The equity method vs. the fair value method comes down to how much sway you hold over the company you’ve invested in. A passive investor, generally holding less than 20 percent of the voting stock, uses the fair value method and reports the investment at its current market price, recognizing income from dividends and price changes. An investor with significant influence, generally 20 percent or more, uses the equity method and reports its proportionate share of the investee’s actual profits and losses. The choice isn’t discretionary. It’s driven by influence.
What Determines Which Method Applies
Under GAAP, the dividing line is whether the investor can exercise significant influence over the investee’s operating and financial decisions. A stake of 20 percent or more in the voting stock creates a rebuttable presumption that significant influence exists, and the equity method applies. A stake below 20 percent creates the opposite presumption, and the fair value method applies.1Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Deloitte’s Roadmap: Equity Method Investments and Joint Ventures – 3.2 General Presumption
The percentages are guidelines, not bright lines. The real test is actual influence, and qualitative factors can push the answer either way:
- A seat on the investee’s board of directors.
- Participation in the investee’s operating or financial policy decisions.
- Material transactions between the two companies.
- Shared managers, or technical dependency on the investor’s personnel.
- A large stake relative to otherwise dispersed shareholders, even if below 20 percent.
The factors can also work in reverse. An investor holding 25 percent might show that another party effectively blocks any real influence, making the equity method inappropriate.2Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Deloitte’s Roadmap: Equity Method Investments and Joint Ventures – 3.3 Other Indicators of Significant Influence
One boundary matters at the top end. Once ownership crosses above 50 percent of the voting stock, the analysis changes entirely. A majority stake generally establishes control, and the investee’s financial statements must be fully consolidated into the investor’s own reporting. Neither the fair value method nor the equity method applies at that point.3Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Roadmap: Consolidation – D.1 General Consolidation Principles
How the Fair Value Method Works
A passive investment is recorded under ASC 321. The investor books it initially at cost, including the purchase price and any direct transaction costs. After that, the carrying value tracks whatever the market says the investment is worth.
For equity securities with a readily determinable fair value, meaning essentially anything traded on a public exchange, changes in fair value flow directly through net income each reporting period. This was a substantive shift from the older framework under ASC 320, which had allowed available-for-sale equity securities to park unrealized gains and losses in other comprehensive income. That classification was eliminated for equity securities by ASU 2016-01, so today all publicly traded equity investments held under the fair value method hit the income statement immediately when their price moves.4FASB. ASU 2020-01 Investments-Equity Securities (Topic 321)
The practical result is earnings volatility. A strong quarter in the market inflates reported income; a downturn deflates it. The investor’s profitability swings with market sentiment rather than reflecting the investee’s underlying operations. Dividends received are recognized as income when received.
Not every equity investment trades publicly. For securities without a readily determinable fair value, the investor can use the measurement alternative: carry the investment at cost, reduced by any impairment, and adjust it up or down only when an observable transaction in the same or a similar security of that issuer provides a new data point.5Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Roadmap: Foreign Currency Transactions and Translations – 4.4 Investments in Debt and Equity Securities
How the Equity Method Works
The equity method treats the investment account as a running scorecard of the investor’s proportionate claim on the investee’s net assets. It starts at cost, the same as the fair value method. Everything after that works differently.
When the investee reports net income, the investor increases the carrying value of the investment by its ownership percentage of that income and records the same amount as equity method income on its own income statement. When the investee reports a loss, the process reverses. The carrying value drops, and the investor records its share as a loss. Recognition happens when the investee reports its results, not when dividends are declared.6Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Deloitte’s Roadmap: Equity Method Investments and Joint Ventures – 5.1 Equity Method Earnings and Losses
Take a 30 percent investor in a company reporting $100,000 of net income. The investor increases its investment account by $30,000 and reports $30,000 in equity method income. Reported profitability tracks the investee’s actual operating performance rather than the market’s mood.
Dividends Are Treated Differently
This is one of the sharpest breaks between the two methods. Under the fair value method, a dividend is income. Under the equity method, a dividend is a return of capital. The investee already increased the investor’s carrying value when it earned the money, so distributing cash simply converts part of that claim from retained earnings into cash in the investor’s pocket. The investor reduces the investment account by its share of the dividend and recognizes no income from the distribution itself.6Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Deloitte’s Roadmap: Equity Method Investments and Joint Ventures – 5.1 Equity Method Earnings and Losses
What the Financial Statements Look Like Under Each Method
The balance sheet tells two different stories depending on which method applies. A fair value investment fluctuates with the market. It might double or halve based on investor sentiment, sector rotation, or macroeconomic news that has nothing to do with the investee’s actual business. An equity method investment moves with the investee’s retained earnings, producing a smoother trajectory tied to operational results rather than trading activity.
The income statement divergence is just as stark. Under the fair value method, income from the investment consists of dividends received and unrealized gains or losses from price movements. A company can report a large investment gain simply because the market rallied, even if the investee lost money operationally. Under the equity method, income recognition tracks the investee’s actual earnings. A bad year at the investee flows straight into the investor’s income statement regardless of what the stock price did.
The dividend treatment alone can produce counterintuitive results. Consider an investee that reports $5 million in losses but still pays a dividend from prior-year cash. Under the fair value method, that dividend is income on the investor’s books. Under the equity method, the investor first reduces its investment account for its share of the $5 million loss, reducing reported income, and then reduces the account again for the dividend, with no income effect. The two methods produce opposite signals from identical underlying facts. Anyone reading the statements needs to know which method is in play before drawing conclusions about what the reported investment income really represents.
The Fair Value Option
An investor that would otherwise apply the equity method can elect the fair value option under ASC 825 at the time the investment first qualifies for equity method accounting. Under this election, the investment is carried at fair value each reporting period with all changes flowing through earnings, effectively the same measurement as a passive investment, without giving up the underlying relationship. The election is irrevocable once made and applies to the entire investment. Venture capital funds and other entities that prefer mark-to-market reporting regardless of their influence over portfolio companies often use it.7Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Roadmap: Equity Method Investees SEC Reporting – 1.7 Equity Method Investments Eligible for Fair Value Option
Switching Methods When Ownership Changes
Ownership levels shift, and the accounting has to follow. When an investor’s stake crosses above the significant-influence threshold, whether through buying more shares, the investee repurchasing its own stock, or another transaction, the investor adopts the equity method going forward. The previously held investment is first remeasured at fair value, or adjusted per the measurement alternative, immediately before the switch. The investor then adds the cost of the new shares to that remeasured basis and begins tracking its proportionate share of the investee’s income and losses from the transition date.8Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Deloitte’s Roadmap: Equity Method Investments and Joint Ventures – 5.6 Change in Level of Ownership or Degree of Influence
The reverse move happens when the investor sells shares, the investee issues new stock to others, or another event dilutes influence below the threshold. The investor stops accruing its share of the investee’s earnings and losses as of the date influence is lost. Previously recognized equity method adjustments remain embedded in the carrying value; the investment account is not restated retroactively. Going forward, the investment is accounted for under the fair value framework of ASC 321.8Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Deloitte’s Roadmap: Equity Method Investments and Joint Ventures – 5.6 Change in Level of Ownership or Degree of Influence