, forward rate agreements, or agency securities.3CME Group. Market Regulation Advisory Notice – Exchange for Related Positions The simultaneous execution keeps either party from carrying unintended directional exposure during the transition.
Exchange for Swap (EFS)
An EFS replaces a standardized futures position with a privately negotiated swap. The mechanics look like an EFR, but the related position is specifically a swap. Banks and large corporations use EFS trades when they need custom maturity dates, payment frequencies, or notional structures that listed contracts do not offer.
Exchange of Option for Option (EOO)
The fourth type pairs an exchange-listed option with a corresponding OTC option. Nothing else qualifies as the related position in an EOO. For quantity equivalence, the net delta-adjusted quantity of the OTC option components must be approximately equivalent to the delta-adjusted quantity of the exchange-listed option.4CME Group. MRAN RA1707-5 – Exchange for Related Positions Parties to EFR and EOO transactions must also comply with applicable CFTC reporting requirements under Parts 43 and 45 of Commission regulations.
What Is Not Allowed
Federal law prohibits wash sales, accommodation trades, and fictitious transactions in commodity futures markets.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 7 USC 6c – Prohibited Transactions An EFRP with no genuine risk transfer between independently controlled accounts is a textbook violation. If one decision-maker effectively controls both sides, or if the related position never actually moves, the trade is fictitious no matter how the paperwork reads.
Exchanges also ban “transitory” EFRPs. A transitory EFRP is one where execution is contingent on a second EFRP or related-position transaction between the same parties, and the related positions offset each other without exposing either side to material market risk. The classic example: two parties execute equal and opposite EFRPs on two different exchanges listing economically equivalent futures products, and the related-position legs cancel out. A short gap between legs is a red flag, but the real test is whether each transaction stands on its own as an independent trade carrying meaningful risk.3CME Group. Market Regulation Advisory Notice – Exchange for Related Positions An EFRP with multiple exchange components is fine as long as the related-position legs do not offset and each carries real exposure.
Documentation and Reporting
Every EFRP has to be backed by records proving both legs were real commercial transactions. Before submitting the trade, you need the exact quantity of futures contracts, the volume and terms of the related position, the agreed price for each leg, and the clearing members responsible for processing it. Parties must keep order tickets, records of payments between the parties, and all documentation customarily generated for the type of instrument involved.3CME Group. Market Regulation Advisory Notice – Exchange for Related Positions
What counts as proof depends on the transaction type. For physical trades, warehouse receipts, bills of lading, or electronic title transfers show that goods actually moved. For EFRs and EOOs tied to OTC derivatives, the parties keep signed contracts, cash confirmations, and documentation containing all relevant terms and counterparty information.3CME Group. Market Regulation Advisory Notice – Exchange for Related Positions Proof of payment evidencing settlement is required where applicable. The clearing firm carrying the account is responsible for obtaining these records from its client and producing them to the exchange’s Market Regulation Department on request. Under federal recordkeeping rules, the documents have to be retained for at least five years from creation.6eCFR. 17 CFR Part 1 – Recordkeeping
Once agreed, the trade is entered into an approved electronic platform. CME ClearPort and CME Direct are the primary systems for CME Group products, and the details flow from the participants or their clearing firms to the clearinghouse, provided the transaction stays within pre-established credit limits.1CME Group. Exchange for Related Positions (EFRPs) Whoever enters the data must flag the trade as an EFRP so the exchange applies the right oversight and fee treatment for off-exchange executions.
Timing matters. EFRP transactions must be submitted as soon as possible after terms are finalized, and absent extenuating circumstances, no later than the end of the business day on which the trade was executed.3CME Group. Market Regulation Advisory Notice – Exchange for Related Positions Other exchanges may use tighter windows, so check the reporting deadline for your product before execution. Late submissions can draw disciplinary action. After submission, the exchange issues a unique trade identification number that becomes the permanent reference for clearing records and any later audit.
If the submission contains an error, the parties must notify the exchange immediately. The exchange then decides whether to cancel the transaction or accept a corrected report. Any correction has to be submitted by the close of business on the business day following the original submission.7Commodity Futures Trading Commission. CME/CBOT/NYMEX/COMEX Rule Filing – Exchange for Related Positions (EFRP) Miss that window and the original trade locks in or additional scrutiny kicks in.
Clearing Member Responsibilities
Clearing members carry an obligation beyond simply processing the trade. They have to exercise due diligence on the bona fide nature of every EFRP they submit for a customer, and in certain cases the clearinghouse must approve the transaction in advance before it can be cleared.1CME Group. Exchange for Related Positions (EFRPs) That means reviewing whether the related position is a qualifying instrument, whether account ownership is structured properly, and whether the quantities are approximately equivalent, before submitting. A clearing member that rubber-stamps a fictitious EFRP faces its own disciplinary exposure separate from whatever happens to the trading counterparties.
Penalties for EFRP Violations
Consequences for non-bona fide EFRPs come from two directions. Exchanges impose their own disciplinary fines and sanctions through internal proceedings, with amounts that vary by exchange, product, and severity. The CFTC, acting under the Commodity Exchange Act, can pursue civil monetary penalties that run larger. For violations that do not involve market manipulation, the maximum reaches $227,220 per violation. For manipulation or attempted manipulation, the ceiling rises to $1,487,712 per violation.8Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Inflation Adjusted Civil Monetary Penalties The Commission can also pursue penalties equal to triple the respondent’s monetary gain from the violation, whichever amount is greater. Cease-and-desist orders, trading bans, and registration revocations are also on the table.
Tax Treatment
Regulated futures contracts are Section 1256 contracts under the Internal Revenue Code, and any gain or loss is treated as 60 percent long-term and 40 percent short-term capital gain or loss regardless of the actual holding period. The mark-to-market rules apply when a futures position is terminated by delivery, exercise, offset, or any other closing event, so an EFRP that closes out the futures leg triggers recognition at that point.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 US Code 1256 – Section 1256 Contracts Marked to Market
The related-position leg follows its own rules. A physical commodity received through an EFP takes a cost basis equal to the agreed price, and gains or losses are taxed when the commodity is sold. OTC swaps and derivatives received through an EFR or EFS fall under whatever tax provisions apply to those specific instruments. For firms that use EFRPs as part of an integrated hedging program tied to inventory, the IRS may characterize the gain or loss as ordinary income rather than capital gain, because hedging transactions connected to a business’s inventory system produce ordinary results.10Internal Revenue Service. Letter Ruling 202140016 The characterization of the EFRP within the broader hedging strategy often matters more than the mechanics of the individual trade.