Donan Engineering Lawsuits: Gerdts Case and Court Rulings

Donan Engineering lawsuits generally fall into two categories: cases where a policyholder sues the firm directly for its role in a claim denial, and coverage disputes against an insurer where Donan’s forensic report is the central piece of evidence. The Louisville-based firm has largely survived direct claims, with courts holding that engineers hired by insurers are not liable to the policyholder for economic losses tied to a denial. But the underlying question — whether Donan’s “functional damage” framework matches what property policies actually cover — keeps returning in new cases, and juries hearing competing experts have sometimes rejected the firm’s conclusions.

Gerdts v. Donan Engineering: The Direct Lawsuit

The most fully litigated case naming Donan as a defendant is Richard Gerdts v. Donan Engineering Co., Inc. and Lance L. LeTellier, P.E., decided by the Iowa Court of Appeals on January 24, 2024. An April 2020 hailstorm hit Gerdts’s duplex in Bettendorf, Iowa. His insurer, The Property and Casualty Insurance Company of Hartford, hired Donan. LeTellier, a licensed civil engineer, inspected the roof and reported no hail damage, attributing what he saw to “man-made damage, balding, age-related deterioration, and nail pops.” Hartford denied the claim.

Gerdts sued Donan and LeTellier for negligence, tortious interference with his insurance contract, breach of contract as a third-party beneficiary, and conspiracy. His core theory: Donan effectively rewrote his policy by applying a restrictive engineering test for hail damage — a fracture affecting a shingle’s water-shedding ability, or an indentation punching through the shingle — rather than the broader “property damage” language in the policy itself. LeTellier acknowledged in a deposition that he had never seen the policy and had not been asked to apply its definitions.

The Iowa Court of Appeals affirmed dismissal of every claim:

  • The negligence claim was barred by the economic loss rule because Gerdts sought purely economic damages and no Iowa precedent exempts engineers from the rule.
  • On tortious interference, the court rejected the lower court’s holding that expert testimony was required, but affirmed on alternative grounds using the seven-factor test from Green v. Racing Ass’n of Central Iowa. Because Donan did not know the policy’s definitions and was fulfilling its own contract with Hartford, any interference was “a minor and incidental consequence.”
  • The third-party beneficiary claim failed because the Hartford–Donan scope of work — “inspect roof for cause of damage” and advise on “reparability vs replacement” — showed no intent to grant the policyholder any right to performance.

Presiding Judge Tabor issued a partial dissent on the tortious interference ruling. She wrote that a jury should have been allowed to weigh evidence that Donan engineers relied on the same restrictive definition “in numerous reports commissioned by an insurer deciding whether to deny coverage to Iowa homeowners,” and to decide using “common sense” whether that pattern reflected a motive to secure future insurer business.

The “Functional Damage” Dispute Behind the Cases

Nearly every Donan lawsuit turns on the same substantive disagreement. Donan and similar forensic firms distinguish between “functional” damage — a measurable reduction in a material’s performance, such as a shingle’s ability to shed water — and “cosmetic” damage, meaning dents or marks that do not affect performance. Policyholders argue that framework is narrower than what their policies say. Most property policies cover “direct physical loss or damage,” and courts have generally read that phrase to include any actual change that makes property unsatisfactory or requires repair.

There is no official engineering standard defining “cosmetic damage” or “functional damage,” even though some firms treat the terms as established. When an engineer’s report says “no functional damage,” adjusters sometimes read that as “no damage,” and the claim gets denied. National insurance bulletins have noted that most policies do not exclude cosmetic damage, so aesthetic-only losses are typically covered unless the policy specifically says otherwise.

Cases Where Courts Backed the Insurer

Donan reports have carried substantial weight when policyholders sue their insurers without their own expert.

In Olayemi Lawanson v. Nationwide Insurance Company of America (Civil No. 23-806-BAH, D. Md.), Nationwide retained Donan expert Austin Murray after an August 6, 2020 storm at the plaintiff’s home. Murray’s October 2021 report concluded the shingles were not wind-damaged but showed “localized creases and tears from inadvertent man-made damage.” A March 2024 report following a court-ordered re-inspection attributed granule loss to blisters, man-made damage, and age-related deterioration, and traced interior stains to rainwater entering through existing flashing gaps. Murray did acknowledge that some cosmetic dents on metal surfaces were caused by hail. On February 24, 2025, Judge Brendan Hurson granted summary judgment to Nationwide because the plaintiff had designated no expert to rebut Murray. Whether damage came from a covered storm or an excluded cause was “beyond the ken of the average layman,” the court held. The court also denied a motion to compel appraisal, finding that a dispute over whether damage is covered at all is not what appraisal panels resolve.

In Amarillo Hospitality Tenant, LLC v. Massachusetts Bay Insurance Co. (N.D. Tex. 2015), the operator of a Courtyard Marriott argued Donan was biased after two inspections concluded no hail damage. The court rejected the argument, holding that “evidence that an expert worked primarily for insurance companies and an insurer’s awareness of an adjuster’s particular view did not amount to bad faith.” A disagreement among experts about coverage would not support a bad faith judgment. The court granted summary judgment on the bad faith and non-contractual claims but let the breach of contract claim proceed.

In Norfolk Transmission & Muffler Service, Inc. v. Owners Insurance Co. (No. 8:16-CV-489, D. Neb.), the policyholder alleged Donan improperly applied a functional damage standard to ballasted and EPDM low-slope roofs and ignored evidence of active leaking. Owners Insurance denied the claim based on Donan’s report. On May 25, 2017, the court denied the insurer’s motion to bifurcate the bad faith and breach of contract claims, finding they were too intertwined to separate. Court docket records show the case terminated on September 27, 2018, with no publicly available filing specifying whether it settled or ended some other way.

When Donan’s Conclusions Have Been Rejected

The 11th Circuit affirmed a $9.28 million jury verdict against Rockhill Insurance Co. in a Hurricane Irma dispute brought by AM Grand Court Lakes LLC and AM 280 Sierra Drive LLC, owners of a senior living complex in Miami Lakes, Florida. Donan expert Timothy Philmon testified for Rockhill that Irma had damaged only one of the facility’s five roofs, with the rest showing “normal wear and tear.” The jury did not accept that position, and it also did not award the full $15.1 million policy limit the owners requested, landing in the middle. The 11th Circuit held the jury was entitled to weigh competing experts and assess damage building by building, and the verdict fell “within the range shown by the evidence at trial.”

The lesson for policyholders is straightforward: in the cases Donan’s clients have won, the policyholder had no competing expert. In the case Donan’s client lost, the policyholder did.

A Pending Case to Watch

Paddock Equity Investors, LLC sued Auto-Owners Insurance on September 29, 2025 in the Eastern District of Missouri over a $2 million coverage dispute. Auto-Owners’ initial estimate for storm damage came in at roughly $15,700, later revised to about $145,600. A December 2023 Donan report by engineer Todd Koenig found recent windstorms damaged approximately 150 shingles on south-facing slopes, two metal ridge caps, two hip-cap shingles, and 240 linear feet of gutter strips, but denied any hail damage to the roofing systems. The landlord’s own engineering firm put repair costs above $2 million. As of early October 2025, Auto-Owners had not responded to the complaint, and Donan was not named as a party.

What the Litigation Pattern Shows

Courts have generally treated Donan’s forensic reports as legitimate expert opinion and have declined to treat the firm’s insurer-paid relationship as evidence of bias on its own. Policyholders who sue Donan directly face steep barriers: the economic loss rule blocks negligence claims for pure financial harm, and the engineer’s contract runs to the insurer, not the insured. Policyholders who sue their insurer without their own qualified expert have repeatedly lost at summary judgment because there is nothing in the record to counter the Donan report. Where a policyholder has produced competing expert testimony and reached a jury, the outcome has looked different. Judge Tabor’s Gerdts dissent — arguing that jurors should be allowed to weigh whether a pattern of restrictive findings reflects an economic motive — captures the argument that keeps returning in these cases even as most rulings go the other way.